Mafia #7 -- The Play

[plantling]

There's still a chance that if Ice shows up as the snitch for one mafia, KOTD could have investigated him from the other mafia team. Even Ice's role confirmed doesn't clear K 100% (wink wink)

Sploke, per the rules at the beginning:

The Mafia - I will pick a leader among your group to PM me your hit. If the leader dies you will need to send in your own hits/investigations. I won't hold a no vote against you, though it will be frowned upon, whoever has the most votes dies. I might be so downtroddened at a non vote that your name could subconciously be typed onto the hit post that night. Each Mafia group will get an investigation per night, if they investigate another Mafia, it will show as innocent.

So if Ice is lynched and he's Mafia and the Snitch, imo, KOTD is the real detective, not part of the other Mafia.

 

[ZSandmann]

Okay, okay.

I retract my vote for KOTD and vote to lynch LohnLarson

for sitting back, only posting when he is defending himself, not helping the town, and then suddenly becoming interested in the game when I come under fire and he sees an opening to go after the person who has been casting suspicion his way.

Grrr. this doesn't make me feel better.

Is Lohn John's evil twin? I knew that fella looked off a bit. :spam:

Seriously though, better than voting King but I don't think it will buy you any friends. To continue to see the vote as it stands and fight against it is almost too Mafia to be Mafia. But of course you could think that too.

 

[johnlarson66]

He gave us a list, your name is on it.

I also think it is odd that you have not changed your vote off of KOTD. Going to place it on Ice? How about me?

Who are you going to vote for?

Good choice, not much of a surprise.

Am I on your mafia team or the other one? This information will be helpful after you are lynched. Maybe I am the snitch or better yet the Don!

Maybe Ice will jump in here with some thoughts.

 

[wataugachicken]

oops. . .

I vote to lynch JohnLarson

 

[wataugachicken]

Am I on your mafia team or the other one?

Hey. . . wait. . . . that's a trick question!

 

[jpappy789]

This tells me that Ice can't actually reveal his role to the mafia. They might ask for him to put certain names down, but he and they can't discuss it, because he can't actually come out and say that he is the true snitch. The mafia come into the game already knowing that there is going to be a snitch, the don probably says "If someone on my team is the snitch, i want you to give these names". They don't have to discuss it, because it's an order from the Don.

When we first played with the snitch, we (the mafia) never even tried to discuss it until the lists were already out and it was too late. Ice is still a mafia and he still wants his team to win (no matter what he says). He can't come out and directly say "I am the snitch" but the members of his team can bounce ideas off each other and come up with a list that is good enough to fool the town...he is not worth keeping.

 

[plantling]

Hey. . . wait. . . . that's a trick question!

Does this mean you almost answered the trick question?

 

[wataugachicken]

No, i just couldn't come up with anything witty as a come-back.

 

[mee-mee]

Okay, if lets just say King is Mafia, but on the opposite team of Ice (which we know is not possible)...here is the thing...any Mafia that is investigated comes up Innocent on their investigation...the only people that come up with roles are the Major players for us Innocents...so I don't see where you come up with that King could have investigated him from the other Mafia team...makes now sense.....and yet you post but no vote...

There's still a chance that if Ice shows up as the snitch for one mafia, KOTD could have investigated him from the other mafia team. Even Ice's role confirmed doesn't clear K 100% (wink wink)[/quote

The Mafia role...
The Mafia - I will pick a leader among your group to PM me your hit. If the leader dies you will need to send in your own hits/investigations. I won't hold a no vote against you, though it will be frowned upon, whoever has the most votes dies. I might be so downtroddened at a non vote that your name could subconciously be typed onto the hit post that night. Each Mafia group will get an investigation per night, if they investigate another Mafia, it will show as innocent.

So if King were on the other team, how would he even know that Ice was the Snitch and and Old Mafia...the only reason he knew that Ice was from the Old Team and the Snitch is because he is the Detective...

 

[plantling]

But King isn't a new suspect either???
HN has that stray vote on joander, but you haven't jumped over there.
You haven't tried to start a new candidate.
You haven't done anything really. Just say on King who will very soon be outted as either Detective or Liar. And if you look at my previous post you can see which way most of think that will go.

My List:
Lady G
IceH2O - 2
Wataugachicken - 3
joander123 - 4
sploke – 4
DeputyChiefJR - 5
Dangerdoll - 5
johnlarson66 - 5
mee-mee - 5
plantling - 5
Charlie_Stubbs - 6
Hooked Newbie - 6
MadCrawdad - 7
jpappy789 - 7
KingOfTheDeep - 8
Zsandmann
[FONT=&quot]Swayed[/FONT]

Now back to my Pops Cereal. Mmmmmmmm. Sandy tucks into his cereal, sitting on the couch in his modest Dogcatcher home. When the wife's away he gets to play. But right now playing is sitting on the sofa in his boxer's, eating Pops, and watching Sportscenter.

Plantling is working on decorating Sandy's kitchen as requested by "the wife" and she sees that he's left the milk and a box of corn pops sitting on the kitchen table. She murmurs "typical male!" then decides to have a bowl herself while she rethinks the color scheme. Yummm, childhood memories, maybe she can alternate Pops with her other usual morning cereal, Honey Bunches of Oats.

Z, I had you leaning Mafia with you giving KOTD the 3rd degree last night, but this list actually looks good, so you're now more innocentishtish.