mafia 63- Who is Who

[AnniesNotOK]

My vote could end up in one of four places:

1) JL
2) Annie
3) FF
4) Lab

I'm ruling out the first two since I believe one of them is the actual cop, but I honestly have no clue which is which. I'm not willing to give it up to a coin toss nor am I willing to just take a guess.

A vote on Lab really doesn't do much good.

I vote to lynch FF

A mix of scumminess but also a mix of playing it safe.

I believe one of us is telling the truth as well Jpap.

I dont think its in the towns best interest to have a JL vs Annie. We will be risking the Cop (me) for a mafia goon (JL).

I think its best to let the mayor choose which one he believes and investigate.

I would move my vote to Lab.

FF seems like a reasonable choice as well. The more I think about it, the more I think he's a scumbag thats trying to get investigated by his team while kicking up as much dust as he can. Not the greatest strategy, but he has admitted he isn't the greatest strategist...

 

[Fishfriend1]

Good grief. I'm not even sure I want to ask you this, but note the part of your post I turned red.

If in your notes you think "johns the liar", then why exactly are you voting for me?

I may change my mind, in fact i will.

I retract my vote on annie and vote to lynch JL

 

[jbradt]

I believe one of us is telling the truth as well Jpap.

I dont think its in the towns best interest to have a JL vs Annie. We will be risking the Cop (me) for a mafia goon (JL).

I think its best to let the mayor choose which one he believes and investigate.

I would move my vote to Lab.

FF seems like a reasonable choice as well. The more I think about it, the more I think he's a scumbag thats trying to get investigated by his team while kicking up as much dust as he can. Not the greatest strategy, but he has admitted he isn't the greatest strategist...

Wow, Annie.
Thanks for going out on a limb...
And yet your vote is on Jpap... unless I've missed something.

This post really makes me wonder. It seems as though most of the posts are people who don't know anything trying to either figure it out or spread confusion. I have to say though that Labby is the one who makes the most sense to me, and she hasn't wavered in her conviction/argument. I don't know if I believe someone just making it all up could tie it together so neatly.

Hell, I still don't really know what to think.

 

[jpappy789]

I may change my mind, in fact i will.

I retract my vote on annie and vote to lynch JL

:shakehead:

 

[jbradt]

I may change my mind, in fact i will.

I retract my vote on annie and vote to lynch JL

I know I'm going to regret this, but... any particular reason FF?

 

[johnlarson66]

Well, I think going back to the orginal plan is best.

 

[johnlarson66]

I thought that FF1 might be innocent. I am pretty sure I am wrong.

I retract my vote on anniesnotok and vote to lynch fishfriend1.

 

[jbradt]

Well, I think going back to the orginal plan is best.

Which original plan is that JL? I'm still going with my original plan of voting for people I find most scummy.

But, dang; the gap is narrowing...

 

[jbradt]

I thought that FF1 might be innocent. I am pretty sure I am wrong.

I retract my vote on anniesnotok and vote to lynch fishfriend1.

Ok, JL... one for flip flop to question. How are you "pretty sure" you're wrong? What's your evidence/basis for gut feeling?

I'm looking for anything to make sense out of this...

 

[johnlarson66]

Which original plan is that JL? I'm still going with my original plan of voting for people I find most scummy.

But, dang; the gap is narrowing...

As far as my plan, it is simple, not lynch the mayor, not get myself lynched, and hope the mayor looks into me.

So who do you find most scummy?

Once the mayor finds me, I will be placing a hit. If the mayor has not found any mafia, I will hit annie to prove I am the policemen. If I hit someone else, I will announce it first.