MAFIA #5 The Play.....

[OgreMkV]

My thoughts as of 7AM with no food and a long night o diaper-changin...

I'm agreeing with Coler that both jo and clown may be innocent. Also, there is a rush to put joander on the spot today. WE NEED DISCUSSION, not massive voting. With four votes already on Joander, I doubt that there is one other candidate who could get that many votes (right now). This ramrod voting is BAD for us.

Jensons - first on the list doesn't mean you are my mostly likely candidate (does anyone actually read my posts?). You had a statement in your post that made me feel like you didn't care and I said so.

ZSand - I changed to no one (like I said when I changed) that I thought that clown probably was innocent and that I thought there was a 50/50 shot it wouldn't matter anyway. ABout the time, I switched, there was a sudden surge to clown lover... like my vote ws important to someone and they had to scramble to fix it.

My vote for clown was also intended to even things out a little bit. Several people switched to clown after I cast my initial vote (including you and joander and Coler).

Right now, votes are the only thing I'm really going on. We've got kind of a short day today, because of the way the 36 hour schedule works out.

I'd also like to add the three non-voters to my list of suspects.

Now, who will go up against joander for this round. If joander is ramrodded and innocent, then we really need to look at those people.

 

[Dangerdoll]

hmmmmm.....

im not sure i know what u mean?....


You people think about this stuff WAYYY to much... dont try to figure out whether or not my mind mislead me and i typed something wrong, i meant what i said... stop taking everything so far into context.... and if you dont... you'll just loose another innocent (myself)

i am innocent, and unfortunatley... i am still all over peoples radars. I do not know how to get off either. If you lynch me... you will only find that i am in fact another innocent. I regret previous remarks and statements, but i was just getting a feel for the game at that time. Its sad to me that simply a mis-understood post can lead to so much confusion and suspicion.

To prove my innocents, i will lynch myself... along with cory lover

I vote to lynch Joander

Agreed, at the moment.



Not sure about the mafia thing, but the more jo posts, the more I'm beginning to lean toward another innocent. Its possible that the mafia figured if they could swing the vote to clown, we would go back after jo afterward and waste two nights lynching innocents. That maybe be giving them too much credit, but its plausible.

If that was the case, then jpappy comes off my list as well, since my whole reasoning was, I thought jo was mafia, and jpappy was telling him to basically cool it or he'd get lynched. If jo is innocent, that theory falls apart.

Ice and Jensons are definitely suspect for that last minute voting for clown. I still don't understand that one, but whatever. KOTD is also tentatively on my list. He was quiet and pretty subdued all last game and ended up being the Don, but I'm not sure if he's just a less-vocal player than some in general. Its hard to get a read from the quiet ones.


Right now on my "presumed innocent" list is HN, ZSand, coler and mal, and I think I've given reasons for all those already at some point. Comments?

with the exception of Color who is 98% innocent at this point unless he's really risking his mafia status with that 50/50 shot, anyone who is lynching themselves is waving that Mafia flag wide and high..... also, sploke, you say that the more joander posts, the more innocent she appears? I dunno, seems the opposite for me, especially with these two last ones.

 

[ZSandmann]

Good more all! Justing peaking in this AM to see what has transpired overnight.

Ogre: Fair enough, just seemed very different from your normal vote style but you were right.

 

[Sploke]

Not relevant to gameplay, but I think joander is male...fyi.

 

[ZSandmann]

You see why I never say he or she. I always say them, their, they...

 

[ZSandmann]

Bueller? Who are we gonna vote for Townies?

 

[judgemax]

Hmmmm...really

well...you were entirely convinced about joander the last time right ? surely nothing has changed your mind ? Give us your top suspects and why.

I never said I was entirely convinced, Just that I was more sure of him, and that I regret switching my intuition last game, I do not want to make the same mistake this game.

since you all seem to think, that people will blindly follow me, (evidentially not true, because I was the first to vote for jo, and CL2 was lynched)Why are you guys asking for my list?..

I also saw some strange things, although, I can not be sure, what I saw was an innocent, with a special role, or a very "unsmart" mafia, I would like to think, the latter, rather than the former, which is why I chose my comments the way I did last night.


i also said, I wanted a lil time to form an opinion, SO, without further ado, ..Heres what I am thinking:

1) I still hate to swing from JO, I am not sure 100% on any one, So, at this point, I am watching, and seeing some very desperate moves.

2) sploke - why are you so willing to just trust, The point of the game, IMHO, is to respect their opinions, but trusting them this early, Is dangerous.

3) JL66, very smart, a little to quite this game

4) KOTD, he is a reserved player, until you hit his button, Am a Little concerned here.

5)ogre- STILL VERY HELPFUL POSTS, .smart player, ..worth watching, But no opinion yet

6) coler- as far as I am concerned, at this point you are Innocent

7)bkw- i like his style of play, he gives me pause, because I am never really sure how to read him.

8)cory lover- I don't know, LOL, he plays so far from base each game, I think innocent, at this point

9) Mee-Mee- SHE IS PLAYING MUCH DIFFRENT, i AM LEANING INNOCENT

10) Zs - well, truth be told, I am sorta watching him, he caught on fast, and is a very good player, he doesn't give away much in his posts, but that makes me concerned .

I have a busy day, I have two dogs, to home, as having 7 dogs here, is way to many, lol, I also have an interview for the final puppy, which means, I will be a lil sad today

I also have some pictures to edit, and retouch, I will probably be watching, and posting if I get time, ..so, YOU ALL NOW HAVE MY THOUGHTS.

 

[Sploke]

Bueller? Who are we gonna vote for Townies?

Right now I'm split between a vote for JM or Ice. JM's postings are just making me nervous, it seems every 5 minutes she's got an excuse as to why she won't be around...thats fine, we all have lives (well some of us, I don't...) but I dunno something just strikes me as off. Ice's vote change last night caught me as strange as well. but I just don't know what to think of it. I've reviewed the flurry of posts in the last hour or so before night last night, and feel more unsure than ever about anything, so I'm not voting now, but unless something drastic changes, my vote tonight will be for one of those two. Whoever the mafia is this time around, they're doing a good job of keeping us confused. The events last night helped a little but not much. We now know that coler is most likely innocent, but still no sure leads on possible mafia. Blast.

By the way if anyone thinks I'm crazy with either of those two, please give me some other options. Like I said, just hunches, I would love some reasoning or solid justification.

 

[ZSandmann]

Thanks for that JM. I am having a much harder time pinning anyone down this time. I think we have a much more experienced Mafia than last game, which really worries me as that would be some of my favorite allies from last game are against us. It has me watching Ogre, Ice, Coler (Yes still watching), DD, KOTD...

 

[ZSandmann]

Right now I'm split between a vote for JM or Ice. JM's postings are just making me nervous, it seems every 5 minutes she's got an excuse as to why she won't be around...thats fine, we all have lives (well some of us, I don't...) but I dunno something just strikes me as off. Ice's vote change last night caught me as strange as well. but I just don't know what to think of it. I've reviewed the flurry of posts in the last hour or so before night last night, and feel more unsure than ever about anything, so I'm not voting now, but unless something drastic changes, my vote tonight will be for one of those two. Whoever the mafia is this time around, they're doing a good job of keeping us confused. The events last night helped a little but not much. We now know that coler is most likely innocent, but still no sure leads on possible mafia. Blast.

By the way if anyone thinks I'm crazy with either of those two, please give me some other options. Like I said, just hunches, I would love some reasoning or solid justification.

Well see that's what bothers me. Ice switched, Coler retracted, then switched, and Ogre retracted then didn't vote. And there were two or three others that didn't vote at all but I saw them watching the thread. I'm so totally confused at this point. I think a lot of folks are since there are very few votes so far. On the other hand johnlarson is bugging me because of how quickly he jumped back on joander, but then again that was how he voted last game as well.