Mafia #6.....The Play

my newly revised suspect list:
mad
mee mee
kotd
plantling

be advised i will refer to all of the above as mafia scum until further notice
As i interpret the snitch rule i believe that although mafia he may be supposed to help us. it says he wants revenge. perhaps he has instructions with the role that state the townies must win for him to win. the "snitch list" has helped me. mad is the only one on it that rings alarm bells. you can bet your sweet *** im gonna look at the other three. look real close. its gonna be another long day in ACville i can tell you that. i'm voting now. its subject to change. anyone that wants my reasons visit post 406. but beware, coler ghost is haunting it. lets start talking townies.
i vote to lynch madcrawdad
 
Z, posted at about the same time. I think Mad is innocent. I think you are more and more innocent. I think I know who the doctor is and I hope the doc realizes that.

I'm willing to stake my life on it Ice. I've got nothing else to offer, except I still don't believe you. If I'm lynched, I would appreciate it if the doctor protect me.
 
I agree, 3 less vocal people make it hard to choose one.

Phone brb
 
Dangerdoll said:
he's claiming to be the snitch.... the rule says one of the mafia is the snitch and then Mad says it's not him. Then it says "The Snitch will PM rb a list of 4 names, their choosing, whenever he asks. At least one member of this list will be a Mafia member. These names will be worked into the night time story line. None of it has happened. Mad seems to be playing the same card played last game when 2 people claimed to be the detective.
Click to expand...

Thank you DD for explaining that to me...

It could very well be King, I have been keeping my eyes on him, and he seems to be playing the way he did when he was Don in game 4,

and if you notice in the story line, me and Plantling are together, and Mad and King are off to themselves...so I think it is one or the other...but Mad, I am kind of leaning away from you and I think we should go take a look at all of King's posts...that is what I am going to do to see if I can find anything between the lines...I know how he played in game 4 for I was a Mafia also...and he is posting just like he did there, go and compare, you will probably see the same as here...
 
Do we put that much weight on the list, it is about the same as the start of the game. If anything we should treat all 4 as innocent (75% correct) and focus on the rest of the town. It makes the rest of the mafia easier to find.

I am suspicous of Dwarf Puffers at this time.

I am also curious about OgreMvK and why he thinks 2 people know he is innocent. The Doctor did not save him and who knows what the Detective has found.

btw, thanks Doc for letting the town lynch as planned, it would have been total kaos if you would have saved Mike again.

The Detective will really need to wait until they have a good amount of confirmed mafia before they can really help the town.

I also had a list before. I am not sure how good it was, I think I need to examine it and try to come up with a list. Is bkw1982 playing? I have not seen many posts.

I am going to study this post a bit and place a vote. I want to vote before I go to bed.
 
johnlarson66 said:
Which two? The top three seem to be not as vocal and you seem to be on a few "lists".
Click to expand...

I'm going to dig, and I'll post my thoughts on the other three, and also explain why I am innocent.....Even though the snitch was to not reveal themselves to their mafia pals, I don't believe that there was anything to stop the whole team from coming up with a list for the snitch, knowing that one of them would be forced to give up a name.

At any rate, if I were the snitch, I would probably choose to include the most guilty looking townies to date, along with the least guilty looking mafia member, so we need to be really careful...what you see, might not be what you get. The detective may come in really handy here. Problem is, though, that even if the detective manages to stay alive, townies won't get results of any investigations for some time.

Also, there is always the chance that the snitch has given more than one mafia member.....this means that even if we peg one of the four as mafia, unfortunately, we can't clear the other three names.
 
OgreMkV said:
Here's a theory... just a theory for consideration

The snitch (who is still mafia) gave us a list of 4 players where three of them have so few posts that we have no way of making a valid judgment and another that is on several lists.

The snitch could very easily have turned to the rest of the mafia for help in making the list.

This list is tailor made to lynch Madcrawdad. I'm not saying he's automatically innocent, but anyone of those other three would be a perfect stealth mafia. Neither Jensons, nor KOTD post very much... ever. Mee-mee is almost uncharacteristically quiet as well.

I reall don't see mad as mafia.
Click to expand...

The reason I am uncharacteristically quiet is because I had only 2-3 hours for reading and posting, because I work 10 hour days and I have to be in bed by 9 or 930 central time at the most or else I would be really tired at work, and alot of customers at work, running food, taking orders, and we are really busy right now at work...and so with alot of posting and trying to figure people out and reading (we are way ahead in this game than we were in game 5)...So don't even worry about me being Mafia, for that I am not...

ZSandmann said:
He's still getting my vote.
Click to expand...

No problem there...

charlie_stubbs said:
my newly revised suspect list:
mad
mee mee
kotd
plantling

be advised i will refer to all of the above as mafia scum until further notice
As i interpret the snitch rule i believe that although mafia he may be supposed to help us. it says he wants revenge. perhaps he has instructions with the role that state the townies must win for him to win. the "snitch list" has helped me. mad is the only one on it that rings alarm bells. you can bet your sweet *** im gonna look at the other three. look real close. its gonna be another long day in ACville i can tell you that. i'm voting now. its subject to change. anyone that wants my reasons visit post 406. but beware, coler ghost is haunting it. lets start talking townies.
i vote to lynch madcrawdad
Click to expand...

How do I know you aren't Mafia...for I wouldn't even know that, only you would...
 
JL, I said that I THINK two people know I'm innocent. If the det investigated me, then they know too. I'm hoping that the doc knows and that I know who they are.

Like I said... I'm willing to stake my life on it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom