Mafia #53.5 Rock the Vote

[jpappy789]

I vote to lynch Dawg...mafia as all get out.....

Noodles will be my next vote, once Dawg is lynched, if I survive the next night.....

Rb, what are you trying to say here? Do you know investigation results?

 

[noodles62]

Zaffy? really? how did you come to this conclusion?

I am reading things over again (with the usual distractions!:swear trying to determine which way I should turn after nightfall. If Wycco is mafia (which I think he is, obviously) then I will most likely look at Rocker, and probably Ogre since Wycco keeps proclaiming that Ogre is innocent; altho this may be his plan to have the town go after one of their own.....hhhhmmmmm.....
If Wycco comes up innocent I plan on looking into Zaffy, Jpap and Firedancer......

I really dont like "what ifs" (and like suspense even less!) I will gather my thoughts better after we know the results of nightfall....

For the record, I am going out this evening and hope to be home for nightfall but not sure I will make it....

Looks like we will have a bunch more UD's. Let's hope they include more mafia.....

Both are very interesting synopsis' that I would tend to agree with, for the most part. I am still not feeling good about rocker/zaffy based on the first day behavior that I noted at that time and feel that at least one is mafia; and with the added opinion of a known cop (Ice) I am even more inclined to move my vote back to rocker.

However Rbishop's behavior is very disturbing, which I am sure is his intent. It seems very "anti-town" and not hlepful at all. just popping in and spewing some random comments and votes out of nowhere. My vote is currently on him right now as he is the one that I am the most uneasy about, however I am more than willing to move my vote before nightfall if it is needed to make a difference. LG has not been very helpful either; I am inclined to right this off as real life issues however do not want to be snowballed at the same time....Dawg- I dont know, he has fooled me many times, so I am not sure where my thoughts are on him.... MC, I have no feelings of mafia at all right now....Jpap seems to be genuinely trying to root out scum; JM seems to be following leads from FD and RB which I find very interesting and a bit disturbing....Ogre also seems to be genuine in trying to find scum and I am not getting a "read" of scum but I of course am no expert in trying to read the real vets....but still not getting a bad feeling from him at this point...not sure if that is everyone or not...more later; need to get back outside and help with the yardwork. We have been invaded by Cicada Killer Wasps. Goody! These suckers are HUGE!!! :jaw-dropping:

I have stated previously that I have felt that either Rocker or Zaffy were mafia. Rocker obviously was not mafia nor was Firedancer. So Zaffy it is. I still feel RB is scummier so that is where my vote is.

 

[jm1212]

I have stated previously that I have felt that either Rocker or Zaffy were mafia. Rocker obviously was not mafia nor was Firedancer. So Zaffy it is. I still feel RB is scummier so that is where my vote is.

you seemed pretty sure about getting rid of FireDancer. did you know she was an innocent, a cop no less? probably.

 

[noodles62]

you seemed pretty sure about getting rid of FireDancer. did you know she was an innocent, a cop no less? probably.

I did? I never even voted for her. I said I was suspicious of her and did not trust her cause she has fooled me before. Twisting things to suit your needs? Sounds shady to me.

 

[jpappy789]

I'm torn on my vote on Noods.

It seems too coincidental that she names Jm based off of Fire and RB, and "bad notes". Fire is not a really a top suspect at the time but Rb was getting a lot of attention. Then Fire shows up as a cop.

I dunno. The mafia would not have known Fire was a cop but were obviously fishing for PRs. So noods had no absolute risk in naming her. But she didn't just come up innocent, which looks really bad for noods.

Today I've had RB and noodles as suspects. But both are claiming that the other is mafia. Desperate distancing? Not sure.

 

[noodles62]

I'm torn on my vote on Noods.

It seems too coincidental that she names Jm based off of Fire and RB, and "bad notes". Fire is not a really a top suspect at the time but Rb was getting a lot of attention. Then Fire shows up as a cop.

I dunno. The mafia would not have known Fire was a cop but were obviously fishing for PRs. So noods had no absolute risk in naming her. But she didn't just come up innocent, which looks really bad for noods.

Today I've had RB and noodles as suspects. But both are claiming that the other is mafia. Desperate distancing? Not sure.

Another thing about my notes/spreadsheet - not to make excuses - but I figured out what I did wrong. I redid my sheet Friday cause it was getting hard to read with all the votes and retractions and I transferred some data wrong......
Anyway, I do not expect anyone to believe me I just had to post that for my own sanity. I would not be so stupid to make up voting orders as I know that would only look bad on me; I did however fail to check against the mods count before I posted - my bad.

So do I take a page from Luv's and Wycco's book and get all defensive &/or dramatic and profusely proclaim my innocence or a page from Rocker and keep quiet? Neither worked so - :huh: We shall see how it pans out I guess.

 

[jm1212]

I did? I never even voted for her. I said I was suspicious of her and did not trust her cause she has fooled me before. Twisting things to suit your needs? Sounds shady to me.

twisting things to suit my needs? earlier you were ranting on about how i must be following Rbishop and Fire because i voted after them!

i never said you voted for her. i just said you were ready to get rid of her pretty quick. it seems like 1). you forgot how to read again and 2). you are trying to put words in my mouth. you're really bad at playing mafia noods.

 

[jpappy789]

Thought I would pull some posts of Fire's to mull over.

I think this is a FANTASTIC idea! I got all goosebumpy when I saw the night's poopy events, and think that there's definitely much to be learned from what the Det. has learned.

For now, I'm sticking to my gut and going back to my hypothetical situation (seems I was at least 1/2 right, and I'm going to bet the farm completely correct) because I can't justify any other vote.

I vote to lynch Dawg.

Pretty sure about Dawg

But, what if they only started with 2 or 3? I dunno.... JL, can we get a count of how many are still kickin' on each team? I think it would help us make a more informed decision.

Fire likes the idea of getting the detectives info (from first post) but her second post shows she doesn't want to risk losing a cop. I'm thinking maybe this meant she was the only active player left on that team.

About now I am starting to think that Dawg was investigated the night before. Fire couldn't come completely clean but her vote (with certainty) is telling.

But what if Ice didn't know either role for certain, and was acting solely on gut? Wycco, while slightly irritating, seemed pretty innocent to me, too. What if he switched to keep off the train, but didn't have any actual info, other than Rocker's posts seemed scummy. We don't know who the det investigated at all, so guessing is kind of counterproductive. If we focus on that, we are missing time that coud be devoted to fleshing out the rest of the mafia. It's just hard, because there are too many players who aren't really playing. We keep going round and round on the same players, because they are the only ones here. I think we have a sleeping mafia team, doing just enough to keep alive, but not much more. We seem to be doing their work for them pretty well.

Fire asks whether it is worth going after rocker just based on Ice voting for him. In hindsight, knowing that they were teammates means that they probably did not know rockers role. I think if Fire knew, she would have voted for him to make sure he was gone. She voted Dawg instead, which is as good of lead as any at this point.I

I actually did give a reason for voting Dawg, before I switched my vote last night to Rocker (where it wouldn't be wasted). I think it's a solid vote, and it will not change based on any defense he thinks up.

Again, thinks the vote on Dawg is good.

Not 100% sure that FD knew for a fact but I'm willing to roll with it for now...

I retract my vote on noodles and vote to lynch dawg

 

[noodles62]

you seemed pretty sure about getting rid of FireDancer. did you know she was an innocent, a cop no less? probably.

Again, not sure where you see I was so sure and in a hurry to get rid of FD.....I stated I dont trust her. Who is the one being overlydramatic here?

I did? I never even voted for her. I said I was suspicious of her and did not trust her cause she has fooled me before. Twisting things to suit your needs? Sounds shady to me.

twisting things to suit my needs? earlier you were ranting on about how i must be following Rbishop and Fire because i voted after them!

i never said you voted for her. i just said you were ready to get rid of her pretty quick. it seems like 1). you forgot how to read again and 2). you are trying to put words in my mouth. you're really bad at playing mafia noods.

Ranting? I dont think so. I mentioned it briefly in a post.

Both are very interesting synopsis' that I would tend to agree with, for the most part. I am still not feeling good about rocker/zaffy based on the first day behavior that I noted at that time and feel that at least one is mafia; and with the added opinion of a known cop (Ice) I am even more inclined to move my vote back to rocker.

However Rbishop's behavior is very disturbing, which I am sure is his intent. It seems very "anti-town" and not hlepful at all. just popping in and spewing some random comments and votes out of nowhere. My vote is currently on him right now as he is the one that I am the most uneasy about, however I am more than willing to move my vote before nightfall if it is needed to make a difference. LG has not been very helpful either; I am inclined to right this off as real life issues however do not want to be snowballed at the same time....Dawg- I dont know, he has fooled me many times, so I am not sure where my thoughts are on him.... MC, I have no feelings of mafia at all right now....Jpap seems to be genuinely trying to root out scum; JM seems to be following leads from FD and RB which I find very interesting and a bit disturbing....Ogre also seems to be genuine in trying to find scum and I am not getting a "read" of scum but I of course am no expert in trying to read the real vets....but still not getting a bad feeling from him at this point...not sure if that is everyone or not...more later; need to get back outside and help with the yardwork. We have been invaded by Cicada Killer Wasps. Goody! These suckers are HUGE!!! :jaw-dropping:

Here I (apparently erroneously) stated JM was following FD and RB - we have already established that my spreadsheet was screwed up and my vote order was wrong - I still dont see ranting or anxious behavior.

:rofl: This is a bit dramatic, don'tcha think? Almost comical!

Perhaps it is just the feeling and suspicions I get from you following so neatly after FD and RB on the vote for Dawg. RB has been playing very suspicious all game long and Fire - well, I dont feel I can trust Fire, she has fooled me one time too many. You are just fitting into their plan a bit too neatly.

"the mafia triangle is falling down upon you" :rofl: I'm sorry - that is too funny!

HHHMMMM, not seeing me trying to get rid of her really quick????
You are going to have to do better than this. Your case against me is weak at best. So I screwed up and had the vote order wrong. And ya know what, I must a figured that out cause I certainly am not coming after you am I? Do you see me trying to build a case against you? No. If you were aligning yourself with FD then that would indicate you are innocent as she turned out to be a cop. *Gasp!* I musta figured that one out all by my little old self!

Come up with something better than my bad notes; cuz it aint working.

 

[jm1212]

you already know im innocent so it isnt worth arguing over.