Mafia #6.....The Play

Yes, it does plantling.

Here's my take because i'll probably be killed tonight.

If sploke is indeed mafia, the so are sway and plantling (the snitches one mafia), because they were very defensive of sploke (the don?)

the implication of the second group, if sploke is mafia, then bkw and Jensons probably are as well... rb's hint to us?

So if SPLOKE, then PLANTLING, SWAY, BKW, and JENSONS.

if not sploke, then game over.

You guys find the last two, I'm going to bed.
 
plantling said:
I'm just catious because at this point the Mafia could have found out some of our power roles and have included them in the snitches' list. And it would be a good idea to "investigate" their posts first, because as you say let's not let it depend solely on the Bala.
Click to expand...

Why not depend on the Bala, nothing else has worked.
 
OgreMkV said:
Why are you and sway against Sploke?
Click to expand...

I'm assuming this was directed at mad. Mad, as far as I can tell, is going off a list of 7 mentioned names in two of Rb's narrations, and the apparent clues held within. It sounds pretty thin to me, but then again its my name being thrown out there. Also, there was a comment about the snitch list only being used once? Where did the second list come from? Maybe the snitch was used twice...did we ever get that cleared up?

As far as I can tell, Swayde was for me being innocent, not against, as per the post below.

Swayde said:
Madcrawdad said:
I wouldn't be at all surprised if Sploke is Innocent, heck I wouldn't be surprised if he's the only Innocent in that list. Face it, with Z and Ogre pulling one everyone in so many different directions and pointing fingers all over the place, there won't be a big enough concensus to nab a Mafia. So you might as well jump on the lynch Swayde train, get it over with. I sure could use the rest.
Click to expand...

I'm glad someone has noticed this. I've been pretty careful and consistent with my picks this time around, and haven't changed votes at all. My posts, while maybe not as in-depth as Z or Ogre or mad or Ice, have been at least a decent effort to help the town. At the very least, I'm not contributing to the rediculous amount of back-and-forth finger pointing, one of the things that has gotten the whole town down so far this game...no cohesiveness.

Although, now that swayde has stuck up for me, it doubts my vote for her (yes, after all that I'm actually second-guessing a vote...but I guess I haven't been any more right or wrong than anyone else so far this game, so why not.) If Swayde was mafia I doubt she'd be trying to clear me. The mafia are so close at this point, its going to be fairly easy to push the rest of us in the wrong direction, right over the edge. Ugh. I'm leaving my vote where it is because I'm too dang tired to review enough to change it right now, but looks like I have something to look into tomorrow.
Click to expand...
 
Crap that second quote should be attributed to Swayde, not mad...the quote-within-a-quote thing screwed me up. I need to go to bed.
 
guys, just woke up and signed back on....

observation of the last...so many pages

as soon as we start posting a lot everyones radar pops us and says "mafia"

i wasnt posting a lot and criticised for it, so i chnaged tactic and started openly discussing rather than observing...all of a sudden i'm second in line for the lynching

these are facts, not arguments, so when i get lynched, look back and say....

who encouraged nick to post more?
who criticised nick for not posting enough?

and

Second observation, if i assum the last few pages are full of townies, then the townies are all turning against each other playing into mafia hands

what was the rbishoop thing about the Don being very quietly smug?
 
It's very late, but something just came to me. Sploke, if you are the Vig, then the Mafia already knows.

BKW if you are the detective then the Mafia already knows.

See Ogre's post#1558. It's in RB's nightfall narration.

I have some theories, but I need to know if you are those roles first.
 
OgreMkV said:
My thoughts in Red

[/COLOR]



8 PM tomorrow. This one is critical.

Z, what do you think of my analysis? JohnLarson, how about you?

Could rb have put all seven mafia into these posts? I don't know, but I'm thinking that he may have put 3 in the last one for us. I wouldn't have thought rb would help like that in the game, but there it is.


 If you guys concur, I say we go for one of the ones I show above.

I vote to lynch sploke.
Click to expand...

I am not sure how much this storyline has to do with the game. Maybe all of them or none of them are mafia. I think what we need to go by is how people post, vote and act.

I do not understand at all why we are even discussing this stuff. There are 7 mafia. They have controled and changed the voting. DP should have been lynched. Right now, ZSandmann, a respected player, has very good reasons to beleive that Swayde is mafia. So much that he is willing to lynch himself if wrong.

Does that even mean anything?

Why is anyone asking about this storyline. Why is anyone atempting to name and get the Detecitive killed. Why would anyone vote against this.

What am I missing here. I can't beleive some of the posts and actions of some of the well respected players in this game. Are they in on it?

I think we would all agree that this game 6 is a little lopsided towards the mafia, but as a whole, we have not played well. Did Coler have that much influence. I am still shocked that an experienced player picked to veto a town lynch (who was innocent) over protecting Coler. The whoe OgreMvK saying Doc please protect me.

There are a lot of things that are not right in this town. I think we have some of the mafia in our sights.

I think there are many that are trying to keep the town divided. At this point in the game, we really need to be working more together. That is how the town has won in the past.

I think we should either stand behind ZSandmann's vote or vote to lynch him. The latter he has offered if he is wrong. I do not think he would make such an offer if he was wrong.
 
Update...6:30 AM EST...thru post 1579....

to lynch....

sploke (2) by ogre 1558 mad 1561

jl66 (1) by nick 1446

swayde (5) by sploke 1436 jl661407 kotd 1417 plant 1549 zsand 1343

nick (3) by charlie 1365 mee 1475 joan 1437

zsand (1) by swayde 1412


Night fall at 8 PM EST Saturday, 7/28. I'll try to get another update in the early afternoon.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom