Mafia #64 ? Cabin Fever - The Play

Anyone else want to post a top 3?
 
FF, feel free to try again on your list.
 
Wiz- I agree with everything said so far about him hiding behind Kash, but I don't know what to make of her list.

FF- He has a very odd playing style and by the way he was going to "give up" I think he may be a mafia player. Also going off the way he was going to "give up" I do not think he is the madman.

Dag- He just doesn't seem to be trying very hard to help the town. Unless he just isn't posting his thoughts, he may be the madman.

I would feel comfortable voting any of them tonight.
 
Fishfriend1 said:
Ok there are two people on my list, at least two that have goodish reasons bihind them.

Wiz, i think kashta invested u and found u to be evil.

Jl, my gut says so, which means that there is a real reason, i just cant remember it right now.
Click to expand...
your gut says so which is a real reason.... but you can't remember right now? This is not the time to be so wishy washy, FF... at this point, we are at, if we screw up again, we are done.

Fishfriend1 said:
Dag seems to be a good guy, cept that he seems so neutral and raises no scum bells. That alone makes me worry.

she didnt want to be spotted, figuratively, by the bad guys. If she suddenly started pushing for wiz it would have looked suspicious from both sides.
Click to expand...
it worries me that you are saying Dag rings no scumbells while it's proven that he edited a post to make it seem that only Ice was left off of it and no one else... which screams that he was tryng to manipulate things.... not considering that maybe someone would go back and check whatever findings he had come up with.

The point you make about wiz is pretty interesting and surprisingly makes sense however, with your reputation in this game as being so scattered and all over the place, I am not so sure if I can honestly feel comfortable about voting him at this point. I do see though out of these two posts and the evidence of everyone else that Dag might be the one to vote for..... one, because you are so supportive of him and two because of my suspicions on him anyway.

I have a baby shower to go to in a little bit but will be back tonight hopefully. I just want to at least get an early vote out...

I vote to banish Dag
 
IceH2O said:
So instead of pushing for someone she knew was evil she pushed on someone she thought might be evil?
Click to expand...

yep, that way, in her mind, she wouldnt stand out AND would kill a bad guy.
 
Ok so looking at the tally I see that Rich didn't like his lone vote so he voted Kash which tied her up with Annie. But she was 2 on his list after Wiz so that vote would fall in line with his thinking.

DD was a single vote on FF, the 3 previous votes were gone by that time. Her vote at the time wasn't a safe vote because there were no trains at the time and everything was still close but I wonder if she thought the heat was off FF for the day?

FF and Razz both stayed on a player that UDed and made no showing that they would in fact vote by that time. Also Razzs vote was late on Day 2 when Annie had 3 and Kash 2, Razz had been siding with Kash so you'd think the vote would have gone to help save her not to a player about to UD and not really in the running.FF I have no explanations for his actions. There is no rhyme or reason for them I'll probably lean him evil just for his actions.

Dag for reasons stated earlier.

Wiz was the kill vote and had all day to decide where to place a vote. To be fair his posting was leading to Annie. He also had JL and me as suspects.Still has JL but has dropped me off.

Wiz why have I dropped,especially with whats occurred just before night fall till now?


My suspect list in no order

DD
FF
Razz


Dag or Wiz



Think the rest lean innocent.


I retract my vote on Dag for now

I need to look at suspect lists and reasoning and need an answer from Wiz on why he dropped me from his list.
 
u know that there are 4 bad guys right?
 
Dagamoth said:
I know exactly what Kashta means here and for that reason I can't see FF being the madman but it's still possible that he is evil. the madman has been using too much strategy when they picked out the first kill. For that reason I think that we need to focus our attention on someone who has a more intelligible posting style with direct and clearly made points. Not someone who has been all over the place shooting themselves in the foot.

I am going to go back and read through the posts and search them for the people who have made the most concise points in who to banish (with a focus on people making the case to get rid of my sister).


I retract my vote to banish FF.
Click to expand...


Because he posted with in the quote it won't show but I'd recommend going back and looking at it.



He attacks Kash saying she is protecting DD. He ends up voting Kah. Is this an evil attack and Dag is a team mate of DDs is this setup for later in the game if DD dies and shows evil?

Says he could tell Lab was innocent from actions but didn't try to talk us off her. In fact that day he said if she was innocent he didn't want to be responsible for her death because he knows how much she likes to play. Honest or convenient truth to not vote off a known innocent?

Same with Annie, posts as if he knows Annie is innocent

Pointing to a Wiz/Kash team

Subtle point to Rich as possible scum

FF just a noob so I guess he has innocent

Tex on the fence,at this point said some pretty scummy things so would be stupid to say outright innocent

Razz, he agreed with Kash not worth commenting on yet.







Dagamoth said:
people voting for tex might not even want to bother as it looks like he is going to UD unless he pops in and 1 line votes again which would be rather gimp / suspect. anyway i'm off to wedding rehearsal / rehearsal dinner (thankfully not my wedding)
Click to expand...

With both Annie and Kash leading in votes would Dag alert 2 possible team mates to vote on someone else they know are innocent?





This is my quandry. Am I interpreting his list correctly. If so I'll revote him.

If I'm not analyzing it correctly Wiz joins DD Razz and FF.
 
Question to everyone




Nothing formal, no bolding needed, but if you had to vote for Dag or Wiz who would you vote?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom