Mafia 50/50 The play..back to Basics..almost

[noodles62]

Reeally quick cuz i am in the middle of water changes.....

Or he could have been busy and couldn't play the game haa. I have a feeling that you know something about zigman, because as you said you have voted for him twice, and you still seem like your leaning towards. Good or bad who know. I am kind of leaning towards blueiz and noodles are working together because they seem to get in big arguements, only to end with not voting with each other. Noodles is still on the top of my list because of the way she talks and seems to always find a way out of being pin pointed.

Noodles, what do you think you have done for the game, and who is on your list?

This goes along with the red thing up there. What do you mean I started posting more? I have always been somewhere near the top. Do you mean, I started to give my ideas more?

Well, to answer your question, I think I have tried to find the mafia. I agree that I tend to be argumentative (I guess thats how I play) but I have called out several players and made my own assessment of their response. I agree that I did argue with Blue the first day or two and yes I did vote for her. I am perfectly willing to vote for her again. I am not convinced that she is not scum. I have posted my top suspects several times......As far as me being "not pinpointed" you have got to be kidding! I was tied for the lynch on night one and always seem to be on everyone's short list......what are you talking about?

I'd like to let JL respond to my questions first, before responding here, noodles.

I am not sure why JL needs to respond before you post your suspect list. I can see if it determines where on the list he might be, but to name who you think is suspicious, maybe the top 2 or 3, is not asking that much really..........:huh:

 

[Kashta]

I was wondering how cj was going to be able to play while in Jamica. I had him leaning innocent. Since he was non-communicating, mafia still could (and would) have voted for him. The whole cut and paste / spell check was based on cj talking outside the thread. It is clear he wasn't. He was lynched for false reasons. While it is good he was lynched, the circiumstances were false.

Luvbugz was on my list of suspects as being mafia. I did think Luvbugz was playing better and getting more involved. It is a suprising hit.

I don't think this a good nightfall at all. The lynch was good, but it would have been better if the mafia would have hit one of the non-communicating mafia. It could have been worse.

The good news is that the innocents get to hit someone.

I don't think anyone that voted to lynch cj is cleared in any way.

I still suspect The Zigman and Blueiz.

John, you confuse me...... First, you say you were wrong about CJ and you were wrong about Bugz too (which I was as well). But then you go on to say you're suspicious about the people who got this right and lynched CJ. So that means you're talking about Wing Nut, Rich, DD, and Zigman. If they were on the right track, maybe we should consider more what they have to say.

I was concerned about Zigman too because he wasn't posting anything of substance, but he's doing that now so I'm leaving him as a question mark at the moment until we get to see what he has to say today and tomorrow before we vote again. But I don't know about Wing Nut, Rich, and DD... I haven't seen anything questionable by them.. or maybe I didn't pick up on something. All three are hard for me to read (as you are).

 

[Dangerdoll]

ok, sorry I've been away guys... we just got a new puppy today and we've been quite busy with the little girl... pics will be posted shortly

Doll, what are your thoughts on who is scummy? Other than CJ and bugz who are both gone now, any other players you are suspicious of?

ok, let's see... I know yesterday, I had a pretty strong feeling about blue because of her "all over the place" posts... yeah, could call them kicking in bushes, but you can also call them trying overly (word?) hard to seem helpful... not sure which. Also, I find it odd now Noods, that you are the remaining "font color" changer. Care to explain why you changed the color of some of your posts to hyper-bright blue?

 

[noodles62]

ok, sorry I've been away guys... we just got a new puppy today and we've been quite busy with the little girl... pics will be posted shortly



ok, let's see... I know yesterday, I had a pretty strong feeling about blue because of her "all over the place" posts... yeah, could call them kicking in bushes, but you can also call them trying overly (word?) hard to seem helpful... not sure which. Also, I find it odd now Noods, that you are the remaining "font color" changer. Care to explain why you changed the color of some of your posts to hyper-bright blue?

Sometimes, not all the time, when i reply to a post/question, i choose turquoise as my font color so my reply is "noticeable"; God forbid, my posts should go unoticed! :lipssealedsmilie: is that what you are referring to? I have not changed any colors today, at least I dont think I did???

 

[noodles62]

Sometimes, not all the time, when i reply to a post/question, i choose turquoise as my font color so my reply is "noticeable"; God forbid, my posts should go unoticed! :lipssealedsmilie: is that what you are referring to? I have not changed any colors today, at least I dont think I did???

sometimes choose red; just so my reply is "different" and distinguishable from the quote........:huh: I am sure I have done this in prior games.......

 

[noodles62]

g/o Congrats on the puppy DD. What kind? Cant wait for pics! g/o

 

[Kashta]

Or he could have been busy and couldn't play the game haa. I have a feeling that you know something about zigman, because as you said you have voted for him twice, and you still seem like your leaning towards. Good or bad who know. I am kind of leaning towards blueiz and noodles are working together because they seem to get in big arguements, only to end with not voting with each other. Noodles is still on the top of my list because of the way she talks and seems to always find a way out of being pin pointed.

Noodles, what do you think you have done for the game, and who is on your list?

This goes along with the red thing up there. What do you mean I started posting more? I have always been somewhere near the top. Do you mean, I started to give my ideas more?

(Since TRS highlighted his text in red already, so I highlighted in blue for the parts I'm responding to.)

No I don't, TRS... wish I did. All I know about Zigman is what I've been saying about him in my posts so far. I had noticed him mentioning he was glad to be back in the game or something about the last time there was a game (I'd have to go back to check the exact phrasing, which isn't that important)... anyway, from that I took it to mean he was a veteran player. So then when I observed his posts (up until yesterday), they were mostly joking around, rather frivolous, or saying something real non-committal. That gave me a feeling (since he's a veteran player) that he might be hiding out.. not raising questions and hoping no one would notice him. I picked up on him as potential mafia for that reason with my first vote. The first round of voting we do is basically a coin toss anyway because a lot is still just random. By the time we voted again, he was still behaving the same way so my same suspicions were still there... and while I also suspected you, LuvBugz, and CJ... I didn't really have a strong enough reason to vote against either of you.

What I meant about you posting more now is what you said there. Your posts have more content in them now.

 

[Kashta]

Oh.. forgot to add that I'm not a big fan of weighing someone's level of participation based on raw post count numbers... which is why I took issue over that point with johnlarson. In the very same day two people complained about me that... first, my post count was among the bottom three... then second, that I'm too vocal. C'mon folks.. it doesn't work both ways. lmao.

 

[Dangerdoll]

Sometimes, not all the time, when i reply to a post/question, i choose turquoise as my font color so my reply is "noticeable"; God forbid, my posts should go unoticed! :lipssealedsmilie: is that what you are referring to? I have not changed any colors today, at least I dont think I did???

ha!! won't go unnoticed as long as I am here! I don't recall you ever changing the color off-hand... but I dont think I've played in every single game you've played either so... not sure... and no, no change today... not so far as I can see...

 

[Dangerdoll]

g/o Congrats on the puppy DD. What kind? Cant wait for pics! g/o

Thanks, Noods! She's a 7 week old St. Bernard and quite a little doll... I posted pics in ChitChat.