MAFIA #5 The Play.....

OK, I will be out for the rest of the day.I said that I would follow Coler's vote, but he has retracted it, so I don;t know what to do. Ogre v. ZS is interesting. I wonder if rb told zs that he had to post that he was dect? That would be a huge bomb to make the game more interesting. With the small side effect of causing us to have a grumpy Ogre, it has been pretty entertaining, if mind-twisting and confuzzling.

So, I believe that Coler is innocent. He is a smart guy, and I am upholding my word to vote for his choice. He removed his vote for Ogre, but said in #910 that he wanted Ogre or KOTD to go. With this in mind, I vote to lynch KOTD. If KOTD is the vig, his hit will take place before his demise, if he gets lynched/hit, and assuming he hits tonight. So at least we have that if I am wrong.

Yes, I am bandwagon jumping, no it is not the best way to play, and yes, possibly Coler is getting too much power here. We will see tomorrow which way the wicked wind is blowing from.

~brandy

BTW, for anyone who wants to know, my remaining fishies are still alive. :)
 
welp...so much for the townies playing smart..

lynching me tonight doesnt give me much of a choice on who to hit..now does it..we still don't know if Z is the detective..or if he is mafia..same for ogre.

not knowing who the mafia is = no hit as i DO NOT want to hit an innocent.
 
Last edited:
rbishop said:
a. The priority of lynchings is Townies, Vigilante, Mafia, and then Untimely Deaths.
Click to expand...

KOTD - IF you are the vig, and IF you have someone in mind to hit, if you do it tonight it will go through, even if you are lynched. I'm not convinced of any of that, but wanted to clear up the technicality.

EDIT - never mind, if we lynch you it doesn't happen, but if the mafia hit you, it would go through beforehand. I'm confusing myself.
 
Last edited:
Jensons said:
OK, I will be out for the rest of the day.I said that I would follow Coler's vote, but he has retracted it, so I don;t know what to do. Ogre v. ZS is interesting. I wonder if rb told zs that he had to post that he was dect? That would be a huge bomb to make the game more interesting. With the small side effect of causing us to have a grumpy Ogre, it has been pretty entertaining, if mind-twisting and confuzzling.

So, I believe that Coler is innocent. He is a smart guy, and I am upholding my word to vote for his choice. He removed his vote for Ogre, but said in #910 that he wanted Ogre or KOTD to go. With this in mind, I vote to lynch KOTD. If KOTD is the vig, his hit will take place before his demise, if he gets lynched/hit, and assuming he hits tonight. So at least we have that if I am wrong.

Yes, I am bandwagon jumping, no it is not the best way to play, and yes, possibly Coler is getting too much power here. We will see tomorrow which way the wicked wind is blowing from.

~brandy

BTW, for anyone who wants to know, my remaining fishies are still alive. :)
Click to expand...

I agree with the last two lines that I have bolded - I'm holding off KOTD or anyone and suggest you do too. Plenty of time left.
 
well say wht u want about jenson post but its the move that does the less amount of damage. Here u have two possible detectives.....u don't know if ur goin to vote for the right one or the wrong one, so u choose neither.....

kotd we can lynch u and still keep the town but if we lynch the detective well it will be a rougher battle. i think the mafia will kill the real detective tonight and we will be left with one maifa guy and and one dead vig who hopefully used his hit on someone that is mafia or not at all if its not a wise choice. the info we gain from u will be useful to the town as well
 
ZSandmann said:
Because you're calling me out on a font on my post. Why would the font make any difference in the list? Also, why vote joander? To help take stress off Ogre? When Ogre is lynched and proved to be Mafia your going to look more suspicious. I'm sorry but you've played too many rounds to use the confused card.
Click to expand...

I was calling out the font because in the past games, it was said to have been used as a secret code of some sort. Why would that not be used here?

I voted joander because that is one person I have been consistently sure that is mafia through out the game but have bended to vote for other people because of listening to what people have to say. This time I am not bending and no, don't even try bullying me to post one way or the other because it will only push me to vote against you. Also, I never claimed to be confused about how the game is running, only that you and Ogre have delivered a twist that has spun my head a bit. You seem a little pushy to me, but that's my opinion, right?
 
bkw1982 said:
well say wht u want about jenson post but its the move that does the less amount of damage. Here u have two possible detectives.....u don't know if ur goin to vote for the right one or the wrong one, so u choose neither.....

kotd we can lynch u and still keep the town but if we lynch the detective well it will be a rougher battle. i think the mafia will kill the real detective tonight and we will be left with one maifa guy and and one dead vig who hopefully used his hit on someone that is mafia or not at all if its not a wise choice.
Click to expand...

Not smart bkw...the lynch comes before the vigiliante hit.

I was far too hasty to finger KOTD on Ogre's post

Lets work this out between ZS and Ogre. I would say no to voting KOTD and it makes me suspicious that you would try to encourage it.

edit here just to keep the posting a bit more modest :

My suspicious list for now are (aside from one of ZS and Ogre):

Dangerdoll
BKW
Ice
edit : adding Jensons for the KOTD vote

I absolutely take back for the moment that I am convinced Ogre is mafia ; I am far from convinced.

I'm interested in what both ZS and Ogre think of my list
 
Last edited:
KingOfTheDeep said:
welp...so much for the townies playing smart..

lynching me tonight doesnt give me much of a choice on who to hit..now does it..we still don't know if Z is the detective..or if he is mafia..same for ogre.

not knowing who the mafia is = no hit as i DO NOT want to hit an innocent.
Click to expand...

KOTD if you're Innocent or at the very least Neutral and really the Vig then it should be pretty obvious that Ogre is Mafia. If I had the ID of another special character, no way would I reveal it. Hope you pick your hit wisely I've put out all the info I have. I went back after I got the confirmation on Ogre (Night 1) and looked at the people he was talking about, that is where the list came from. If everyone goes back and reads my posts you can see how after Night 1 I stopped following Ogre other than a random, yes or no, here and there to hopefully throw off the Mafia that I knew one of them. On Night 2 I had to know Coler's real identity so I investigated him. At least I got folks posting, man it was quiet today. And rb has NOT given me anything to say, all my words are mine, I received my role at the beginning and the answers to my Investigations.
 
sploke said:
KOTD - IF you are the vig, and IF you have someone in mind to hit, if you do it tonight it will go through, even if you are lynched. I'm not convinced of any of that, but wanted to clear up the technicality.

EDIT - never mind, if we lynch you it doesn't happen, but if the mafia hit you, it would go through beforehand. I'm confusing myself.
Click to expand...

unless something else happens and we know 100% who a mafia member is, there will be not hit from me, i dont have anyone in mind as i do not know who mafia are.

bkw1982 said:
well say wht u want about jenson post but its the move that does the less amount of damage. Here u have two possible detectives.....u don't know if ur goin to vote for the right one or the wrong one, so u choose neither.....

kotd we can lynch u and still keep the town but if we lynch the detective well it will be a rougher battle. i think the mafia will kill the real detective tonight and we will be left with one maifa guy and and one dead vig who hopefully used his hit on someone that is mafia or not at all if its not a wise choice. the info we gain from u will be useful to the town as well
Click to expand...

baboo1bx.gif
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom