Mafia 66: Farmers versus the Railroad - the play

[jpappy789]

I don't understand the reasoning behind keeping Noods alive. How does voting Noods expose the other immigrant worker(s)? The mafia still have to guess. If that person is chose to be hit then they die too, along with the RR person. So it's a trade off. If we lynch Noods, we start tipping the numbers in our favor. This game, at its core, will always be about numbers. That's why I've never agreed with "pocket mafia".

I hope JL will clarify the rule. I also would like either Lab or Dawg to explain what they mean because I don't see how lynching Noods in anyway harms the immigrant worker. Even if they are targeted after we lynch Noods they die, but Noods is dead so it's still a tradeoff.

 

[johnlarson66]

...

Can we get clarification from the game mod on this point?

...

I do not think any clarification is needed.

 

[jpappy789]

Great.

I just don't think JL would have let the immigrant workers know the same RR worker's role. That would put one person at a disadvantage especially because they are the only player that would die if an IW was targeted.

 

[Fishfriend1]

well, i think that noods should die, mostly because she would be sacrificed by the mafia to distance or just to replace with a better player. She may even be talking to them right now, deciding how to die and make it look like her allies had no part in helping her.

 

[jpappy789]

That is true. I don't see any problems in lynching Noods right now (unless Dawg or Lab explain it better) but we won't learn much since it'll end up being a huge train.

 

[jpappy789]

Since so many of us keep track of the votes, is it really that much of a bother for someone to post theirs up when it's obvious the game mod isn't here to post one? :headshake2:

Here's what I have and just updated. If I've missed something, let me know.

1 Noods - Kashta 7 Lab 114
3 Kashta - Coler 8 Odin 40 FF 52 Pappy 70 Dawg 108
1 Odin - Noods 59/154
3 Coler - Lab 61 Kashta 67 Lab 214 Dawg 222
2 Lab - Jbradt 77 Rich 88
1 DD - Wizard 143
1 FF - Dag 166

No votes - DD, Annie, Coler

Tied 3-3.

I retract my vote on FF and I vote to lynch Coler.

Coler seems scummier then kashta at this point in the game.

Coler 4, Noods 3.

You know what kashta - I'm going to admit to being heavily influenced by your sarcasm, and to be fair the day I have just had which I wouldn't even begin to try and explain to my best friend. You know I'm in a different time zone so to be perfectly frank, in as much a you say 'nice you could make it' you can stick it where the sun does not shine. That comment is very similar in tone to Dags comment about me not helping the town...eh...ha ha.

I'm going to reinstate my vote to lynch you and I have no intention of staying up towards nightfall to see how that works out. It would be (for me) either yourself or dag and

I vote to lynch Kashta

*yawn* anyone who see a legit reason to lynch me - feel free.

Kash 4, Coler 4. Alone, this doesn't seem all that scummy since Coler had Kash as a suspect and obviously wouldn't want himself in the lead if he had the choice.

well, i am almost out of time and my company has finally left. (not sure why my house has become the friday night hangout?) While i am not against a lone vote on night one, this day has been unusually busy so I would not feel right leaving it as such. Now, where to move? I do not find what Coler has said/done suspicious so not moving there; Kashta/Labby, I find both suspicious......

I retract my vote for odinthejd and vote to lynch Kashta

However, I do find Noods voting there to be scummy. She could have easily held her tongue and let it go to the coin flip if both Kash and Coler were innocent. If it had flipped Kashta then no doubt Noods would be in trouble today but at least she wouldn't have saved Coler...unless she knew that this would bring him down with her.

oh wow! my internet froze up and i did not see coler's vote before I hit post...not good for you kash, but you kinda dug that grave yourself....

Eh, this seems fake. Knowing that Noods is 99.9% mafia I can't believe that this is true. Looks staged and I think she realized that she ended up saving coler from the lynch and tried to make it look like she didn't know that the voting was tied.

I'm comfortable voting either Noods or Coler, although voting Noods still makes more sense to me...unless I can be convinced otherwise why voting Noods puts the IW in danger. I still don't know how Lab (and later Dawg) came to their conclusions so early, but at this point there's nothing that concretely points to scum.

 

[Fishfriend1]

see, i make sense sometimes. :evil_lol:

 

[jpappy789]

Any objections to making it a runoff or sorts? If we go between Noods and Coler maybe we can make the mafia choose between the two but I could easily see them just going with the coin toss too. Maybe try and make it between Noods, Coler, and another top suspect? I'm open to ideas.

 

[Fishfriend1]

a 3 horse race between Cole, Noods (just to get rid of her), and Odin or Annie. They are both under posting.

 

[Fishfriend1]

I just had a reason not to lynch noods, correct me if im wrong, but if we lynch noods the RR still have the same # of peeps they did when the game started right? If we lynch noods then they will get another night in which none of them are in danger. We should keep noods so they wont know who we lynch till it happens. If this idea is stupid plz give reasons, it just came off the top of my head.