Mafia #6.....The Play

[Sploke]

Also, another "clue" I noticed, not sure if anyone else did, was given through the voting records.

to lynch...

swayde DD 1607 jl66 1407 kotd 1417 ogre 1610 zsand 1343

nick sploke 1603 jensons 1661 charlie 1365 mee 1475 nick 1612
joan 1437

dwarf jpap 1596 plant 1598

zsand swayde 1412

Give you a hint, the votes are not in order of post number as you would expect.

 

[charlie_stubbs]

I wanted to pull down the "Bala" statue the way the Americans pulled down the "Hussein" statue...

 

[Coler]

I'm going to repeat my thanks to RB for running the game - which was a huge committment.

And I'm going to repeat one of the words from the above sentence : "game"

And finally, with no disrespect intended to anybody, there is a certain amount of bellyaching going on, all from people who enjoyed playing the "'game", which is really a little bit inappropriate...imo only of course.

edit : havn't we thrashed out Mafia Game 6 enough at this stage ?

 

[Madcrawdad]

I'm going to repeat my thanks to RB for running the game - which was a huge committment.

And I'm going to repeat one of the words from the above sentence : "game"

And finally, with no disrespect intended to anybody, there is a certain amount of bellyaching going on, all from people who enjoyed playing the "'game", which is really a little bit inappropriate...imo only of course.

edit : havn't we thrashed out Mafia Game 6 enough at this stage ?

I was thinking the same thing....if everyone had fun, that's all that really matters. If anyone feels that they were cheated out of a million bucks, by all means, continue to complain. Otherwise, chalk it up as 'just a game,' and let's just move on....

 

[jpappy789]

Well I want to complain but I don't see the point. You townies aren't even acknowledeging that fact that some of the clues were way in your advantage when this game was supposed to be fair...a 50/50 chance for each side. We tried our best to handle the situation.

 

[Coler]

its a game

i played for a total of one day

fair ?

no

but its a game

 

[jpappy789]

I know that...we just feel like we were cheated...but I'm going to stop this because I don't see it going anywhere

 

[Coler]

I think that's fair enough - the post-game show has run its course lol

 

[Sploke]

I'm just hoping that by posting some of these apparent problems, we can perhaps discuss how to fix them to minimize improprieties in the future. Its a little bit broader than just whining.

 

[Swayde]

I'm just not seeing how anyone was cheated. The clues clearly didn't help us out all that much. BKW was a toss up between being detective and don based on clues...everyone else was so hard to figure out and I was actually thinking Plantling was Mafia based on the whole "connected" clue. The first 3 mafia lynched were not even mentiond in the clues, they gave themselves away.

That last day when there was no hit is the only justifiable complaint. You guys should have been given your hit, but I don't think it would have mattered. By then we had ya'll pretty much figured out, and we only really used the clues to justify what we'd come up with via reading your posts (or lack thereof.)

I notice that NONE of the Mafia said OMG it's not fair, those poor townies they've lost several of their people because they quit. **** that sucks, now they are at a real disadvantage. But you didn't hear us complain about it, we just kept on fighting the good fight and hunting down the bad guys.