Mafia #53.5 Rock the Vote

IceH2O said:
My bad Noods. Thats what I get for not pulling the quotes and trying to just go by what I remembered while reading.
Click to expand...
hmmmm..... Ice, I find this very unlike you. Usually, the Ice I knew would be all over quoting, stating facts with prof as he goes along...

what is with the problems with quoting this game?
 
Well I don't see anything yet to make me want to change my vote so i'm staying on Wycco.

FireDancer7905 said:
Ok guys and gals, bear with me...

As I read the thread and look at the votes I can’t help but feel that we are being led around by the mafia like a people by a poodle. I know that I have a nonsense vote sitting on Annie that needs to be changed, and I don’t like the options I seem to have (either Wycco or I must be mafia). There are sooo many players, and so little posting (I know, myself included, but I think I may be at an all-time with this game thus far, lol) there’re no bushes being kicked, and no new thoughts being put out. We have almost 24 hours left! Are we just going to twiddle ours thumbs? I have a hypothetical situation for all of you. It depends on my gut feelings about players, and runs with those feelings for all they are worth.

Assume that Jpap and Wycco are innocent. If we lynch Wycco today, and he comes up innocent, then Jpap the next and he comes up innocent we are in a sad place. So, let’s pretend that we know that they are innocent, cuz I say so. Who do we look at next? Ddoll? Dawg? TRS?

Ddoll has a vote on Wycco with a majority of the town. She switched from Jpap after Wycco pleaded his case ad nausea. I already pulled posts from her that don’t sit right with me. I can totally see her as the vet who pulled the plug on Z and Plant.

TRS hasn’t been terribly helpful, and seems to have given up on voicing his thoughts. Beaten down mafia give up, and become rude/nonchalant about their input.

Dawg has me the most worried right now.



I think you are setting up Wycco, because here:



you claim that Wycco is distancing and bring in Jpap, setting them both up to take a fall in your absence.



Above, you set up Ogre to look like he meant to out the Det, even though it looked pretty clear from his post that that was not what he meant. Again, it feels like a frame job to me.

There are, of course, others to be suspicious of, (like everyone!) but this is what I’ve got running around in my brain right now. I just can’t shake the feeling that something is terribly wrong about what we’re talking about and who we’re interrogating. It never hurts to look at other options.

I retract my vote on Annie and vote to lynch Dawg.
Click to expand...

Well FD all I can say is you are asking people to kick bushes in the first part of your post and then in the second part you want to take me out for doing just that. It doesn't make much sense to me. The other part of your quote that bugs me is "let's pretend we know they are innocent" (meaning JPap and Wycco). Since when do we pretend anyone is innocent? You are really starting to worry me FD.

Unfortunately I won't be around at nightfall and will be camping until probably Sunday afternoon. So I'm hoping I can get caught up and post my vote and thoughts before the next nightfall. This may be my last post until then as i'll only be on for a few more minutes.
 
IceH2O said:
I switched as I said to give Wycco 24 hours to convince me he is innocent.

I wanted to give him the false security that if I dropped that others could drop also.

Since I was going to look at TRS I figured he would be where my vote would go after the retraction for the reason stated above.

Yep I'm still not sure about Wycco. Most of his posts seem to confuse but a couple stick out as innocent. Rockers post kind of confirms Wyccos guilt to me though.

But it scares me that both you and Noods name players you will go after if Wycco is innocent, not mafia but innocent.

But we have Rocker voting Noodles when he says Wycco is setting him up.

I retract my vote on TRS and vote to lynch Rocker
Click to expand...

I said I would vote rocker if Wycco comes up mafia, and I'm pretty sure that I made that clear earlier when I said I though they were a team. Right now I think no matter which side Wycco ends up on you should be a suspect.

jm1212 said:
but you didnt vote for either?
Click to expand...

Annie doesn't have a vote...Fire stole hers if I'm not mistaken.

Dangerdoll said:
hmmmm..... Ice, I find this very unlike you. Usually, the Ice I knew would be all over quoting, stating facts with prof as he goes along...

what is with the problems with quoting this game?
Click to expand...

I'm thinking the same...something doesn't feel right with Ice. He made the comment that I was not playing my game by not digging up a bunch of posts (or something to that effect) but he is not doing that either. I do think he said in defense to TRS that he thought more people would be active, but I still don't get a good feeling with Ice.
 
IceH2O said:
I switched as I said to give Wycco 24 hours to convince me he is innocent.

I wanted to give him the false security that if I dropped that others could drop also.

Since I was going to look at TRS I figured he would be where my vote would go after the retraction for the reason stated above.

Yep I'm still not sure about Wycco. Most of his posts seem to confuse but a couple stick out as innocent. Rockers post kind of confirms Wyccos guilt to me though.

But it scares me that both you and Noods name players you will go after if Wycco is innocent, not mafia but innocent.

But we have Rocker voting Noodles when he says Wycco is setting him up.

I retract my vote on TRS and vote to lynch Rocker
Click to expand...

Also forgot to address the fact that I do not buy into people setting traps...even when it's you involved, Ice.
 
jpappy789 said:
I said I would vote rocker if Wycco comes up mafia, and I'm pretty sure that I made that clear earlier when I said I though they were a team. Right now I think no matter which side Wycco ends up on you should be a suspect.



Annie doesn't have a vote...Fire stole hers if I'm not mistaken.


I'm thinking the same...something doesn't feel right with Ice. He made the comment that I was not playing my game by not digging up a bunch of posts (or something to that effect) but he is not doing that either. I do think he said in defense to TRS that he thought more people would be active, but I still don't get a good feeling with Ice.
Click to expand...
i know that, but i was referring to the first post she had of this night that was filled with random quotes and no explanations. if any post was weird and suspicious, it was that one.
 
I think that is the one where she hit submit too soon, according to her...

I'm not all that suspicious of Annie. It would be pretty bold for her to vote a teammate night one, which is also why I am much less suspicious of Ogre.
 
JM, here is the post. I think it was pretty obvious she was going to go after MC if you look at it.

AnniesNotOK said:
RANDOM RIDICULOUS RAMBLINGS by AnniesNotOK
Click to expand...

Here she says she was trying to build a case and was going to vote.

AnniesNotOK said:
Sorry about my previous post. I had pulled some of MC's quotes and was going to build a case, but hit submit by mistake before i added my commentary and vote.

Now I will be going to my trailer until Sunday, where I will try to access the site via cell phone, coverage there is spotty at best.

My suspects at this point are:
MC
Wyyco

Wyyco for obvious reasons, and MC has been my prime suspect since early day one for previously stated reasons. Sorry I don't have time now to pull posts and such.

Sorry I haven't been a great townie, this game has been harder than I had anticipated.
Click to expand...

I don't see anything scummy here.
 
Ok, it seems that my vote on Dawg is wasted. I don't want to vote for Wycco. I could be totally wrong, and be totally snowed by him, but I truly don't get mafia from his posts. Does anyone remember lchap and his first game? He got it, right away, with no coaching; we were all so surprised, and he was so adamant about his innocence that we lynched him. Innocent. I feel like we are doing the same thing right now. I have no way of knowing his true identity, but I don't feel like I have to vote for him. I'm willing to be wrong on this one.

So, the question becomes where to lay a vote (or two)? My lists from a previous post would be wasted atm. I did think Rocker was suspicious, and rereading his posts a stench began eminating from my monitor. It's totally conceivable to me that he is either setting up or distancing from Wycco. Either way, it's a good vote that I am happy with.

I retract my vote to lynch Dawg and vote to lynch Rocker.
 
Am I dead ? I just got back from holiday and don't want to read the thread unless I'm not dead.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom