Mafia #7 -- The Play

also, the town lynched charlie once they found out. . . .so i don't know if the mafia would have done it instead.
 
wataugamafia,

Do we spare Ice because he might not be mafia or because he is the snitch?

Give us you clear reason sparing Ice.

Oh, I appeared without you saying my name...

Also, the more you post, the more mafia you look.

I look foward to seeing you in the next game also.
 
John, you're just posting because Mad started thinking i looked suspicious, and since i've been commenting on your behavior, now you want to jump on because you feel like you'd be backed up.
 
There's still a chance that if Ice shows up as the snitch for one mafia, KOTD could have investigated him from the other mafia team. Even Ice's role confirmed doesn't clear K 100% (wink wink)
 
wataugachicken said:
post 2 - turns out i was wrong in who i thought

post 153 - was in response to people talking about Rb, not the snitch. Rb's little stories had everyone running in circles

post 178 - so what?

You didn't really expose me, Mad. . . anyone who played in that game or the WW game knows that i was constantly lurking in game 6. that's the difference though - i was lurking, not playing. if i had to go by the reaction of the townspeople to the Snitch, well, charlie had them completely confused over the names. they didn't know who to investigate, or vote for, or anything. i've bee wondering if, since the teams are smaller in this game, that if the snitch only knows the mafia on his own team, maybe we will have an easier time of deciphering the list if Ice doesn't get lynched. I have also wondered in a few posts how important the snitch is to the mafia - if they are very likely to take him out tonight or the next night, then we should start looking for other suspects and let the mafia do our job as well. i for one would like to have at least one snitch list to work with.
Click to expand...

according to the signup thread you were reading intently enough that you were picking mafia, trying to analyze RB's clues, and you were so excited about the game that you almost 'peed' yourself. So why the comment about not being familiar with the snitch? You're as familiar as anyone else who played the game...
 
i don't think that we should spare Ice. the reason i posted the numbers of those other two posts was because i never said that ice was innocent. it was in response to mad saying that i was going to start distancing myself from ice. i was already holding a 10ft pole between him and myself before he tried to say that I was the Detective, but i'm holding it between myself and KOTD too. Ice being mafia, IMO, doesn't prove KOTD being innocent. That's all i'm trying to say. People were already looking at Ice for the whole Swayde train, it didn't start with KOTD.
 
Okay, I think people are looking at what i write but missing what i am trying to SAY:

I have also wondered in a few posts how important the snitch is to the MAFIA - if they are very likely to take him out tonight or the next night, then we should start looking for other suspects and let the mafia do our job as well.
 
In Game 6 charlie had already produced two or three lists, and so had fulfilled his Snitch role. . . I understand why the townspeople were happy to take him out right away because it was later in the game and there was no more use for him. All i want is one list to use before Ice is taken out.
 
wataugachicken said:
In Game 6 charlie had already produced two or three lists, and so had fulfilled his Snitch role. . . I understand why the townspeople were happy to take him out right away because it was later in the game and there was no more use for him. All i want is one list to use before Ice is taken out.
Click to expand...

He gave us a list, your name is on it.

I also think it is odd that you have not changed your vote off of KOTD. Going to place it on Ice? How about me?

Who are you going to vote for?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom