Mafia #7 -- The Play
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
KOTD- So you're 100% sure, but not the detective? Seems the only way you would be able to say that is if you were mafia or am I missing something? Quite a few folks were certain of Swayde's "guilt" too.
I couldn't sleep.
I need to know how KOTD can be 100% sure.
Lets say he is the detective, which I know he isn't because I'm innocent, but lets just say he is.
Why come out? The heat is already on me, the train has already started. What does he gain by coming out? Nothing, all he does is paint a big target on himself to be taken out by the mafia. If he dies the town loses its only weapon against the mafia.
K now lets say he isn't detective. Which I'm sure he isn't.
Either he is trying to buy time and get the Dr to protect him because his name has been mentioned a lot tonight.
He is trying to get the real Det to come out so the mafia can hit him thereby protecting his mafia brethren.
If the Dr protects him all he has to do every night is say that the person he investigated was hit that night. Protects him from his lie.
The real Detective can't come out or it dooms the town. Best he can do is guide us subtly towards the right people. KOTD knows this and either is trying to force him out or will play it for all its worth until he is finally caught. Either way he has put himself in position to take out a few innocents.
I don't trust KOTD and I'm placing my vote on him.
I vote to lynch KOTD
Maybe now I can sleep knowing my vote is on a mafia member this time.
I need to know how KOTD can be 100% sure.
Lets say he is the detective, which I know he isn't because I'm innocent, but lets just say he is.
Why come out? The heat is already on me, the train has already started. What does he gain by coming out? Nothing, all he does is paint a big target on himself to be taken out by the mafia. If he dies the town loses its only weapon against the mafia.
K now lets say he isn't detective. Which I'm sure he isn't.
Either he is trying to buy time and get the Dr to protect him because his name has been mentioned a lot tonight.
He is trying to get the real Det to come out so the mafia can hit him thereby protecting his mafia brethren.
If the Dr protects him all he has to do every night is say that the person he investigated was hit that night. Protects him from his lie.
The real Detective can't come out or it dooms the town. Best he can do is guide us subtly towards the right people. KOTD knows this and either is trying to force him out or will play it for all its worth until he is finally caught. Either way he has put himself in position to take out a few innocents.
I don't trust KOTD and I'm placing my vote on him.
I vote to lynch KOTD
Maybe now I can sleep knowing my vote is on a mafia member this time.
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
Day One is just guessing in the dark.
All of this "looks mafia" stuff is complete BS.
If there are people that think I am mafia because of my day one voting for role playing, then I suggest that you make your move now.
Let's get to the bottom of this.
If you really think I am mafia for voting for the first role player, then by all means vote for me. If this is going to be used against me the whole game, then lets clear it up now.
In the next game, I am going to do the same.
I also know that as a group, we have decided that voting for no body on day one is bad for the town. Well, historicly our lynches have been bad for the town as far as killing an innocent.
What have we learned from last nights lynch train. Almost nothing. We all got a chance to see Ice freak out about the train. The more I think about it and the more I do not see him freaking out about the votes he has on him now makes a good case for him, as an innocent.
We really need to focus on who the mafia hit and who they did not hit.
We also need to think as if we were in the mafia, who would we want to hit. Most of us have been mafia at least once, so we should understand this. If I was mafia, I would not hit Ice, I would let the town lynch him. I have to think who would I hit.
So why did they hit Lady G? Was she onto something. Was what she onto going to put us on a wild goose chase?
vote change
I vote to lynch ZSandmann
Why ZS? The mafia did not kill hit him and he "wanted" me to vote for him on day one.
I also think voting Ice out at this time is a mistake.
All of this "looks mafia" stuff is complete BS.
If there are people that think I am mafia because of my day one voting for role playing, then I suggest that you make your move now.
Let's get to the bottom of this.
If you really think I am mafia for voting for the first role player, then by all means vote for me. If this is going to be used against me the whole game, then lets clear it up now.
In the next game, I am going to do the same.
I also know that as a group, we have decided that voting for no body on day one is bad for the town. Well, historicly our lynches have been bad for the town as far as killing an innocent.
What have we learned from last nights lynch train. Almost nothing. We all got a chance to see Ice freak out about the train. The more I think about it and the more I do not see him freaking out about the votes he has on him now makes a good case for him, as an innocent.
We really need to focus on who the mafia hit and who they did not hit.
We also need to think as if we were in the mafia, who would we want to hit. Most of us have been mafia at least once, so we should understand this. If I was mafia, I would not hit Ice, I would let the town lynch him. I have to think who would I hit.
So why did they hit Lady G? Was she onto something. Was what she onto going to put us on a wild goose chase?
vote change
I vote to lynch ZSandmann
Why ZS? The mafia did not kill hit him and he "wanted" me to vote for him on day one.
I also think voting Ice out at this time is a mistake.
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
Well guys it appears the game is over. According to KOTD if you don't trust someone and vote for them its a mafia move. I guess anyone that votes is now mafia.
Really KOTD, is that the best defense you could come up with?
already explained it
lynch me if you want
Then he pulls his own classic move, including winking eye
Now I agree with this wholeheartedly. The mafia wants to hit who they think aren't lynchable. That is people that they think they would have a hard time getting lynched due to being hard to read or very helpful or low side posters. People that are vocal like myself already put targets on themselves and have lots of posts to twist and turn.
But I don't agree with Z as much. I think Z is lynchable. Maybe not as quickly as others but still lynchable. If anyone stands out for not being hit it is Mad. Historically in these games Coler or Mad have been hit early. Did a hit go out on Mad by the new mafia or is Mad one of the mafia, new or old?
I can't say I see anything on either one at this moment, but since you brought up the lynch vs no lynch I thought I'd have to throw the most obvious name out there.
This post was brought to you by Folgers. If you need a quick pick me up just double the strength we promise you'll think straight.
I would also caution everyone to look at those who jumped on the Ice train so quickly after Jl. There has to be at least 1 mafia maybe 2. I don't think all of them are though with 2 groups its possible. I would look closely at
Jl- just because of the lurking and no posts during the Ice firestorm even though he was reading the thread
KOTD - for the obvious reasons we just went over in the threads since night fall
Jo- already has heat on him and this would be a good deflection of votes. He agreed with me on Sway multiple times and then turned on me as soon as Sway was shown innocent.
Plantling- don't really get a vibe from them but anything is possible, will have to look into their posts a bit harder.
3 of the 4 were also on Sways train until KOTD pulled off and then didn't make another vote.He said he didn't have time but would have voted me. He had enough time to retract, why didn't he just vote then?
Jl- just because of the lurking and no posts during the Ice firestorm even though he was reading the thread
KOTD - for the obvious reasons we just went over in the threads since night fall
Jo- already has heat on him and this would be a good deflection of votes. He agreed with me on Sway multiple times and then turned on me as soon as Sway was shown innocent.
Plantling- don't really get a vibe from them but anything is possible, will have to look into their posts a bit harder.
3 of the 4 were also on Sways train until KOTD pulled off and then didn't make another vote.He said he didn't have time but would have voted me. He had enough time to retract, why didn't he just vote then?
Went through Plantlings posts, not to many of them but all were informative for the most part. I don't think she is mafia at this time.
