Mafia #57: The Great Mafia War- The Game

[Wycco]

Actually- Ice doesn't rate Annie... let me readjust that:

Again- just putting what comes to mind.

Theoretical Team A
JohnL
Bishop
LB
MC


Theoretical Team B
Ice
Annie
DD
?????

 

[jpappy789]

Sorry G, I did miss that. I believe this is correct but...you never know...

LG- Annie 132
Ogre- Rocker 136, Luv 156, JL 178
Annie- JL 141, LG 143, DD 154, Jmax 168, Zs 217
Rb- Zaffy 155, Wood 161, Jmax 168, Ogre 177
Ice- MC 157, Lan 207
Rocker- Annie 166
Luv- Ice 173, Annie 210

No votes: Rb, Rich, Wycco

Night is in approximately 6.5 hours

 

[Wycco]

I vote to lynch RBishop.

I don't mind seeing a Bishop/Annie tie by any means.

 

[Dangerdoll]

I vote to lynch ICE

To be clear, I haven't had time to read through the thread and am in danger of UD'ing. This vote means absolutely nothing and is based on absolutely nothing.

I apologies for slacking, I've been too busy and I'm really a little worried about being able to keep up with a bit complex of a rule set than we had last time I played.

this is the 2nd post where the vote come sout of no where.... the first was from MC... is there a problem with your chat room?

Really I don't care about the votes on me right now. The "getting Luvbugz to crack" theory is truly funny. I see JL pulling the same stuff he has before. He plants seeds about people's "scumminess" in other people's minds. He waits until someone else picks up on it and then jumps right aboard. When the person in question turns out to be innoncent, JL still looks okay because the everyone goes after the person who first voted; not JL.

To answer Ice, I didn't think Annie was protecting Ogre. I thought OGRE was protecting ANNIE by switching his vote. I think Annie's vote switching was to cover this fact up. So, it's not good enough for me to be voting for Ogre?? I really don't care who goes tonight. Annie, Ogre, and RB are all on my list. Add JL to my list as well. DD's following Ice's logic onto Annie was odd. That is all I have. I have been trying to keep up as much as I can.

Please explain to me where am I following Ice's or anyone else's logic. I could have sworn that the last I saw, Ice was leaning Annie as less suspicious as time goes on.... I don't think so, and was always suspicious of him.....so because I am no stranger to skimming, please let me know what you are reading that makes you come to this conclusion..... please do it before nightcall so that I may switch my vote if need be....

 

[Luvbugz]

I can see that logic...

What do you have to say to that Annie?

I am on my way out the door and don't think I will be back before nightcall.... so because I still see nothing better, I am going for the vote on Annie. I vote to lynch Annie

Right here. Of course Ice quoted someone else about Annie, but right after that fact you vote for Annie and then leave for the night. Looks like you were just trying to find a quick way to place a vote and vanish. The DD I know doesn't need other people's theories or logic to place votes. Did your team tell you to vote for Annie and you were just waiting for a convient time to place it without looking too suspicious??

 

[Luvbugz]

ummmm.... having withdrawals.... I guess that's why it took you 24+ hours to post after the thread start

I was thinking the same thing when I read that post. For now I vote to lynch Annie

Actually I just went back and found this. DD was suspecting Annie BEFORE Ice said anything about it. So, actually this clears up DD for me. I wonder why Ice would implement Annie, but yet vote for me?? Hmmm isn't this what I am supposedly in hot water for??

 

[jpappy789]

NIGHTFALL IN APPROXIMATELY 3 HOURS. PMs AS NEEDED!

 

[IceH2O]

Not as much positing as I thought there would be but just wanted to comment on a couple.

Actually I just went back and found this. DD was suspecting Annie BEFORE Ice said anything about it. So, actually this clears up DD for me. I wonder why Ice would implement Annie, but yet vote for me?? Hmmm isn't this what I am supposedly in hot water for??

I never implicated Annie. I said I agreed with the logic to see who would follow which DD did. Then she decided to strenghten her case with the vote switching episode.

Look back and you'll see a few posts down I claimed it was a weak day 1 reason and explained why.

:lipssealedsmilie::laugh:

Sorry Ice...his actions clear nothing IMO. I doubt I would of moved a vote to "save" myself if I were mafia, it would just draw to much attention to the fact I did especially if the person ended up innocent that I moved to. There was so many tied the risk of actually being the one the coin flipped on were pretty slim.

LG, he moved a vote and didn't save himself using it. So using your logic you're agreeing that Annie is most likely innocent.

 

[IceH2O]

Nah Annie, I don't agree with Ogre at all. I just wanted to see who would jump on next using that reason as an excuse. Its a weak reason even on Day 1 IMO.

I don't think any of us if put on a mafia team would wait to post anything until we communicated with our team. Day 1 is just mostly babble, not anything you really need to talk over with a team.

I do have to say though that weirder things have happened.

I won't be jumping on that train. I like my Luv vote for mentioning RB peeked her interest then votes Wycco for no apparent reason. It seems more scummy to me.

Here Luv I pulled the post for you.

 

[Lady G]

Not as much positing as I thought there would be but just wanted to comment on a couple.




I never implicated Annie. I said I agreed with the logic to see who would follow which DD did. Then she decided to strenghten her case with the vote switching episode.

Look back and you'll see a few posts down I claimed it was a weak day 1 reason and explained why.



LG, he moved a vote and didn't save himself using it. So using your logic you're agreeing that Annie is most likely innocent.

No, Ice either you miss understood me or I am misunderstanding you. My point was I would not move a vote to save myself (which he did NOT do). You were saying, if I got it right and I think I did...since he didn't save himself it pretty much clears him....in my thought it does NOT clear him, because if I was in his position (could save myself by moving my vote) I would NOT of switched to someone on the chopping block...which he did not. Yes, he moved his vote SEVERAL times, but not to anyone who actually had a chance to be lynched. Just because he didn't save himself and had the chance to does NOT in anyway "clear" him in my mind.