I get what you are saying..the same thing happened to Charlie when he was the Snitch, and the Detective was told he was the Snitch...
Mafia #7 -- The Play
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
I get what you are saying..the same thing happened to Charlie when he was the Snitch, and the Detective was told he was the Snitch...
The thing is that I don't see why any mafia would try to claim to be the dectective this early. Ice already said, I believe, that he wasn't a power role, so what would they gain by getting one innocent lynched tonight when one of their own would be gone for sure the next night? They wouldn't be getting anywhere. Of course, KOTD COULD be on the other team and gotten lucky by naming Ice as a member of the other, but that is very unlikely as all their investigations for the other mafia tema come up as innocents and he named you as snitch...and I think everybody has posted at least once since KOTD claimed to be det, why hasn't the other "real" det tried to out King? What I mean is that say hypothetically that wata is really the det like Ice thinks, why would she let us get snowed by KOTD tonight? So what if she comes out, at least she would have the docs protection rather than letting a mafia fool us and guide our votes, while getting protection from the doc, leaving the real det open for a hit? I mean none of this has any merit Ice, which leads me to believe you are mafia and King is the real det...
I revoke my vote for King and vote to lynch Ice
edit:sorry I had more and some grammar stuff that was bothering me, corrections in red
I revoke my vote for King and vote to lynch Ice
edit:sorry I had more and some grammar stuff that was bothering me, corrections in red
Last edited:
Just a thought here... King, while I currently believe that you are the detective, I would caution against naming those who you will be investigating. If folks know who you're investigating they'll expect a report the next day regardless of your candidate's guilt or innocence. If one of your investigations turns up a townie and you don't announce the result as mafia, it then paints a target on that player's back for a mafia hit. Example: if you say I'm going to investigate Player A, and you find out that they're the doctor...you certainly wouldn't announce the result of your investigation. BAM! The mafia picks off Player A. Bye bye, Doc.
Make sense?
That's what I was gonna say, mee-mee. In Game 6 BKW investigated Chaz and told us he was Mafia and the snitch.
makes a ton of sense
but i never named who i would be investigating, all i said was i have my eye on them
I see your point, Mad. KOTD should not let on who he investigates nor should he tell us unless he gets a Mafia.
king if you think im gonna just lay back and let you have all the fun your sadly mistaken. nervous wata??? you should be. there is an angry mob coming. your not the detective don't bother trying to sell me any snake oil. your mafium and your going to hang.
yeeee hawwww i love when the detective comes out, its like when your big brother sticks up for you after a bully has pushed you down!!! get em king!!!
