Mafia #67 - 50/50 -- The Play

[rich311k]

LR's self defense. You said that since she didn't roll over and take it she was scum. Therefore if you're willing to defend yourself you're scum. I think it is much more likely that JB was doing any last hour defense because he was busy chatting with you in the scum den and talking about last minute vote changes.

It was the constant claims of innocence and you will be sorries not a defense that is the issue.

I have not had outside contact with JB that would be against the game rules.

 

[Fishfriend1]

opcorn:

 

[Madcrawdad]

Of course I could be telling the truth and that I did what I did for the reasons I stated.

You may want to look at others instead of banging away at me, of course you have done that all game, aim and fire with no extraneous thoughts allowed.

Funny how Lab's apparent appeal to emotion didn't bother you until JB was about to be lynched... I don't believe that you even mentioned it.

 

[rich311k]

Funny how Lab's apparent appeal to emotion didn't bother you until JB was about to be lynched... I don't believe that you even mentioned it.

I dont think I did either.

 

[IceH2O]

The point is that Rich and JB are scum-buddies.

Yes, other people switched, but Rich did a complete last-minute 180 on his suspects. He then jumped on for a kill vote with not enough time for anyone to react. All to save JB...someone Rich had listed as a suspect up until the last-second switch.

What is there left to look at?

It's pretty clear. Don't you think?

I don't think its as cut and dry as you think. What if JB is also innocent, then the move by Rich saving him also implicates him. Noods did something similar against Coler.

Not saying JB is innocent, just saying its not as cut and dried as you think.

Rich is mafia though.

 

[rich311k]

I don't think its as cut and dry as you think. What if JB is also innocent, then the move by Rich saving him also implicates him. Noods did something similar against Coler.

Not saying JB is innocent, just saying its not as cut and dried as you think.

Rich is mafia though.

Good enough for me. When do we vote.

 

[Madcrawdad]

I don't think its as cut and dry as you think. What if JB is also innocent, then the move by Rich saving him also implicates him. Noods did something similar against Coler.

Not saying JB is innocent, just saying its not as cut and dried as you think.

Rich is mafia though.

If you believe that Rich is mafia, why do you think he would be trying to implicate JB? JB was already implicated...he was about to die.

Makes no sense that Rich would expose himself as scum, in order to implicate a dying town player. He'd have been better off just letting a dying townie go, as opposed to be asking to be lynched along with him.

Whether Rich and JB are in actually in communication, I can't say with certainty. Rich's motives, though, were clearly to save JB...not to implicate him.

Good enough for me. When do we vote.

With nightfall being at 7:00 PM EDT tomorrow, I figure 6:58 would probably be a good time for you...

 

[johnlarson66]

I put most of this on here for my own reference -

JB's vote - I think it is in the afternoon -

I vote to lynch jb.

Just about to head home and I want to be sure to have my vote in. In the odd case I don't get back on the computer.

Mad moves to JB -

Nope. My singleton vote isn't working out and I like JB better...

I retract my vote on Ice
I vote to lynch JB

Noods moves to JB -

well, i would rather see a coin toss.... I retract my lone vote on JL and vote to lynch JB

Dag votes JB -

Yup JB seems much scummier then LR. LR if you die and show mafia I'm gonna be pissed.
I vote to lynch JB. keeping someone around who says they want to be investigated by the mafia is almost as bad as saying you want to be investigated by the mafia.

Rich moves to LR (for the kill)

I retract my vote on JB and vote to lynch LR.

This might be Lab's last words -

And Rich shows his true scum colors... :thumbsdown:

 

[rich311k]

If you believe that Rich is mafia, why do you think he would be trying to implicate JB? JB was already implicated...he was about to die.

Makes no sense that Rich would expose himself as scum, in order to implicate a dying town player. He'd have been better off just letting a dying townie go, as opposed to be asking to be lynched along with him.

Whether Rich and JB are in actually in communication, I can't say with certainty. Rich's motives, though, were clearly to save JB...not to implicate him.



With nightfall being at 7:00 PM EDT tomorrow, I figure 6:58 would probably be a good time for you...

Also could be exactly what I told you. Having nothing to do with saving anyone. Just finding that I did not like my vote and decide to change it. That wont work in your world though. There must be a conspiracy.

Only regret I have about my switch is that you all are wasting time on me and letting the bad guys get away. Of course for you, I am a convenient place to play, with out having to expose yourself.

 

[Madcrawdad]

Also could be exactly what I told you. Having nothing to do with saving anyone. Just finding that I did not like my vote and decide to change it. That wont work in your world though. There must be a conspiracy.

Only regret I have about my switch is that you all are wasting time on me and letting the bad guys get away. Of course for you, I am a convenient place to play, with out having to expose yourself.

You don't regret being the kill vote on a CI?