MAFIA #5 The Play.....

Hmmmm there are waaaaay too many hypotheticals going on in my head right now...

I retract my vote for joander...something more important is going on right now but I don't know what to make of it...I need to reconsider...
 
Well, I have to go home for the day. I'm keeping my vote where it is simply because I believe ZS..for now anyway. If I get home in time I'll review any new information, but its possible that we may just have to take a chance and make what we can out of the information afterward.
 
Guys I don't have any more info to give but will gladly answer any questions. I'm still at work, and the posts about me being busy were not a setup, I really am. But I have some time this afternoon if you want anything from me.
 
my current list of mafia if I had to pick them would be (leaving aside ZS and Ogre for the present)

bkw
DD
Jensons

thoughts ?
 
Hey everyone!

Ogre IMO tryed to do a last ditch effort to save himself....but I'm not falling for that and I'm keeping my vote for him.

Heres my list:

(1) Ogre- ZS is the detective, and revealed Ogre is Mafia. Also Ogre did a a bad effort to save himself IMO.

(2) DD-Mafia Princess sounds right to me. Voting for joander, therefore trying to save Ogre. Also trying to pick at a tiny blip by ZS, which probably meant nothing.

(3) jpappy (reasons stated before)

(4) Ice (fishy)

(5) KOTD (I'm confused)

CL
 
OgreMkV said:
Crap. The mafia must be getting very desperate for them to try this. It's a nice play, but it won't work.

ZSandmann is not the detective. I'm the detective. That's one reason that I've been relatively quiet (my wife really is sick, but that was only a part of it and a good excuse).

Of course Coler is innocent, he was the target of a mafia attack the first night. My two investigations were slightly more useful that Z's fake ones though.

I really hate to do this, but how else can I prove my identity. King of the Deep is the vigilante. Also, JohnLarson is innocent (my night 1 investigation). Why those two?

I investigated JL first because we have something of a history and I didn't realize that he was on vacation during the game. The next night, I knew Coler was innocent and I couldn't tell who would be lynched and killed each night. I had to send in my investigation very early and so I picked someone I knew would not be lynched or the mafia target.

Some might say that I am a mafia (or even the Don), but why, since I know that KOTD is the vigilante, is he still alive? Why wouldn't I (as a mafia) take him out first. It's simple, I can't take anyone out because I'm not mafia.

Now, I suggest that the mayor investigate me. I also pray that KOTD hit ZSandmann tonight. I'm sorry I had to out you King, but I have no other way to prevent myself from being lynched to no result.

King, if it looks like Zsandmann will be lynched, then I suggest that you take out bkw1982. He's my most likely suspect for another mafia. Tonight's investigation will be to find the mayor. I have a very good idea who either the mayor or the doctor is.

I'm not saying anything at this point because that would out them too. The vig is a one shot weapon and he should go ahead and use it tonight or he might be dead. Here's why... the doctor will hopefully, protect me (or Zsandmann, but it doesn't matter since he's mafia). Since the mafia may think I'm protected, they might not waste a shot on me. So the mafia will try to take out KOTD.

My real list:
JOhnLarson - innocent
KOTD - vigilante
ZSandman - MAFIA
Coler - innocent
JMAx - MAFIA

Good luck guys. I hope you all make the right decision.
Click to expand...

OgreMkV said:
I'm saying that Coler is the vig... I got nothing else. I'm not assuming anything at this point. rb could let JMax come back as zombie mafia for all I know now... shudder.

Z is very good at this.
Click to expand...

Coler said:
Ogre...you are telling us that KOTD is innocent and the vigilante I take it...that might not have been a good idea...now the mafia know who he is, and he has basically got until tonight to use his hit...before he is taken out.

That is pretty crummy detective play :D

Wasn't there enough stuff out there in ZS's game to show him up as mafia, if that's what we now must clearly believe ?
Click to expand...

OgreMkV said:
882 was a post for you Coler. I was telling you that I thought Z was a good player. He is.

The zombie part was just for fun.

If that was a trap for me it didn't work cause you got the wrong info. KOTD is the vigilante. I don't know if he's working for mafia or not. I guess we'll see tonight.
Click to expand...

OgreMkV said:
I don't know what makes me more frustrated... that you don't believe me or that you think I'm stupid.

I'm thinking that KOTD has already verified that he is mafia.



Coler, we all know you're innocent. But you are not the end-all be all of this game. I have no idea what you're talking about in that post that makes me mafia. I told you that Z is a good player. He is. I was answering YOUR question. I also don't understand how KOTD is automatically mafia. I'd vote against you right now if it weren't for the fact that you are innocent.

BTW: Your question to KOTD won't really help because if he's mafia... HE'LL LIE! Ever thought of that? He's the vig, if he pops me tonight, then he's either innocent or mafia, if he pops Z, then he's either innocent or mafia, if he pops no one, then he's probably dead.

It really depends on what the doctor thinks. It's all up to them at this point. Who to protect?

I've got to go guys. If anyone has any questions for me in the next 10 minutes or so, ask away. I'll answer.
Click to expand...

OgreMkV said:
Oh, I did mistype that. KOTD is the vig, but...

I vote to lynch KOTD. That make you happy Coler?

Let's all just vote for KOTD. Since I outed him and no one believes that he's the vig, let's just vote for him and see. Then you will know who to trust.
Click to expand...

Ogre confuses me. First KOTD is the vig. Then a post about Coler being the vig. Oh, that post was directed at Coler. Oh, and it was a typo? Not a very good cover up if you ask me...I vote to lynch Ogre. If he's innocent and the detective, than ZS is next.

EDIT: One of my quotes wassn't showing up and I fixed it...
 
Coler said:
my current list of mafia if I had to pick them would be (leaving aside ZS and Ogre for the present)

bkw
DD
Jensons

thoughts ?
Click to expand...

bkw: Yes I agree seems to be shadowing the other Mafia suspects.

DD: As you could see earlier she tried to wedge some doubt into my posts, but could of done a better job. Gets really defensive when questioned.

Jensons: Not sure about them. I have them as Innocent right now, I think there is nothing very solid.

Ice: I still think Ice may be Innocent

KOTD: Has me very confused right now but I can hold off on that for now.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom