Mafia 62- The Play

[RazzleFish]

Post #4
Rich

I am proud of you Pap. Second!

Ok, second to post.....

Post #13
Rich

It is a quiet start, by now we should be on trees or pizza toppings.

Not much here.

Post #33
Rich

Some one has to break the ice and get things going. We cannot count for ever. Though it did make it easy to see who had not checked in yet.

Trying to get some info but still not hinting at anyone, but still only day one.

Post #41
Rich

It is amazingly quiet. Only one vote, no random accusations, nothing. maybe we all should randomly vote and see who reacts to getting voted.

Trying to get some info out of people but other than getting some random votes, it didn't do much.

Post #43
Rich

See how easy that was.

In responce to Zs vote on Rich.

Post #46
Rich

I vote to lynch kashta.

Because my last name starts with K. Now that is logic.

Demonstrating how to do a random vote. It would help but we know Kash was innocent.

Post #93
Rich

If he does not vote by 8:00 tomorrow evening he will UD. Knowing JL he will be along. He would not have joined if he didn't think he would be able to play.

Talking about JL's lack of posting.

Post #115
Rich

I was mafia in that game as well. Ag barely played so we told him to keep it up it was working.

JL was quite active.

Talking about when he was on the mafia team with Ag and JL.

Post #156
Rich

The old gut feeling, popular on day one.

I have not really drawn much of a conclusion on anyone. No one has done anything extraordinary.

The strangest voting was from Ag in my opinion with multiple changes and not really for any reason.

I will have to wait and see. I am not all that uncomfortable with my vote on Kashta right now.

In responce to Lab voting to lynch Jpap.

Post #181
Rich

I retract my vote on kashta and vote to lynch Ag.

He is highest on my radar and a vote on kashta serves no purpose and was just for a vote anyway.

Is Ag mafia? Was he onto something here?

Post #193
Rich

Where is DD?

.....

Post #227
Rich

Ok that was ugly.

After the first nightfall.

Post #264
Rich

Pap - either he made a mistake or he was after Ag. I dont think Ag would have been a target for a trap, he was not a strong threat.

Rat - could not wait to get on pap.

Ice - same as everyone else, cant figure what he is doing.

Noods not sure about her. I will watch.

Not really a list just some thoughts. I need to read this with a little attention. I have been bouncing around on other matters. My nephew is a volunteer in Haiti and I was helping his mother get stuff together to send him.

Had Noods on his list but so did a lot of people. Maybe that wasn't the only mafia player he suspected...... Jpap, Lab and Ice. One or more of them could be on the mafia team.

Post #352
Rich

I do not know if I would have pulled off AG if he came out or not. I very well might have. I would have voted for labby if I did.

I don't think pap laid any traps yesterday for Ag and I dont think he is scum.

I don't like that LR voted pap right away. I think she was hoping there would be a train right away and she would be able to hide and get a townie.

Dawg always is on my list. This game very much so, just does not ring true.

Ice seems to be playing like his usual self today and I agree the DR should not come out. I dont like that it even came up.

Noods, and Zsand are making me a bit nervous. We shall see.

Zaffy seems to be helping out.

DD has said less than she usually does and not real substance of any kind. She is on the list.

JL is beating bushes, and right now I will say for the good. That could change and he seems to play the same no matter what he is.

JB is really out their looking for things to go on. Right now it seems to me in a very pro town way.

If I missed anyone it is because they made no impression on me. Our new comer made one weird statement and a vote I think. He also tried to change votes during night fall. Quite odd but it is his first game.

Anyone on that list could be mafia......

Post #422
Rich

I vote to lynch Lab. That immediate vote then back off when no one else jumped with her, just does seem right to me. I think JB and dawg are playing with her.Jb has moved the consensus towards Noods and off of Lab. That is how I have read all of this.

His vote on night 2 was for Lab. A lot of people think she is mafia so that may explain why he was hit......

Post #434
Rich

Sorry my reasoning is not up to you geniuses but it was I got so I am going with it. I think Lab is scum, I do not think Noddles is.

I didn't see it either but this trows me off. Knowing that he is (was) a townie I don't have any reasoning for this.

Post #437
Rich

make that "but it was what I got"

Maybe you guys are right about me being slow o the uptake.

Correcting post #434

Post #443
Rich

What exactly are you saying? You lost me, remember slow down I am not that bright.

In responce to Jpaps question.

Post #445
Rich

I meant as a comparison that noods was after people and makings points about them, LR was defending herself. It was meant to show why I picked one over the other. Noods may be scum as well but I do not see it now so she is townie. There is no grey areas in my world. Probably the ex Army in me.

IDK.......

Then he is hit by the mafia.

I am thinking that Lab is mafia. Rich was thinking that Lab was mafia and then got hit...... Lab, why did you hit Rich? He didn't do anything to you and he didn't catch on to Noods. Why wouldn't you, the Don, choose someone who was leading the charge against one of your other players? I know why. It's because you saw it comming and you wanted to end the "problem" before it stated, right? I think Lab is the Don.

I vote to lynch Lab_Rat.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Sweet, nailed a mafia scum!!!

Sucks the hit was a success, but with rich's vote and how he acted right before nightfall I was leaning him as mafia. It helps clear things up a bit in my mind. DD's vote also makes me less inclined to think scum for her as iirc she could have voted so I would get the lynch instead of her teammate. With the vote as close as it was it would make no sense for her to vote for her teammate.

Razz is now my top mafia suspect. I need to go back and re-read, and will provide my reasoning later. Michwol is also high on my list, I suspect he and Razz are teammates. Dawg is still suspicious to me too, especially with his recent flub.

I'm going to re-read and will post my reasons for him being my strongest suspect.

 

[jpappy789]

Razz, I dont like your thinking there. Rich being innocent has no bearing on what Labs role is...very rarely does the mafia go after people who will be linked back to them. And its not like Rich was making a big fuss about Lab in the first place. He wasnt a threat, in fact, he probably would have been lynched today so I think their move was just to get rid of a random player. It wasnt well thought out at all IMO.

 

[IceH2O]

Does the Don have powers that the goons don't have? Was this a way to protect the Don? I need to check the rules.

I am thinking that Lab is mafia. Rich was thinking that Lab was mafia and then got hit...... Lab, why did you hit Rich? He didn't do anything to you and he didn't catch on to Noods. Why wouldn't you, the Don, choose someone who was leading the charge against one of your other players? I know why. It's because you saw it comming and you wanted to end the "problem" before it stated, right? I think Lab is the Don.

I vote to lynch Lab_Rat.

The Don has no special power. Its one of the reasons I complained that they show innocent the 1st 3 days. The mafia lose nothing by losing him. There was no reason for the Don to show innocent.

Razz I loved your post. It made me laugh. After you are lynched should we lynch Dawg or JL 1st?

JL do you prefer being lynched before or after Dawg?

Dawg same question to you.


Can you guys figure out what my suspect list is?

 

[jpappy789]

I vote to lynch Razz

Might as well...

 

[IceH2O]

I'm bored and the Jet game doesn't start till 3.

Thought I'd go through and pick out my favorite parts of this post.

Post #115
RichTalking about when he was on the mafia team with Ag and JL.

Post #181
Rich


Is Ag mafia? Was he onto something here?


I am thinking that Lab is mafia. Rich was thinking that Lab was mafia and then got hit...... Lab, why did you hit Rich? He didn't do anything to you and he didn't catch on to Noods. Why wouldn't you, the Don, choose someone who was leading the charge against one of your other players? I know why. It's because you saw it comming and you wanted to end the "problem" before it stated, right? I think Lab is the Don.

I vote to lynch Lab_Rat.

So since JL was active as mafia do you think since he isn't as active that means he is innocent?


This was one of my favorite. Ag was the DETECTIVE not mafia and no Rich wasn't onto anything here LOL


Then of course the accusation that Lab was the Don and the reason Rich was taken out over anyone else.




So with all the new revelations do we want to throw out a top 3 or 4 suspect list guys?

I already have mine out but for easy reference:

Are the 2 I have no problem voting for:
Razz
Dawg


Could vote for
JL


3rd tier, not as sure based mostly on voting
Zaffy
Mich

 

[jpappy789]

Updated suspect list:

Razz
Ice
Mich
JL?

I'll put mine in order:

Razz
Mich
JL
Ice

 

[Dangerdoll]

ok, mine in order are

Mich
Razz
JL
Zaff (I still have to look and see his record of posting)

 

[jpappy789]

Something has stuck out to me...

I've seen enough from Pappythat I'll give him the benefit of the doubt for now. I'm gonna keep him on my short list though.

I don't want to vote Lab because I hate landslides, and everyone I suspect aside from Lab herself, and DD are voting on her; Jpap, noodles, Ice.

I don't like Ice's whole deal with begging for protection, if he's scum and the Dr. buys it, it's a guarantee that their hits will go off without a hitch. He's poking at everyone just a bit, which I like though.

Noodles, I suspect for a reason that I'm keeping to myself for right now, I'll see what happens there.

So Zaffy had Noodles as a suspect for an unknown reason. This seems abnormally scummy to me. The fact that he stuck to a single vote also makes me wonder if he didn't want to draw any attention.

Until this is explained I'm switching out Ice for Zaffy on my list. It better be something good, Zaff, not just a contrived reason taken from the siz people who voted for Noods.

 

[Zaffy]

So I'm pretty sure there are no mafia on Noods so the remaining mafia are from the following

Razz
JL
Dawg
Mich
Zaffy


I'd lean towards Razz Mich and Dawg

What if on Noods list she put herself as the lone mafia which was required so as not to call out her "teammates"??

Perhaps the remaining 3 on the list are innocent? Tough to say at this point though.

Something has stuck out to me...



So Zaffy had Noodles as a suspect for an unknown reason. This seems abnormally scummy to me. The fact that he stuck to a single vote also makes me wonder if he didn't want to draw any attention.

Until this is explained I'm switching out Ice for Zaffy on my list. It better be something good, Zaff, not just a contrived reason taken from the siz people who voted for Noods.

Get out your tinfoil hats.

Stephen King is the reason I suspected noodles. In a previous game Annie asked a question about the dark tower series. So I'm not drinking any fluoridated water under the assuption that Annie chose his mafia team out of members of his book club.

I hid this info from everyone because frankly I was embarrased to even think it. But, with noodles coming up scum it's something to wonder about.

Is that contrived enough for you?

I vote to lynch Zsandmann.