Mafia #67 - 50/50 -- The Play

[jbradt]

And just curious what was so great about that post. You were the third person to say I still think LR is a townie, which really worked well for you since you are in the same boat as her.

I voted to get rid of FF, there was certainly enough to think he was mafia which would be have been an added bonus, but I voted to be sure he was gone.

For the record I am thinking JB right now. He misquoted me and is picking things I think are not all that tremendous as reasons to suspect folks.

Wow, Rich. Again someone questions my reasons without even the respect to pull the post. All the sudden word twisting and vote jumping aren't good reasons. And I still don't see where I misquoted you, but I'm not going to argue this point either.

 

[jbradt]

This is why I still suspect you.

You keep insisting that we would have learned more from lynching anyone other than FF, which is wishful thinking at best.

You cannot point to the number of posts generated as reason that we would learn something and then not comprehend that FF being on the block generated almost all of those posts. Again, it's a two way street JB.

I see what you're saying here, Pappy; but the way that I look at it is that if there was that much energy behind posting for this game, then the posting would have been there anyway. However we could have directed it toward other things. Things that IMO could have been more productive than the NOTHING that we got from the way it actually turned out. Again, if you gained some grand nugget of wisdom from FF's lynch, then by all means; please share it.

All of this, however is speculation at best..

 

[jbradt]

Because she has in the past and I think this time gone with unwavering certain after someone. She was wrong but she was innocent. The gun slinger game she did not do that.

So I , I know another broken rule, changed my mind. Dare I type the words.

Hey Labby, is Rich on your list? I don't remember because your insistence looking only at FF all day 1 has made me basically disregard your posts... He had a bad idea too! :lipssealedsmilie: He changed his mind though....

 

[jbradt]

Popcorn is delicious and even zombies can enjoy it while watching the game unfold.

Mafia zombies are the best kind of zombies!

 

[jbradt]

If you look back, you'll see I've thought JB was scum from the time he started defending FF. In fact, on the sliding scum scale, JB is significantly more scummy than you are imo. Right now my vote is on who I feel is scummiest. Sorry Ice, you're not it.

I can see your point here, Labby. You thought I was scum since page 4. So you might as well run with it! After all, you were sooooooo right on about FF. :thumbsup:

If you ever want to work on changing this problem, let me know... helping people get through tough obstacles is what I do! For now though, I can see that you're not really interested in changing. And that's okay too.

 

[jbradt]

I was saying I'm not going to let him play me for a fool like he did last time with the same scenario. It was no dare. You're reading way too much into things...dare I say, like I did with FF...

So how 'bout it Labby... am I super scummy because I decided to pull some posts?

 

[jbradt]

So how 'bout it Labby... am I super scummy because I decided to pull some posts?

Sorry, I quoted the wrong post above... not interested enough to go back and fix it right now...

 

[jbradt]

Thanks Dag, I mean Jpap. Why the defense?

Not innocent still doesn't mean should be voted out, SB is still a possible help to the innocent team.


What is your take on the SB? What is everyones take on the SB?

I wish I had the power to blow up half the town right now... clicks heels together 3 times...

****...

 

[jbradt]

For dramatic effect...

How so JB?

Wiz, so now you're going to not go on FF's word and assume he posted lies when innocent? He clearly wanted anyone mafia to investigate him. If you believe that he did this for the stated reason of knowing who was mafia based on votes then it's obvious he wasn't posting that to Lab, since that's what he said.

You cannot believe one thing FF said but then turn around and pick and choose what he said was his true intentions on the basis on implicating someone else.

That's a fair question so I'll answer it... for the same reason Ice is looking at Labby. You bolded the phrase "if the mafia investigate me" and left out the following phrase: they will vote for me. That totally changes the meaning of the whole post.

Then when you say it was for dramatic effect... I've learned from my clients that people who are being dramatic purposely are trying to sell you something. I'm seeing a lot of that going on this game, and not just from you...

 

[jbradt]

Kash, maybe you would like to just answer the question presented then. Your post was filled with other people's viewing about not lynching FF but had no direct correlation to my original question regarding JB's suggestion. I chose to ignore that and counter the parts of your post that did deal with what I specifically asked about.

I, first of all, wanted to know because you said you agreed with what Jb had said. I wanted to know if that included his suggestion since it has been widely regarded as not a good idea, if not scummy.

You seemed to agree with it, or at least made no objections. So I countered because apparently you missed everything said in regards to the the specific suggestion Jb made that keeping FF around EVEN IF MAFIA could help the town.

Even Jb thinks the suggestion was flawed. How can you not?

Pappy, at the time I made the comments they made sense to me. I still stand by my statement that we could have learned more from nearly any other lynch candidate, and possibly saved an innocent. If you've never come up with an idea that you wish you hadn't put out there, go ahead and put your vote down.