Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread

[dirtydawg10]

Bio, where did LG say that her kids were puking? I know she has two sick kids today, but I reviewed her posts from today, and can't see where she mentions puking. It's possible that I missed it, so can you point that out to me?

To me this still may be an issue since no one ever mentioned puke. I'm surprised anyone would just assume that regardless of the reasoning that followed.

The order of the post is explained in the post. Lab wasn't part of the post because at the time I didn't think lab was evil. This post was typed before the Lab slip post. I posted the newer suspect list for you.

I'm sorry if you can't comprehend the post I thought I laid it out quite well.

Anyone else not understand what I was saying here?

I understood it to mean that they were the bottom 3 people on your list of 8 scum suspects...not that they were the bottom 3 overall out of everyone.

 

[johnlarson66]

Ice's OLD list -

Dawg
JL
Wiz (least)
LG
Annie
Bio
Mael (least)
Noods (least)


Ice's NEW list -

JL
CCM
Dawg
Bio
JRR
Rich

I think Lab is on that list also. Note there is no least group in this list. Maybe Ice feels there might be 7 mafia.

 

[IceH2O]

I just saw that this was before Lab made her remarks.

I still think that it is odd that you had Wiz in the top 5 group, but because his vote was on Bio he was in the bottom 3.

I am sure it is just me not being able to comprehend.

The list states possible mafia.

The top 5 players listed are all players that wouldn't vote me and made excuses that I saw as protection,except JL who still chided the idea enough to keep it an option for others to vote but nothing he wanted a part of doing himself.

So a 5 yr old would understand: These are people who reacted in a certain way to make me suspect them.
Since Wiz was voting Bio at that time I lowered him to less likely mafia of those listed along with Noods and Mael.



Hope that clears it up for you.

 

[IceH2O]

I understood it to mean that they were the bottom 3 people on your list of 8 scum suspects...not that they were the bottom 3 overall out of everyone.

At the time they were the bottom 3 of suspected scum.

I still don't have them as the bottom 3 out of everyone. I don't trust anyone in the game enough to say that.

 

[Lady G]

Post 877 bolds the reasons and hopefully helps everyone understand why they were in the order they were.

I did read that too. I said when I first read it, and I will admit there where times it still kinda "egged" at me. I did understand after reading it several times.

 

[IceH2O]

Ice's OLD list -

Dawg
JL
Wiz (least)
LG
Annie
Bio
Mael (least)
Noods (least)


Ice's NEW list -

JL
CCM
Dawg
Bio
JRR
Rich

I think Lab is on that list also. Note there is no least group in this list. Maybe Ice feels there might be 7 mafia.

Why not just pull the post JL instead of leaving parts out. I even reposted it not long ago.

 

[johnlarson66]

To me this still may be an issue since no one ever mentioned puke. I'm surprised anyone would just assume that regardless of the reasoning that followed.



I understood it to mean that they were the bottom 3 people on your list of 8 scum suspects...not that they were the bottom 3 overall out of everyone.

Then why not have a list of the top 5 and then the next 3. The list was almost like that anyway, except for Bio and Wiz.

The reason Wiz is knocked down is becuase he was voting Bio, but why not knock Bio down because Wiz was voting for Bio.

 

[Zaffy]

Vote count so far.

(2) JL - Wiz(553) CCM(688)
(0) Lady G - JRR(554)
(8) Lab - Ice(556), nood(559), annie(645), lady g(648), maelstrom(653) Dawg(708) DD(816) Lady G(844) JRR(865)
(1) Ice - JL(563), Lab(580), Rich(759)
(2) Wiz - Bio(629) Mad(846)
(1) Noods - Labrat(680)
(1) Annie - JL(793)

No votes from: I Love Mollies

Nightfall in 17 minutes.

 

[johnlarson66]

Why not just pull the post JL instead of leaving parts out. I even reposted it not long ago.

I just made your lists. I did not claim it was a quote. You do not like your Old and New lists?

How come on the New list you did not have 2 that were least likely as you did in the first list or do you think there are 7 mafia?

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

I dont think this has been brought up yet but I find it particularly interesting...

I do have to say the double standards about who is busy irl is amazing. Apparently it's ok if Noods, Rich, Dawg, or Annie claims to be busy, but if Bio or I say we've been busy irl a huge deal is made out of it. I don't get it... :screwy:

If lab indeed slipped before the first nightfall she may have very well slipped again...she certainly seemed flustered enough too drop a teammates name.

i think that if/when lab flips scum I will be voting bio. the fact that she has no firm stance on what lab said makes me think they are teammates.