Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread

[IceH2O]

Lets do this Lab. I'll keep my vote on you and you keep yours on me but we call a 24 hr truce and look at others.

Give me a suspect list that has nothing to do with me and I'll do one that has nothing to do with you. That means no linking players as scummy with regards to me and I'll do the same in regards to you.

In no order and without Lab as a suspect ( but she is)


JL- the early vote on FF was fine but keeping it there because of FFs posting is suspect to me. If I had taken a poll in the signup thread if FF would post scummy on Day 1 everyone would have agreed.

CCM- voted FF even though his posting made it sound as if he thought JL was more scummy then moved his vote to JL late in the day to a place it didn't matter.

Dawg- not as certain but seems to be not as active as usual. More of a gut feeling at this time.

Bio- Her vote switch from a lynch candidate to a player that had zero chance of being lynched even if Bio made a great case is very suspect.

JRR- votes without reasons

Rich- also a gut feeling. Rich is hard to read no matter the role. He stays pretty non committal in his posts. They usually consist of seeing both sides.


Everyone one else either hasn't posted enough to make a choice or I'm leaning towards innocent at this time.

In case you want to try and tear my new suspect list apart JL.

 

[Lady G]

Alright. Sorry about not talking much, I have been working ridiculous hours.

Anyway. I really have no suspect on ILM other than the kid likely has no idea how to play. G, you're starting to look less suspect, IMO. Hopefully you're not just a sweet-talker.

After reading a plethora of posts, I have to RETRACT MY VOTE FROM LADY G. I think lab's posts aren't just affected by personal life, I think they may be influenced by a more sinister power, one that we are trying to eradicate. I VOTE TO LYNCH LAB.

Ummm, thanks? Not really sure where I was "sweet". Are you sure your not just switching to Lab because there are so many others on her?

Well, I am starting to realize that I almost need a notebook to keep track of all this stuff....
But, I am leaning towards ILM, Lady and Wiz as scum.
ILM due to his not being here. Seems like someone is telling to him keep quiet.
Lady because she seems to agree with Wiz too much.
Wiz because I feel like he is asking a lot of questions, but not really getting anywhere.

I'm not sure Wiz and I agree so much. He is gunning for John, I however am not sure I think he is scum. I am back and forth on him and a couple others.

Rich what happened in the past 36 hrs or so that made you go from the conclusion that Lab was evil to I am evil? Was it something I said or something she said? If you read as you claimed I hadn't gone against Lab yesterday and instead tried to focus on other players and get her to also. So if you'd kindly explain the sudden change of minds.

Good luck with getting a answer, I'm still waiting and I asked right after he posted. I didn't say the same thing exactly...just asked why you when there are so many others on Lab (something on the lines of that, don't really remember my exact wording).

unless I missed it, bio has yet to comment on anything lab has said...basically spent the entire day bickering with LG and wiz...trying to create a distraction? do you think lab is at all scummy bio?

Ditto, on this one.

 

[IceH2O]

I am running back and forth between the game and fixing dinner and trying to keep up! LOL

There are several players other then ILM that have not voted yet.....interesting.

I have 15 voters. ILM seems to be the only non voter.

 

[BioHazard]

unless I missed it, bio has yet to comment on anything lab has said...basically spent the entire day bickering with LG and wiz...trying to create a distraction? do you think lab is at all scummy bio?

Well, everyone else seems to...
There was a lot of bickering. Perhaps LG, Wiz, and Lab are on a team, and distracting all of us?

 

[noodles62]

I have 15 voters. ILM seems to be the only non voter.

yeah, I just double checked and I missed a couple earlier today.....:huh:

 

[IceH2O]

Good luck with getting a answer, I'm still waiting and I asked right after he posted. I didn't say the same thing exactly...just asked why you when there are so many others on Lab (something on the lines of that, don't really remember my exact wording).

He said he wouldn't be back on till tonight or tomorrow.

 

[johnlarson66]

Did a quick skim and see votes flying all over the place. I'm only on lunch break so not enough time to post everything I'd want but should be home tonight to post more before night.I didn't want to give away my thoughts till more votes were laid out.



I don't have time to find the post but I explained pretty well in one why I thought FF is innocent, doesn't mean I'm right but its my thought process for now.



It is my plan that the reactions brought forth by my coming out like that would pull reactions from a certain group. I don't think mafia would have been the 1st few on me. More likely to be innocents. Mafia wouldn't risk the finger pointing from being 1st on.
Mafia would be more likely to protect me so they could point at the innocents for lynching me when I show innocent.

My list for possible mafia, and I'm hoping there aren't this many but its who should be investigated in no certain order:

Dawg
JL
Wiz
LG
Annie

They are all players that wouldn't vote me and made excuses that I saw as protection,except JL who still chided the idea enough to keep it an option for others to vote but nothing he wanted a part of doing himself.

My next few are players that did vote me. Once a couple of votes fell on me it was safe for mafia to vote me as the finger pointing doesn't hit the middle group as fast.But is necessary to keep the train moving.

Bio
Mael


Noods I would look into just for the fact that at the time she tied me backup with FF but I'm wishy washy on her. I just needed a place to put my vote where I didn't think it would matter to see how other votes fell. Noods could be mafia so I'd also investigate her just because it would bother me not to and her vote is OMGUS.

Thats 8 players to look into, obviously they can't all be mafia unless Zaffy is trying to make this game impossible to win. I'd be willing to think 5 at most. My 3 least expected mafia would be Noods,Mael and Wiz,because he is voting Bio.


Heh I got most of what I wanted to post in after all....

So the list is in "no certain order". It is a list of 8, but if you had to put a top 5, then you would remove the last three. Two, noods and mael you did put last and in a different set, but the list was in "no certain order".

Then instead of Bio being on the bottom, him being in the different set with mael, you put Wiz on the bottom because he is voting Bio.

Maybe it is just me, but I don't understand how your list is not in order, but clearly it is - just not as it pertains to Wiz and Bio.

Also what is odd is that your list of 8 or 5 does not include Lab. Who are you voting for?

 

[noodles62]

Well, everyone else seems to...
There was a lot of bickering. Perhaps LG, Wiz, and Lab are on a team, and distracting all of us?

now who is skirting questions like a politician?!?! Can you please state if YOU feel Labby is scummy?

 

[Lady G]

I dunno,just seemed like a hastily typed post to me, IMO.

How about any of her follow up posts?

 

[the wizard]

Just finished catching up with the days events and saw a few possibilities I didn't think of before.

It was mentioned that scum may have hit Kashta to set JL up, I wouldn't be much of a man if I didn't acknowledge that as a possibility that I didn't think of.

My thoughts were more along the lines of who was Kashta going after when she got hit?

Does it clear JL in my mind?

Not really just means I need to look a little deeper to see what else I can find.

It seems ILM will ud.

If however ILM comes in with a last minute vote, then leaves, I know who to vote tomorrow.