Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread

IceH2O said:
Here is my problem Wiz. These are the votes. Post 931.

Plenty of votes fell on other players even after Labs goof. Why would you say the evil team hid on Lab and not point to those not on Lab? Only half the players were on Lab,the other half were spread out on 5 other players. If the evils did pile on Lab to hide then they are the reason she went home. I'm not saying 1 or 2 could be on her but why post just 1 instance and not a counter.

Of the 7 players on the other 5 we know Mad was innocent and Lab was evil. So we're down to 5 players to look at for possible evil.

Wiz
CCM
Rich
Bio
JL

Pretty close to my list
Bio
CCM
Rich
JRR

I still think there are only 3 left. But your posting today is either you trying to hard to save your team from losing or over thinking the situation.

My vote is staying on Bio.

Mael, If you want to make this a 2 horse race I'd rather see CCM then JRR at this time I think. JRR isn't giving us much to work with but CCM has said some strange things in his lists.

I don't really think Wiz and/or JL are evil but if any of the others on the list flip innocent they would be who I replaced them with.
Click to expand...

I'm pretty sure of bio but i was just thinking about what other info we could gain since it doesnt look like others are going to be close to the chopping block today...I dont have ccm as a top suspect per se but I dont have him leaning innocent either. If others have a strong enough opinion of him being scummy and you need my vote there count me in.
 
dirtydawg10 said:
There are 12 players left according to Zaffy's list.
Click to expand...


Thanks I didn't count myself, went off my list of players..
Gives us a little more wiggle room.
 
[AC] maelstrom;2342966 said:
I'm pretty sure of bio but i was just thinking about what other info we could gain since it doesnt look like others are going to be close to the chopping block today...I dont have ccm as a top suspect per se but I dont have him leaning innocent either. If others have a strong enough opinion of him being scummy and you need my vote there count me in.
Click to expand...

Either way I don't think we'd learn much unless the evils make a suicide move or innocents are trusting of an evil player that gets them to lynch an innocent 3rd player.

Might just be safer to take this 1 player at a time. We can all come to an agreement on at least a few players. The less players post at this time the more suspect they will look. So if they are innocent and on everyones lists they better come up with good case why they are innocent and why they think someone else is evil.
 
IceH2O said:
Either way I don't think we'd learn much unless the evils make a suicide move or innocents are trusting of an evil player that gets them to lynch an innocent 3rd player.

Might just be safer to take this 1 player at a time. We can all come to an agreement on at least a few players. The less players post at this time the more suspect they will look. So if they are innocent and on everyones lists they better come up with good case why they are innocent and why they think someone else is evil.
Click to expand...

makes sense.

And I agree with the bottom part...now that you all mention cap he hasnt said anything in quite a long time.

waiting to hear your thoughts ccm.
 
Interesting i expected a lot more chatter today but if it was as beautiful where you all are as it was here I can understand why.

I would think that LR was a foregone conclusion pretty early in the day and I think many a scum was on her. Just like I imagine many are on Bio right now. Why rock the boat and expose your self.

I did not like Jrr's attitude and his lack of sharing his thoughts. I have not talked much but I have shared my thoughts, much to my detriment it seems. I can live with that I was thinking out loud.

I vote to lynch JRR.

I will be around so if you want to go around in circles with me feel free.
 
rich311k said:
Interesting i expected a lot more chatter today but if it was as beautiful where you all are as it was here I can understand why.

I would think that LR was a foregone conclusion pretty early in the day and I think many a scum was on her. Just like I imagine many are on Bio right now. Why rock the boat and expose your self.

I did not like Jrr's attitude and his lack of sharing his thoughts. I have not talked much but I have shared my thoughts, much to my detriment it seems. I can live with that I was thinking out loud.

I vote to lynch JRR.

I will be around so if you want to go around in circles with me feel free.
Click to expand...


I'll bite. Who is on Bio that you suspect to be evil and why?
 
had to run out for a while. am I correct that we are leaving it a one horse race?

I am ok with my vote on Bio but if we need to add another horse in the race I ready to go....

I will continue my reading back from the start will refrain from posting quotes unless I find it really relevent. Apparently my last attempt (earlier today) was not that impressive. LOL
 
oh, and for the record (but I think I alredy put it out there) JRR and CCM are on my short list as well.....
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom