That's the way I was looking at it as well Mad. DD had to be either Don or a secret identity, BUT I thought it would say "not enough information" if it was a secret identity event, maybe that was only on investigations though.
Mafia #6.....The Play
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
Regardless I am going to assume till I see different that we tipped the scale and there are currently 7 Innocents and 5 Mafia.
that would be what i would assume (will assume) as well. There may be possibilities, but we dont want to overthink/overlook anything either.
Z, I'm sorry if you think I was pulling your strings yesterday. By the time I signed on yesterday morning, I was pretty sure Swayde was also an innocent just as Nick was. I was very alarmed t see 3 votes on her already, which was started by JL who was on my Mafia list:
KOTD
Jensons
JPappy
JoAnd
John Larson
DD
Charlie Stubbs
Then JoAnd throws a vote on you post#1747 and at the time I had Jo equally marked with you as Mafia. Then DD throws her vote on you post#1756 so I start thinking it's another Mafia set up and you could be innocent as well. On post #1785 I tell you I believe you both are innocent and think it's another set up. I then plead with you and several others to help me vote KOTD and hoped Swayde would join also. My fault was that I overestimated how much pple would trust me even though I was listed along with mee-mee in the snitch's list and to me it was obvious we both were innocent. So I posted my list and pleaded with you and Swayde and anyone who would listen to let's find a common point and vote on as it was a do or die night. I didn't think my Mafia list was that far off of everyone else's, but like I said I didn't think pple distrusted me so much either.
And then I think it was you that mentioned possibly voting for BKW and I don't know if anyone caught it but it's post #1796:
I was hoping he would come out soon and have names for us and luckily he did. If you read my posts you will see that I was very happy he did. I first suspected he was detective a few nights ago:
I ask you to read Ogre's and my conversation and tell me what you think of his behaviour because it's a little odd to me.
And because I refused to vote Sploke who I thought was the Vig at the time, Ogre called me Mafia. Up until last night I thought Sploke was the Vig and innocent but I don't know if he is an innocent anymore. His not voting for Charlie actually has me wondering about him also, but nothing highly alarming.
So again I'm sorry if you felt I was trying to manipulate you, but I just didn't want the town to lose and was a bit frantic.
KOTD
Jensons
JPappy
JoAnd
John Larson
DD
Charlie Stubbs
Then JoAnd throws a vote on you post#1747 and at the time I had Jo equally marked with you as Mafia. Then DD throws her vote on you post#1756 so I start thinking it's another Mafia set up and you could be innocent as well. On post #1785 I tell you I believe you both are innocent and think it's another set up. I then plead with you and several others to help me vote KOTD and hoped Swayde would join also. My fault was that I overestimated how much pple would trust me even though I was listed along with mee-mee in the snitch's list and to me it was obvious we both were innocent. So I posted my list and pleaded with you and Swayde and anyone who would listen to let's find a common point and vote on as it was a do or die night. I didn't think my Mafia list was that far off of everyone else's, but like I said I didn't think pple distrusted me so much either.
And then I think it was you that mentioned possibly voting for BKW and I don't know if anyone caught it but it's post #1796:
I was hoping he would come out soon and have names for us and luckily he did. If you read my posts you will see that I was very happy he did. I first suspected he was detective a few nights ago:
I ask you to read Ogre's and my conversation and tell me what you think of his behaviour because it's a little odd to me.
And because I refused to vote Sploke who I thought was the Vig at the time, Ogre called me Mafia. Up until last night I thought Sploke was the Vig and innocent but I don't know if he is an innocent anymore. His not voting for Charlie actually has me wondering about him also, but nothing highly alarming.
So again I'm sorry if you felt I was trying to manipulate you, but I just didn't want the town to lose and was a bit frantic.
Yes, here is the post...
JL finally makes an appearance
Okay, I know this is quite long. I am mostly doing it for myself, to get this stuff in one post so I can reread it easily, but I also hope that maybe someone else can help me see if I am way off base or what. I find it fishy that Dangerdoll was apparently trying to defend JL when it looked like everyone else who commented was suspicious of JL.
Dangerdoll says this, after I've said I am going to bed (Sorry I never did really explain that Ogre, I did state that I was having tooth problems (abscess & root canal) and I'd imagine between fevers and pain killers my brain did scramble up at times, but I really was going to bed when I said I was).Quote:
Originally Posted by johnlarson66
I have Nick on my list, but really his play the last day has matured. I still do not understand the lack of following ZSandmann's claim of Swayde being mafia.
I still think that either ZSandmann or Swayde are mafia (or even both). What is sad, tomorrow this will not even be talked about. We will be right were we started.
Here is the problem, I think we have to get a mafia on this round. If DP quits and the town lynches an innocent and the mafia lynches an innocent then it will be 7 to 7. I am fairly sure the mafia win.
If the vigilante is for the town, I think it would be wise to take a shot at whoever is in second place on the voting. This game could be over.
Also, has anyone noticed when the game gets intense there is no role playing. Hmmmm.
And then she saysQuote:
Originally Posted by Swayde
No offense DD, but I believe you are Mafia too, so we'll see what others think.Quote:
Originally Posted by OgreMkV
Sway is beginning to persuade me... JohnLarson was on my final list. Keep going...Quote:
Originally Posted by Swayde
*Swayde heads home with a very heavy heart. She is so sad to see even more Innocent's blood shed on yet another infuriating night in this new town. Why did she choose to come here again? She is glad to have another day with her lovely goldies at least. She hopes that good can still overcome evil, but things are really not looking good. She closes her house up and goes to bed*
Rest in peace Nick and DP. And to all the other Innocents who have perished, I am so sorry we have not been able to avenge your deaths yet.
JL finally makes an appearance
Madcrawdad says:Quote:
Originally Posted by OgreMkV
Sway is beginning to persuade me... JohnLarson was on my final list. Keep going...
Some how I am on "the final list".
I see some of the smoke and mirrors that is going on and it kinda makes me wonder.
We are back to where we were.
There is no reason not to follow ZSandmann. All this other finger pointing is a disperate atempt to muddy the water.
Is there a new and improved "Snitch list" this day? Who else can we throw in the mix to take the pressure off. Why not hear ZSandmann out.
Here is my top three of mafia:
Either Swayde or ZSandmann
Ogre
Mad
Once again, I think we as a town need to lynch one or the other. Swayde or ZSandmann.
I vote to lynch Swayde
Quote:
Originally Posted by OgreMkV
Sway is beginning to persuade me... JohnLarson was on my final list. Keep going...
And then he says:JL responds:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Madcrawdad
I concur....JL was insistent on voting for DP for quite some time. Now he writes him off as innocent?
Madcrawdad says:Quote:
Originally Posted by ZSandmann
I hope the Townies that remain are watching what's going on here. I offered up my game life if we could unite and lynch Swayde, but once again we got bamboozled and now the lynch train is gearing up against me.
Madcrawdad says:Quote:
Originally Posted by johnlarson66
I am freaked out. Still more distractions.
Look folks, I am willing to go along with ZSandmann here. I think as a town we either need to go with him or against him.
There are people that talk about uniting and then start another tangent. This makes no sense.
I think in game 4 madcrawdad put his life on the line for a lynch vote and the players took it serious. Now he is not even acknowledging it. It's too late in the game for that kind of statement...At this point, the mafia can choose to play very BOLD. They can even all pile their votes on one candidate. If even one townie waivers and votes elsewhere it's game over. Townies, at this point it has to be all or nothing. The vote cannot be split. A onesie vote here or there can break our back.
It is 8 against 7. We can not miss.
Also, why did the mafia hit DP? There seems to be a lot better targets. I was highly suspicious of DP because they talked of quitting and did not quit, but then did not post again, so maybe they had quit late. I was not voting for DP that day nor would have I been for it, due to the unknown status of them.
I was sure of this, if DP stayed in the game they were mafia, if they quit they were innocent.
I think it comes down to 2 camps, those that follow ZSandmann and those that do not. At this point I feel that anyone that does not follow ZSandmann is mafia.
What is sad, the mafia do not even have to vote for ZSandmann. They can just not vote for Swayde, they can vote for whoever else and muddy everything else. I am not sure how many votes got the lynch yesterday, but I am fairly sure 5 votes will get someone killed.
There are so many other things I would like to post about, but I think we need to stay focused on this. There should be two "Canidates". I think we all agree that one of them is mafia.
Based on last nights votes, I can see where they are both mafia, but the mafia is starting trains for other people, making both these two look like innocents.
Either I am being suckered by ZSandmann or we get our first mafia dead.
Once again, I think we should either vote for ZSandmann or Swayde.
JL says:Quote:
Originally Posted by johnlarson66
Was it too late yesterday?
JL again:
I say:Quote:
Originally Posted by johnlarson66
I think it comes down to 2 camps, those that follow ZSandmann and those that do not. At this point I feel that anyone that does not follow ZSandmann is mafia.
What is sad, the mafia do not even have to vote for ZSandmann. They can just not vote for Swayde, they can vote for whoever else and muddy everything else. I am not sure how many votes got the lynch yesterday, but I am fairly sure 5 votes will get someone killed.
There are so many other things I would like to post about, but I think we need to stay focused on this. There should be two "Canidates". I think we all agree that one of them is mafia.
Based on last nights votes, I can see where they are both mafia, but the mafia is starting trains for other people, making both these two look like innocents.
Either I am being suckered by ZSandmann or we get our first mafia dead.
Once again, I think we should either vote for ZSandmann or Swayde.
Okay, I know this is quite long. I am mostly doing it for myself, to get this stuff in one post so I can reread it easily, but I also hope that maybe someone else can help me see if I am way off base or what. I find it fishy that Dangerdoll was apparently trying to defend JL when it looked like everyone else who commented was suspicious of JL.
Also, I thought it was interesting that in post 1754 DD defends KOTD and insinuates I'm Mafia. And shortly after that, KOTD comes out and says he's starting to believe I'm not innocent.
I know DD's status hasn't been confirmed, but I highly believe she is Mafia and even maybe the Don.
I know DD's status hasn't been confirmed, but I highly believe she is Mafia and even maybe the Don.
I vote to lynch johnlarson66.
I have been quite bad this round at picking out Mafia but you sold me sway. This is preliminary but I want a vote out there so folks can see what's going on.
I have been quite bad this round at picking out Mafia but you sold me sway. This is preliminary but I want a vote out there so folks can see what's going on.
