Mafia #47 "Ghost Hunters"

[[AC] RICKETS]

Rich would be my top suspect. However as I already said unless Ice is lynched and found to be a turned GH (which I'm not sure is a good idea) there's no way of telling if JL is a GH because the evils know lucky's role too.

OK. So JL says he is a GH. Ice says he is a townie w/ no PR. If we lynch Ice we have a 50/50 chance of lynching a townie/or a turned GH. If we lynch JL we have a 50/50 chance of lynching an innocent GH/or a turned townie. Out of the two I'd rather take my chances of lynching Ice over JL because there is no chance of lynching an innocent GH if Ice goes.

I understand the vote is for Lucky right now for which we have a 50/50 chance of lynching a suspected murderer/or a townie. A tough call for the town. But as I said before I really don't see the murderer calling that much attention to themselves. You have to remember that Lucky seemed like he was trying to get people to vote for him last night. I don't see that as something the murderer would do.

 

[noodles62]

OK. So JL says he is a GH. Ice says he is a townie w/ no PR. If we lynch Ice we have a 50/50 chance of lynching a townie/or a turned GH. If we lynch JL we have a 50/50 chance of lynching an innocent GH/or a turned townie. Out of the two I'd rather take my chances of lynching Ice over JL because there is no chance of lynching an innocent GH if Ice goes.

I understand the vote is for Lucky right now for which we have a 50/50 chance of lynching a suspected murderer/or a townie. A tough call for the town. But as I said before I really don't see the murderer calling that much attention to themselves. You have to remember that Lucky seemed like he was trying to get people to vote for him last night. I don't see that as something the murderer would do.

but how do we know that JL is not the murderer?

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

but how do we know that JL is not the murderer?

According to both Ice and JL's theories JL is not the murderer. I also Highly doubt the murderer would make the last minute vote move as JL did last night.

 

[noodles62]

ok - I guess I could see it that way.....

 

[noodles62]

shouldn't we be focusing on trying to take the soul of the murderer and not worrying about who is turned and who is not?
So if we rule out JL, Ice and Lucky, based on the two theories out there, who could be the murderer? I know it is not me, and we can rule out JL, Ice and Lucky based on the two theories out there; that leaves Rickets, Ogre, Opi, Jpap and Rich...any thoughts? I just think this should be our focus....:huh:

My power is about to go out so I hope to be back after I eat my yummy salmon dinner. :grinyes:

 

[noodles62]

let me rephrase my above post - the "3" are cleared as the murdered based on JL's theory, I dont think Ice cleared them both. I would have to go back and try to find it to be certain but am not sure I have time with the weather situation....

 

[noodles62]

yeah, you and John!

you say you have not liked ice from the beginning yet you have never even voted for him once. in fact your first vote was on John. "you will reveal why you were acting erractically at the end of the game"; there was no mystery gas that made people talk mumbo jumbo; I think you are on the evil team and are in over your head and could not handle the pressure; and now your protecting your team mate, john who royally screwed up last night and is trying to BS his way out of it.

I am reposting my comments to Lucky (post #538) as this is still where I am at.....I am not ready or willing to buy into Johns tale...my vote stays.
now, my salmon was fantastic and I need go to shower before we lose power- all electric apt. + high winds = cold water, no heat!!!!!!

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

More on the Lucky JL Noods team...( it can't be)

Lucky voted JL day 1 then dropped him completely. Classic mafia move.

We know CJ was evil, and a turn so he must have been turned after Night 1.

CJ voted for Lucky last night. I think he knew Lucky was done for and tried to blend in. John then jumps off last second bc CJ isn't around and is forced to save Lucky by being the kill vote on Fire. That means Lucky must be the murderer and JL is the accomplise.

So Noods can't be evil since they only had 3 as of night fall and the team was JL Lucky CJ.

I vote to take the soul of Lucky

Here you go Noods

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

You're right about both though, Noods. Ice thinks Lucky is the Murderer.

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

^^I meant both being cleared by Ice...