Mafia 62- The Play

[Lab_Rat]

Seems to me you went from your low poster idea and switched it to the highest poster.

More and more I like my vote on Lab_Rat.

No, jpap's frequent posting has absolutely nothing to do with why I chose him. And I'm actually rethinking that choice right now...the only reason you're liking that vote more and more is because you are indeed mafia. You know I will show innocent. This will be a problem for you, since you've led the charge against me which is why you put in this nice disclaimer:

If Lab_Rat comes up innocent, then I can see why noods or anyone voting for Lab_Rat might be a good suspect (including myself).

If Lab_Rat comes up mafia, will Noods still be tomorrows vote?

There is something off with Noods too, and Dawg has raised my suspicions as well. I'd bet my fish that at least 2 of the following 3 are mafia: Noods, JL, Dawg. It could possibly be all 3, though they seem to experienced to pile on a vote like that. I'm gonna go pull some posts from Noods, she's the one primarily setting off my mafia radar at the moment.

 

[noodles62]

There is something off with Noods too, [snip]

:rofl: it took you how many games to note there is something "off" with me?
:silly: sorry, I have been reading stephen king lately and it seems to warp my sense of humor! any other SK fans here?

 

[Lab_Rat]

I see something better. The post above is Noods only post nearly 24hrs into the game. She also states that she almost missed the game. Not very Noods like IME. Even if it's only to get her talking in her normal fashion...

I vote to lynch Noods

Distancing?

well thanks dawg! FYI - I was sick all day yesterday and had not been on the forum at all. This morning I checked before I hopped in the shower before work and noted the game had started. That is all but feel free to read into anything you wish, Lawd knows many of you will! LOL

I do sort of read something into it in retrospect.

well, I s'pose I will go ahead and vote my uselss day one vote before i get on with my own evening.
I vote to lynch Dangerdoll, because I can and it feels good to type! This is subject to change as obviously a lone is useless, but then again it is nite one, so who knows what may or may not present itself.

Downplaying your vote as useless? Why?

You have been active, that does not mean you are a townie. I agree that my vote is largely based on how well you have played the past couple of games but the comments made about Alex and then your vote for him are a bit fishy. As for Rich, no, not suspicious, yet. the banter between Ag and JP seems pretty typical for JP. He finds something to pick at and keeps picking away until he is satisfied. (eeewww, wonder if he picked his scabs as a kid!) LOL

the rest in no particular order:

Ice, I got nothin yet except that he seems resigned to the fact hat he will be hit or lynched early.

Kash, pretty quiet thus far but it is day one..

Zaffy, no read
DD, evil to the core! (JK, I have no idea)
Dawg, no read
JL, no read
Zsand - suspicious as we have not had a "question" yet and it is almost the end of day one!

JB, creeping up on the meter, but this could also be residual from him killing off Santa! :angryfire:

Razz, no read yet.

Obviously, day one has me pretty baffled and right now my vote sits where I feel it is best. This certainly may change as the daylight fades........

oops, forgot the new kid on the block...:huh:
think that is everyone.

So I quoted this before, but you have absolutely no read on anyone? Not willing to hazard any theories? That seems like something mafia would do to fly under the radar.

To the statement in bold above...

...telling us about Alex's style of play is not scummy but voting for him because he is playing the way you say he always does is scummy. Then retracting your vote because of the pressure is equally scummy. Then changing your whole philosophy and voting for the highest poster is scummy again. Since my vote for Noods was more to get her talking than anything else and the above statements have caused me to doubt LR even further then I already did...

I retract my vote for Noods and vote to lynch Lab Rat

As I said before, my vote for him was a random, bogus vote, to help encourage discourse. I never planned to stay with it unless something really came up against him. I explained above that my vote on jpappy had nothing to do with the number of posts he made, rather the intensity for which he was grilling Ag.

I see a case for Lab, not what you guys are pointing out but I can see a lot of finger pointing by her which I never like on Day 1. How can you put so much suspicion on so many people after 1 day? It just adds to the confusion.

This is why I much prefer communicating roles, being unable to communicate outside the thread means I am stuck throwing my ideas out there to see what sticks. I'm not trying to add to the confusion, I'm simply talking out loud. If my fellow townies won't communicate their thoughts then I can't get a read on anyone.


Annie, can we get a vote count?

 

[Lab_Rat]

:rofl: it took you how many games to note there is something "off" with me?
:silly: sorry, I have been reading stephen king lately and it seems to warp my sense of humor! any other SK fans here?

Noods, this is only the second time I've played with you. The first one you got hit pretty quick by Frosty's misplaced snowball. I still don't feel I know the playing styles of anyone well enough to know what their tells are.

 

[Kashta]

Good case and all good points Kash. Just wrong answer to the analysis.

I'm not pleading as much as I'm trying to make the mafia wonder if the Dr will believe me and protect me or not.This way they either don't hit me and the Det can safely investigate me ( Day 4 or later) or hit me while under protection so the Det doesn't need to waste an invest to see I'm innocent.

I think it's more a differing presumption from the start, Ice. You seem to believe you're dead meat as mafia kill on Day 1 or maybe Day 2. (Or that's the angle you're playing from.) But I don't believe that's true and I don't believe the overall concensus among other players here would be that you're an automatic first hit either.

Another point... if you're NOT the Don in this game, I don't see why the Detective shouldn't invest you until Day 4. You've already "come out" as an innocent, right? And the Det is looking for innocents to start with instead of mafia anyway, right? Or... is that just something eles you're trying to pull over on us?

Obviously, I don't know which team you're on this time... but we'll figure that out at some point. All I can say is your game is weird. I think my vote is about as well placed as it would be anywhere else.

 

[AnniesNotOK]

Dawg-0- Zaffy(#28)
Rich-0- ZS(#42)
Alex-0- Lab(#45)
Kash-1- Rich(#46)
Lab-3- JB(#47), JL(#139), Noods(#150), JL(#162), Dawg(#165)
Razz-0- Ag(#48)
Ice-1- Jpap(#53), Kash(#168)
Zaffy-0- Ice(#55)
JL-1- Mich(#57), Ag(#67)
Noods-0- Dawg(#66)
Ag-4- Ice(#70), Razz(#71), ZS(#147), Jpap(#157)
DD-0- Noods(#78)
Jpap-3- Zaffy(#109), Labby(#155), JB(#158)

NIGHTFALL IN ONE HOUR FIFTEEN MINUTES

 

[johnlarson66]

No, jpap's frequent posting has absolutely nothing to do with why I chose him. And I'm actually rethinking that choice right now...the only reason you're liking that vote more and more is because you are indeed mafia. You know I will show innocent. This will be a problem for you, since you've led the charge against me which is why you put in this nice disclaimer:



There is something off with Noods too, and Dawg has raised my suspicions as well. I'd bet my fish that at least 2 of the following 3 are mafia: Noods, JL, Dawg. It could possibly be all 3, though they seem to experienced to pile on a vote like that. I'm gonna go pull some posts from Noods, she's the one primarily setting off my mafia radar at the moment.

So why did you choose to vote jpap?

I don't know if you are innocent or mafia. A good way to find out is to lynch you. So far you are my top suspect. I am not sure if I have "led the charge against" you or if anyone really even trusts me enough to follow me. It is not like their is a train on you. It is day one and someone is going to get lynched. Who is your top suspect now? Any suspects of people not voting for you? Why are two of the three people voting for you mafia or even all three?

 

[johnlarson66]

annie, can you post who has not voted and is in danger of UD?

Thanks

 

[IceH2O]

Another point... if you're NOT the Don in this game, I don't see why the Detective shouldn't invest you until Day 4. You've already "come out" as an innocent, right? And the Det is looking for innocents to start with instead of mafia anyway, right? Or... is that just something eles you're trying to pull over on us?

.

Because no invest the 1st 3 days that show innocent can be deemed 100% innocent (except the Dr) because the Don shows innocent the 1st 3 days.

 

[johnlarson66]

While I like what Kash has said about Ice as I agree with most of it, I don't agree with her vote on Ice when there are 3 players with multiple votes.

I have not seen anyone else even question Ice's plea and change of game play. This is a concern. I would expect jpap amoung others to catch on to some of it.