Mafia 56. An Unknown Evil. THE GAME....
- Thread starter Wycco
- Start date
I keep forgetting but we have no idea what's going to happen tonight in terms of a hit/turn/whatever it is...I'm also hoping that whatever is revealed to us is helpful.
I'm back now, so I'll post. Looks like nothing much has happened.
Everybody worries me at this point because I don't have any idea who's playing for which side. There's been a lot of confrontational stuff going on between different people and I never get a good read on those... especially on Day 1.
In the vamp game, yes that's right. Annie worked hard trying to get turned on purpose because he wanted to join the scum team. In the following game, Annie was scum and did a great job playing that role. One thing I remember reading in their thread when they posted that after the game ended was how much Annie kept asking Wycco to let him be evil again when this game started and Wycco was going to be the mod. I don't know if Wycco would be willing to indulge that request or not.. so I realize that has no bearing on the actual assignments made here. But I do see something of a cockiness in his posting which was much like the posting he did once he became a vamp. Having successfully fooled everyone as evil last time, it's possible that Annie is tackling this game with even more confidence than he's done before...
Everybody worries me at this point because I don't have any idea who's playing for which side. There's been a lot of confrontational stuff going on between different people and I never get a good read on those... especially on Day 1.
In the vamp game, yes that's right. Annie worked hard trying to get turned on purpose because he wanted to join the scum team. In the following game, Annie was scum and did a great job playing that role. One thing I remember reading in their thread when they posted that after the game ended was how much Annie kept asking Wycco to let him be evil again when this game started and Wycco was going to be the mod. I don't know if Wycco would be willing to indulge that request or not.. so I realize that has no bearing on the actual assignments made here. But I do see something of a cockiness in his posting which was much like the posting he did once he became a vamp. Having successfully fooled everyone as evil last time, it's possible that Annie is tackling this game with even more confidence than he's done before...
Ice if this isn't a classic setup, I can't imagine what else would be. Seriously...
I listing Annie as a possible suspect, but didn't feel the case strong enough to justify voting him. You came along then to state you don't see the case.. and specifically asked me to explain it. So I did... to give your direct question an equally direct answer. As I've said, I do see a case.. but I think it's a weak one.
Now you come back to me saying I should be voting Annie. Why would I do that when he's not at the top of my suspect list?
Okay, I guess this post makes me a little less concerned about Ice now. But still.. jeez.
I do think Jpappy is up to something here (more than usual) but I'm not sure whether or not it means he's evil. I just have to vote for someone.. and it's all I have. I don't have a case built for Jpappy either.. or anyone else. I haven't been able to put enough time into this for that. What I saw was Pappy jumping onto just about everyone no matter what they've posted (including me)...
If he's evil, that's good play because it enables him to switch around, incriminate certain players for lynching - while posting glancing blows on teammates to distance himself. If he's innocent, it's also good play because it helps us flush out scum. Of everything else I've been reading here, it's Jpappy's activity level and doggedness that stands out. So I felt it useful to address that (whether it's good or bad, I'm not sure either). At the moment, I've decided to make a call that it's more evil than innocent and he got my vote today. I don't like either of the 3 candidates who were in the running, so I went with the most likely person I could find who I felt should be questioned and possibly voted on.
Its a boring weekend so far, so I'm active. Always will be when it comes to mafia or AC in general for that matter. I'm not going to stop posting just because others in the game have.
The highlighted part is important, I think. As I understand the rules/scenario we've got so far... the mayor knows what the roles are. But they do not know which player is in which role. If that's true, then the mayor doesn't know who is evil and who is innocent.
Most likely the case as I dont see Wycco just handing the mayor the game on a silver platter, but to be fair who knows what he is up to...
I guess I just don't understand why you went through the trouble in your limited time to build a case on Annie being evil then dismiss it as not enough evidence then vote Jpap with nothing but a feeling as your base.
