Mafia #6.....The Play

[ZSandmann]

Am I totally misunderstanding the rules?

Nope you are at the same logical point I am Sway

 

[Madcrawdad]

planting, why are u apologizing, are you changing your opinion on me or what?



also, someone clear this up here for me, the secret identity has to be a special role? It cant just be a normal mafia?? i was under that impression that a mafia was a special role, but maybe not?

that would be my impression...general mafia would apply.

The doc was lynched and appeared as 'Doc'
The snitch was lynched and appeared as 'Snitch'
The Don is dead and appeared innocent as per the rules

Who else would the special character rule apply to but the vig and mafia?

 

[Swayde]

Quote:
The Secret Identity…one or more townies who befall a lynch/hit will not have their special role revealed until the night after their death. Limit of two times that this will be done.


The special role part is what jumps out at me. At first it did seem like any townie could have a secret identity, but that clearly states that their special role would not be revealed.

And anyhow, if I misunderstand it, there have been NO "Not enough conclusive evidence" deaths.

I would really like to know if I misunderstand this rule or not, please.

 

[plantling]

My top 3:

KOTD
Jensons
John Larson

 

[ZSandmann]

Z's Top 4 Mafia-O-Rama

Jensons
Jpappy
johnlarson66
(joander plantling sploke KOTD all tied)

 

[Swayde]

that would be my impression...general mafia would apply.

The doc was lynched and appeared as 'Doc'
The snitch was lynched and appeared as 'Snitch'
The Don is dead and appeared innocent as per the rules

Who else would the special character rule apply to but the vig and mafia?

The Doctor, the Detective, the Don....you know the "special roles".... I am really starting to wonder about you people, why would mafia be considered a special role when the whole game is about Innocent vs. Mafia?

 

[Swayde]

1. JohnLarson
2. Jensens
3. Sploke

 

[ZSandmann]

Sway: Let's just move on to who we suspect is Mafia and hope RB will clarify. I too would not consider Mafia a special role but we just do not know and there is no point in working ourselves up over it.

 

[OgreMkV]

Secret identity could mean that DD was mafia/Don AND/OR it could mean that anyone killed last night could be mafia. I think that Nick or DP could also have been choices.

Either way, we have a chance. Let's keep focused on good mafia choices. We MIGHT have a extra day, but we might not too.

Am I thinking that this is the current (extant) mafia list:
JohnLarsons
Jensons
Joander vs. me. vs. Madcrawdad
jpappy
sploke vs. Plantling

 

[ZSandmann]

Sway in my opinion only one of the two of Jensons and sploke are Mafia. Do you have a feeling on which one you prefer of the two?