Mafia #6.....The Play

Hooked Newbie said:
To me... any suggestion that Coler was the Don and his hit was a mafia tactic is very suspicious. They wouldn't hit the only one with the power to investigate...
Click to expand...

I never said Coler was Don? Where did you get that?

Mad isn't being hit he is being lynched so the mafia really has nothing to do with his demise.
 
IceH2O said:
I never said Coler was Don? Where did you get that?

Mad isn't being hit he is being lynched so the mafia really has nothing to do with his demise.
Click to expand...

Ummm...

Originally Posted by IceH2O
I'd agree except if he is Don it will show as innocent.

 
plantling said:
So Mike, you think Coler might have been the Don? A possibility, but I'm not seeing it.
Click to expand...

I have to agree with this statement. However there is possibility of Secret Identity.. I am hoping he wasn't the detective or doctor since we seem to be very hobbled this game.

MikenDanielle said:
How do you not like the idea... different scenerio... Tim has cancer and Bob does not... one of these two must die. Tim has been givin 2 months to live, Bob is healthy... who would you pick to die if you had to choose? I can;t make this seem any simpler. And we do get info from JM being lynched, we find out if she is infact mafia or innocent... if she just slides away into the darkness do we get to find out her role?

Simply put, because you had the wrong analogy as well as the wrong logic on the whole matter. But since she has withdrawn from the game anything else I post on this is moot.

Have you passed a grade 3 comprehension test? I follow whoever is not against me?? Not that this is true.. but what do you expect me to do?? Follow those who are against me??? Seriously use a little common sense and I think we will be doing better.
Click to expand...

Actually I was going to ask you if you flunked out of "Are you Smarter than a 5th Grader show..." While I understand what you are saying you are throwing way to much deception around right now for my comfort level. The doctor might have saved you, but that doesn't make you an innocent by any means. You really have done nothing constructive to help the town and pretty much are just slinging crap all around the place. If you truly want me to continue to believe you are an innocent and just made a stupid mistake you'll stop making them since "you have read the other games".

IceH2O said:
I didn't realize till I went back and read the rules again that there was no botched hit/lynch this game. Rb has heavily favored the mafia this game. If they don't win they should all hang their heads in shame and retire from this game. Its that loaded for them.

That is about the largest understatement I have seen in a long time.

The only problem with this is if she is Mafia and posts at the very last second then she doesn't die.With lynch votes she goes either way. I myself think she is hiding mafia and one of the invisibles.Mostly because the people against the lynching are mafia suspects in my eye and they don't want us to lynch one of their own.

The only problem with this theory is that when I checked her status last she still hadn't done anything since Sunday. Now while DD might have access to stuff that we don't until it can be verified by another independent source by the definition of law as it stands today it would be considered Here Say

The day cycles are 48 hours so night will always fall at 5 AM,

This is wrong the cycles are 36 hours. See Bob's Post, night will fall tomorrow at 8pm.

I am postitive that Mad is Mafia

I have to agree. If Mad isn't mafia I will resign from this game because as of that point everything that I have come up with to this point will be garbage and I really don't feel like starting over.

Nic, I work sometimes till 8 PM though not often, usually home by 6. You want to write that down somewhere so you don't get confused? Maybe you should put it on the big board you guys are using to frame innocents?
-----------------
:lol:
-----------------

I think the Dr probably thought the Mafia figured Coler .
Click to expand...

I think that the Doctor is a complete Nooob and if they new what they were doing, which I don't think they do, I hope they do.. But well you know. The Doc should have protected Coler. He has been the first hit of the Mafia the last game and he was right in line (for the most part) this game. It should have been painfully obvious that they would hit him again.. If he isn't hit the first night on the next game he will be mafia in my book. I personally feel he is one of the strongest, if not the strongest player of this game.

IceH2O said:
Post 652 she says she quits. I think if you say you quit that should be it. Its an unfair ploy if thats what it is.
QUOTE]

If I don't see a post from Bob tomorrow stating that she died from mysterious death, I'll be voting for her at 8:01 pm and I won't be changing that vote at all. Period. I don't need anything else for that vote.

As of this point I don't see a reason to change my vote from MadCrawDad and pretty much feel that it won't be changing. I still reserve the right to change this vote (and that nice little disclaimer I saw earlier).. But realistically we need a true lynch to see where things are going.

My list hasn't changed.
Click to expand...
 
Hooked Newbie said:
Ummm...

Originally Posted by IceH2O
I'd agree except if he is Don it will show as innocent.
Click to expand...

Ok I see DD got between z, sway and my answer. I'll have to make sure I always quote what I'm talking about.But I was answering them not DD.
 
ZSandmann said:
He was talking about Mad I believe
Click to expand...

I think he was replying to my questioning of this...

Originally Posted by IceH2O
I'd agree except if he is Don it will show as innocent.

We still need to be careful.

FOR THE FIRST 6 DAY/NIGHTS, THE DON WILL SHOW AS AN INNOCENT ON ANY INVESTIGATION OR UPON LYNCHING.


This really hurts us, I could see on investigation but to handicap us on a lynch is just brutal. Even on investigation since we only have 1 person investigating.
 
So we are doing 36 hrs? Okay I know in the sign up thread he mentioned going back to 48 hours. Thanks... **** I need to pay attention lol. So caught up in who is what I have totally blacked out anything else.
 
I read the post and I do remember talking about making it an 8 or 9 pm deadline to help out with people just getting home from work around 6.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom