Mafia 56. An Unknown Evil. THE GAME....

[Lycanthropic]

I edited my post because of a spelling error. Im sorry but I kinda like to have my spelling correct.

 

[jpappy789]

Alaska in 1960 too, Z.

 

[OgreMkV]

I am pretty sure someone has the role of Village Idiot...

:lipssealedsmilie:

That would be me... as usual... LOL

Too strange to be evil.

I retract my vote on phoenixn7g and vote to lynch AnniesNotOk.

Something Luv pointed out about them being all gung ho and then not posting got me thinking Annie, who was viewing the thread. I expected some sort of post, but nope, nothing. I also have Ogre leaning innocent and he is voting Annie.

I need to chill on the vote changing and most likely will not be changing. Unless jpappy uses his baiting skills on me.

John, I appreciate the vote (or non-vote in this case) of confidence. However, even if you have me leaning innocent, that's not a very good reason for voting Annie. This is day one. As, as has been pointed out to me by you or jpap, my reason for voting Annie is incorrect anyway.

I vote to Lynch Annie.
Ice, I admit to skimming a bit this thread. I did not see your post, and for this I am sorry as I have allready mentioned. I retracted my vote due to my ignorance.
Yes jpap, interesting.

Annie voted, and changed her vote 3 times within the first half hour- 45 minutes, leading me to believe that something is up. Im thinking some kind of way of communicating within posts maybe? call me crazy, but it would explain her erratic behaviour. First vote could have been hers, then the next vote could have been, if there is a communication between posts, maybe her leader or fellow member of some sorts suggested she change her vote, and then if a group of "baddies" has been established, maybe a consentual vote on who should be lynched? Thats just my thoughts

OK, now there's a train on Annie. Not that I'm sad, I might not be the one to go... or anything, I'm just wondering if I can be trusted by anyone after the events of this day. I really don't want to lead whatever good guys are around astray because of any presumed role (good or evil) I may have.

I will not be around most of the day. We are having a family party. I dont know if I will be back by 9 or not.

I see merit in all the different suspects today. I think my vote on JL is wasted at least for now. I dont see Ogre as guilty.

Since he got me before and he has been all over the place I will go with Annie.

I retract my vote on JL and vote to lynch Annie.

What the heck?!?!?! THis is pretty scary. I go away for almost a day to think things through and I come back to being not only, not the leading vote getter, but having two people following me onto someone for no reason.

I am not sure why you have Ogre leaning innocent.... or rather why you think he is holding a power role instead of being innocent, JL...

I also don't understand why being "too strange" excuses anyone from being evil either.

Annie, looks like a good reason to change your vote to though...

I have to head out... will respond more when I get back...

DD, so if Annie is some kind of evil player, am I in the clear? If Annie is innocent, does that make me evil? Remember these day one votes are random.

i retract my vote for annie and vote to lynch kash.


her not voting by now makes me worry.

This is just getting weirder and weirder

I'm back to terra firma!!! Thank the stars. Just in time for college football, woot!

I have no idea what is going on this game but "folks be crazy" seems a good way to sum it up. Coler, Ogre, now phoenix.... what is in the water around here? I don't know if this is something to do with roles or if it is trying to cover slip-ups or what. phoenix appologized for nothing, literally. Makes me think it was intended for another window she was chatting in. Then all the smoke about blizzards and ice cream follows to try and cover that. I think it is a more sinister slip than anything Ogre has done, although I admit the KGB bit is interesting considering this is in Alaska. Close to Russia.

I retract my vote for Dawg and vote to lynch phoenix.

A three horse race should make nightfall exciting.

I can live with that. Provided it stays that way.

Kash is basically the deciding factor tonight. Provided that JM and rocker stay on their singleton votes. With the way things are going today, I'd be surprised if one of those two wasn't a bad guy. Singleton votes when everyone else is training is pretty scummy to me.

 

[Kashta]

Jeez, now I'm the last to vote. I got slammed yesterday and was just skimming along as I could. Intended to delve into the thread last night to catch up with the rest of you, but I kept falling asleep and didn't get very far. At this point, I'm not that sure I remember all that I read... that said, I took a few notes through the first part of the thread and will be working as I can to post more throughout the day. I should also be here for nightfall, this time.

At this point, my strongest "feel" in this is Jpappy. I vote to lynch Jpappy.

Reasoning... Pappy was all over JL right off the bat... made more of his odd posting than seemed right to me at the time... hoping to start a train on him? Or genuinely suspicous? I'm not sure which. After that, Jpap seemed real heavy handed in his case-building and that usually doesn't bode well for the town from any player on Day 1. That goes a tad further than just kicking the bushes. Then, when I saw Pappy's "gosh darnit" post, it seemed he was trying to make his play seem casual.

I'm used to Jpappy's very inquisitive posting style but this time, something doesn't sit quite right. So that's what I'm going with for the time being... subject to change between now and nightfall if something more compelling develops.

 

[jpappy789]

Ogre, even though your reason for voting Annie is wrong and you are supposedly worried about others "following" you on to him...you're still keeping the vote?

 

[OgreMkV]

Ogre, even though your reason for voting Annie is wrong and you are supposedly worried about others "following" you on to him...you're still keeping the vote?

What do you want me to do Jpap?

If I move and Annie evil, I'm dead.
If I don't move and Annie's evil, I'm distancing to make myself look good.
If I move and Annie innocent, I'm covering myself.
If I don't move and Annie's innocent, then I'm bad guy for voting innocent.

I've got enough problems. I said I wasn't going to move unless something really obvious happens, that hasn't happens, so I'm staying. At least I'm being sincere.

 

[IceH2O]

I took over my daughters comp.I tried something with mine and now even the Ubuntu Live CD won't load so again bear with me.

I edited my post because of a spelling error. Im sorry but I kinda like to have my spelling correct.

1st of all no editing posts after you make them.

2ndly...My problem isn't the reason you used to vote me.Its that you voted me period. If you were a person that played lots of games I could understand maybe being worried about me but you have no experience with me. I think someone told you to vote me.What changed your mind on voting JL? How did you go from him to me and with such drastic reason change.
Jl was because he was talking mumbo jumbo to me who you claimed wasn't talking?

Phoenix I see you answered the 1st part of the post how about the 2nd part?Especially the bolded part.

 

[jpappy789]

Jeez, now I'm the last to vote. I got slammed yesterday and was just skimming along as I could. Intended to delve into the thread last night to catch up with the rest of you, but I kept falling asleep and didn't get very far. At this point, I'm not that sure I remember all that I read... that said, I took a few notes through the first part of the thread and will be working as I can to post more throughout the day. I should also be here for nightfall, this time.

At this point, my strongest "feel" in this is Jpappy. I vote to lynch Jpappy.

Reasoning... Pappy was all over JL right off the bat... made more of his odd posting than seemed right to me at the time... hoping to start a train on him? Or genuinely suspicous? I'm not sure which. After that, Jpap seemed real heavy handed in his case-building and that usually doesn't bode well for the town from any player on Day 1. That goes a tad further than just kicking the bushes. Then, when I saw Pappy's "gosh darnit" post, it seemed he was trying to make his play seem casual.

I'm used to Jpappy's very inquisitive posting style but this time, something doesn't sit quite right. So that's what I'm going with for the time being... subject to change between now and nightfall if something more compelling develops.

Heavy handed case-building?

Nothing about my play style is casual and I don't see a reason to try to play it off as such. I suppose I could question your comment in post #43 (Gah! This is going to be tough. <sigh>) as trying to do the same thing but I see no merit in that as its true, everyone is confused and this is going to be a hard game to figure out.

You of all people should know that by now Kash. All you've done is play around with with little rules we have. So far you have been non-existant in terms of actual analysis.

 

[jpappy789]

What do you want me to do Jpap?

If I move and Annie evil, I'm dead.
If I don't move and Annie's evil, I'm distancing to make myself look good.
If I move and Annie innocent, I'm covering myself.
If I don't move and Annie's innocent, then I'm bad guy for voting innocent.

I've got enough problems. I said I wasn't going to move unless something really obvious happens, that hasn't happens, so I'm staying. At least I'm being sincere.

Maybe come up with some other suspects...already some people have listed a few names they are interested in. All I see from you is "I screwed myself over"...

 

[IceH2O]

What do you want me to do Jpap?

If I move and Annie evil, I'm dead.
If I don't move and Annie's evil, I'm distancing to make myself look good.
If I move and Annie innocent, I'm covering myself.
If I don't move and Annie's innocent, then I'm bad guy for voting innocent.

I've got enough problems. I said I wasn't going to move unless something really obvious happens, that hasn't happens, so I'm staying. At least I'm being sincere.

This post really makes me want to look at you even harder,I'm even starting to wonder if KGB wasn't a slip after all.

Why are you worried about what others think of you? If you don't think Annie is evil then you move to someone else.You commented on how you don't like that others quickly followed you on to Annie but then you whine about how you look no matter which move you make.
Since any move looks bad on you then why worry about taking out someone you think is evil? I think it looks much worse if Annie dies an innocent and you failed to move coupled with the above post.