Mafia #67 - 50/50 -- The Play

Madcrawdad said:
Pretty sure with scum in the lead, that you'll be fine...



Not sure. It's okay here in a 50/50, but I can see problems in a real mafia game. In a real mafia game if it were a townie to not vote, chances are they wouldn't have been very involved anyway... As a fellow townie, I'd rather see that person cut loose as opposed to giving the mafia a greater chance to lynch a townie of their choice with an extra vote. Not sure which hurts the town more. Definitely worth discussing for sure.



JB was probably half-drunk and half-naked on your scum-den couch....and that's why you switched.



JB was probably half-drunk and half-naked on your scum-den couch....and that's why you switched.



JB was probably half-drunk and half-naked on your scum-den couch....and that's why you switched.



JB was probably half-drunk and half-naked on your scum-den couch....and that's why you switched.



Yeah. It seems like a good reason for a complete 180 and vote switch with only seconds to spare...



Yeah. It seems like a good reason for a complete 180 and vote switch with only seconds to spare...



To save the half-drunk, half-naked JB on your scum-den couch



Yeah. But the way Lab and Annie flipped, there were scum and town on JB...unfortunately, no info can be gleaned



Nice to see you.... hope all is well.
Click to expand...

Well info was gleaned to at least one person possibly a whole communicating side. I think it's probably safe to assume that an innocent was given the extra vote since it appears that Annie was hit by the mafia. I don't think it would be very likely that the communicating mafia would hit someone who was voting along side them. There is however the slight chance that another non com mafia for JB trying to save LR. I really don't know if it will matter though because tank may end up just UDing this time around. (if he does UD does his vote get doubled again before death?)
 
Madcrawdad said:
Nice to see that Rich's last-second voting gymnastics aren't at all interesting to you, JL....
Click to expand...

Yes it is. Your quote of rich and reply is also very odd.

What is the point of it? Am I missing something?

I am not sure what to think of the switch, there was some other switching going on, tomorrow I will look at it more in detail.

Right now I still think Dag is mafia and noods right behind him. I started the day with JB leaning mafia, but as the day went on and the case of his "pocket mafia" was put on him (and his response) I have him more innocent.

I will look more into rich.
 
johnlarson66 said:
I still like Dag and I am unsure why no one else sees what I see. FF still haunts us and people are getting lynched because of him.

I had a busy day here at ELITE ZONE and I am just catching up. (We have a MW2 league with other game centers). I felt good about my vote and even though I was by myself I would have been unwilling to go to either Lab or JB.

I do like the UD rule, but I am guessing that it will just drag out the processes. Why do people sign up and not play? So it looks like someone that was voting JB got the noobs vote -



We also know that both innocent (Lab) and mafia (annie) were voting on JB, so it is real hard to tell what team got the vote. We do know that someone voting on JB is on the opposite side.

The good news is that it looks like the mafia killed one of thier own -



Even thought Lab led the charge on JB, I really don't think he is mafia. I hope people look at the people that have been latching on to LR. I hope the ones that were able to talk to Lab take a look at those people.

My guess is that this list: Mad (848) Noods (849) Dag (856) has more mafia than innocent on it.
Click to expand...

So you're still gunning for me then JL? So out of the people who voted along side LR you think most of them are mafia. Does that mean that communicating innocents sold out LR when there was chance to save her? If they had chance to save her do you think that is why Rich changed his vote at the last second? Do you find Rich's change of heart based on self defense = scum is legit?
 
why is it you have gone two times in a row of wasting your vote JL? Given now that we know the first time was between two innocents but why yesterday? The first time was a vote against FF just protecting yourself from him being SB, but yesterday was a vote against LR without voting for her. Same as day 1..
 
Dagamoth said:
So you're still gunning for me then JL? So out of the people who voted along side LR you think most of them are mafia. Does that mean that communicating innocents sold out LR when there was chance to save her? If they had chance to save her do you think that is why Rich changed his vote at the last second? Do you find Rich's change of heart based on self defense = scum is legit?
Click to expand...

Who voted in self defense. I was in no danger of a lynch.

You brilliant rebuttal of my argument was impressive. Is that all you got?
 
johnlarson66 said:
Yes it is. Your quote of rich and reply is also very odd.

What is the point of it? Am I missing something?

I am not sure what to think of the switch, there was some other switching going on, tomorrow I will look at it more in detail.

Right now I still think Dag is mafia and noods right behind him. I started the day with JB leaning mafia, but as the day went on and the case of his "pocket mafia" was put on him (and his response) I have him more innocent.

I will look more into rich.
Click to expand...

The point is that Rich and JB are scum-buddies.

Yes, other people switched, but Rich did a complete last-minute 180 on his suspects. He then jumped on for a kill vote with not enough time for anyone to react. All to save JB...someone Rich had listed as a suspect up until the last-second switch.

What is there left to look at?

It's pretty clear. Don't you think?
 
Madcrawdad said:
The point is that Rich and JB are scum-buddies.

Yes, other people switched, but Rich did a complete last-minute 180 on his suspects. He then jumped on for a kill vote with not enough time for anyone to react. All to save JB...someone Rich had listed as a suspect up until the last-second switch.

What is there left to look at?

It's pretty clear. Don't you think?
Click to expand...

Of course I could be telling the truth and that I did what I did for the reasons I stated.

You may want to look at others instead of banging away at me, of course you have done that all game, aim and fire with no extraneous thoughts allowed.
 
rich311k said:
No self defense. You should have at least glanced at the vote.

What?

I felt acting with a little dignity was a good sign of a townie.
.
Click to expand...

LR's self defense. You said that since she didn't roll over and take it she was scum. Therefore if you're willing to defend yourself you're scum. I think it is much more likely that JB was doing any last hour defense because he was busy chatting with you in the scum den and talking about last minute vote changes.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom