Mafia 52: Killer Comes A Courtin' (The Play)

[Luvbugz]

Townies: I feel like we are getting lead around by certain people. I feel that the whole FD thing is almost a mute point. I feel like that is playing into the whole thing that JL and Kash have been pushing at us from the beginning. It even seems like JL is going down my suspect list and throwing those names out there again to see if I will jump at any. He pulled the whole JM doc thing again. Also, if anyone hasn't noticed both Ice and JL are now pulling out low participators outta their hats for votes. Easy to stick a vote on someone who isn't around much to defend themselves. Why isn't JL looking at Kash? Why isn't Ice looking at Kash? Why isn't JL looking at Ice? Why isn't Ice looking at JL? Seems like they are pointing fingers at everyone but themselves. Thoughts??

 

[Luvbugz]

I would totally right now lynch myself if it wouldn't hurt the townies. I feel like if I did though I would be handing the game right over to the mafia. I am trying really hard to get a win for the townies this time around. It is about darn time we won.

 

[johnlarson66]

Here are my first three posts -

I never liked day one anyway!

All in all, from my skimming, it looked like MC put themselves into a three way tie and died from it. I need to soak that in.

From what I have seen, it looks like there are lots of posts, but I am catching up.

Does anyone want to hear my reasons for not posting?

Here I vote for DD with my second post.

Here is DD's first post, the fourth post of the game!



Then some pertty good input, even for day one.







I looked these up, because it was stated that DD didn't vote. I have not seen where she stated she would not be voting. Maybe she did, I am still reading. I read (skimmed) from start to finish and now I am kinda going backwards.

I think DD was plenty active. Her no-vote is strange.

I vote to lynch DangerDoll

Here is where I state I have noods and Luv leaning innocent.

Kash, so if Ice lives, he is mafia and the town should lynch him? Is this the seed you wish to plant?

Did you post before nightfall that if you were mafia you would hit Coler or Ice? Looks to me you waited until after nightfall with this great insight.

Looks to me like you are setting Ice up. There are some good players this round and there are lots of good choices for the mafia to hit. The mafia will want to take out a power role and they will want to keep possible mafia suspects (that aren't mafia) in the game.

I am looking into jpaps posts, but nothing really jumped out as mafia. I wonder is the SK was thinking. Was the SK trying to hit an innocent or a mafia? What side were they on? MC' vote on themselves was odd.

Also, if DD comes up as mafia, I think that would clear noodles and luvbugs. Really, I have them leaning innocent as I would think that the mafia would not let one of their own go into a three way tie on day one.

Man, I have lots of catching up to do!

Want me to find the ones where I had you no longer leaning innocent. I am not even sure if I have ever stated that I had you leaning mafia, just no longer leaning innocent.

 

[Luvbugz]

I kinda don't know why I am fighting so hard for the town though. No one else seems to care or have any real input.

 

[IceH2O]

I dislike being a final vote on day 1. That being said, I don't feel quite right about Mostly, and I really don't like the vote on Luv right now. Especially as it is the first vote on.

I vote to lynch MostlyChiclids.

I hate to admit it, but I can kinda empathize with DDoll not posting. With the votes being so close, it almost seemed like a better idea to let the dice decide who was going home. But, it does seem out of character for her to not vote.

I think that it was a good thing that the SK is gone. Thanks for taking out a goon, but it was really a wild shot. What if jpap had been innocent? We would have lost 2 townies. Ouch!

Don't even pretend to askcwho the Dr is! We can't afford to lose them, and asking about is only going to cuase someone to slip up. You should know this jm (and yes, I understand that you said you were only joking, but still).

Why am I being linked to Luv? Yes, I "saved" her by voting MC, but it was mostly because I didn't think that the pizza fiasco was a good enough reason to vote her. I wish she would have given the rest of us enough credit to understand her joke, after all, we are playing a pretty intense thinking game, but that was it.

Maverick is worrying me with the run in, post something that sounds definitive and then disappearing. I think he is worth watching.

Ice always worries me. I get the urge to lynch him, just to be sure he's really a townie. I'm not totally feeling the mafia vibe, but maybe it'll come.

JL, wth?!?! I am not gonna get on your case too badly, but man! You're usually more on top of your game than this! I know you've caught up and all, but missing day 1 is pretty icky.

Well, stupid though you may feel it to be, a late vote is better than no vote. I think DDoll might be mafia, I don't think that LBug is and no matter how I vote now it looks scummy. That being said,

I vote to lynch Kashta.

She spent way more time making a case against me, DDoll and Lbug than could possibly hold water. It looks good, keeps the heat where she wants it and names enough people to keep suspicion from her for a couple days while the list is lynched. I'm not involved enough to be in such a conspiracy. Sorry.

Okay no typical list from her but some names being thrown around.


Comparing with Luvs list you see she has Mav as possible mafia along with Kash. Fire is known to name some mafia within her innocent list. Mav though has voted for Luv.
I can't shake the thought that Fires vote on Kash wasn't a distancing/safe vote though.

 

[Luvbugz]

If that is true JL then why arent you looking at Kash?? Or Ice??

 

[IceH2O]

What is your reasoning for thinking I am mafia Ice? Is it still over the pizza comment? Truly the only reason I said you (Ice) and DD only got it is because no one else referred to the joke directly. Everyone else seemed to just be chiming in with what they liked on their pizzas. I wasn't even sure if Kash got it. Maybe I didn't give everyone else enough credit.

Here is my list:

DD: Didn't vote at all last night, but kept pointing towards me all day yesterday saying she would probably vote for me. I think that DD is mafia. She knew Noods, me , and MC weren't mafia (she couldn't have known MC was the SK) and therefore didn't wanna draw too much attention to herself by making a tie breaking vote. None of them were mafia, so she wasn't gonna lose any buddies, so she didn't care.

Kash: Very quiet this time around. Don't know if that is just because she isn't having to defend herself from the get go or not. Still up in the air.

Rich: Looks like he is defending DD today. Hmmmm.

JM: Hmmmmm...

Noods: Has totally fooled me before. I thought for sure she was mafia my first game, but she was communicating innocent. I don't know what to think, but does seem like she is trying to help the town; more so then some.

Ice: The whole Coler/Ice thing yesterday was weird. Don't know if he is riding Coler's innocent coat tails or is truly trying to help the townies. So far, has been makin some great points and been somewhat helpful.. Dunno..

JL: Doesn't post or vote first day. Comes in outta the blue on the second day, votes DD first thing. Gives what I think is a decent reason for not being on the first day. Up in the air.

TRS: Usually comes in guns a blazin' to every game. Where is he?

Dopehand: ?????

If I were to take that list and pull off every name as innocent

DD:
MC
Kash:
Rich:
JM:
Noods:
Ice:
JL:
TRS:
Dopehand:


That leaves mafia as

Luv
maverickbr77
Agassizii
FireDancer7905
Jpap who we know was.

Agi as I said was on earlier but decided to not post or vote.

I'm going to go with this list of possible mafia.


Luv
maverickbr77
Agassizii
FireDancer7905
Kash

Jpap who we know was.

Its more people then I'd think Z would put in. I have to look back but I think Mav was on Luv both days and I don't think mafia would that.

 

[johnlarson66]

Townies: I feel like we are getting lead around by certain people. I feel that the whole FD thing is almost a mute point. I feel like that is playing into the whole thing that JL and Kash have been pushing at us from the beginning. It even seems like JL is going down my suspect list and throwing those names out there again to see if I will jump at any. He pulled the whole JM doc thing again. Also, if anyone hasn't noticed both Ice and JL are now pulling out low participators outta their hats for votes. Easy to stick a vote on someone who isn't around much to defend themselves. Why isn't JL looking at Kash? Why isn't Ice looking at Kash? Why isn't JL looking at Ice? Why isn't Ice looking at JL? Seems like they are pointing fingers at everyone but themselves. Thoughts??

So FD shouldn't be a suspect or jm1212 or even Dopeland? I had jm1212 as a suspect long before you did, it was me who was kicking him. Did you forget that? I am not trying to get you to jump at anything. I am trying to get people talking.

Now I am on a team with Ice and Kash? Want to explain that?

Can you stop the drama? It is really getting old. You have no thoughts about Dopelands tie breaking vote out of nowhere with no real reason? I think it should be discussed. FD's worthless vote for Kash is something that should be talked about.

You and your drama are getting to be a distraction.

 

[Luvbugz]

Going off my list now Ice?? What you don't have any thoughts of your own??

 

[IceH2O]

Day 1 votes

Mostly: Dawg(93) Luv(127) Kashta(156) Agass(161) Fire
Red: --Noodles(100)--
Coler: --Ice(106)--
Noodles: Jpappy(108) Ice(173) Coler(195) Jm(203)
Dopehand: --Mostly(118)--
Luv: Mostly(136) Noodles(154) Rich(191) Mav(202)

Day 2

DD: JL(254) Luv(285) Nood(320) Dawg(339) Kash(390) Nood(421) Dope(442)
JL: DD(276) Jm(338)
Luv: Mav(350) Ice(356) Jm(383) Rich(395) DD(406)
Jm: Nood(379)

Kash - Fire


These are the past 2 days of voting