Mafia #7 -- The Play
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
I agree. Plantling is a good candidate for investigation. Mee Mee is the worst "bad guy" in the history of the world. Some excellent observations by Mad concerning that crazy post, it had to be written by MP, HN doesn't seem that retarded. That post made my eyes hurt. Only a fool would think that post is helpful. Looks more like what you would get if you gave a hundred monkeys a hundred typewriters. I'm glad Mad caught her mistake or myself and many others would have missed it. Good work Mad, i was starting to lean you towards mafium, now i'm leaning you back the other way.
yep. you got it my investigative friend. by the list of confirmed innocents there are two of nine spots left. Once i insert my name into one of the slots, and Madcrawdad into the other, the remaining players must be mafia. Good job on the stolen hit Jpap, you likely saved the doctor!!! Let's bring it home, and avenge our lost townies. Any investigation is a good one now.
Hmmmm...I have been thinking. Maybe we should investigate and try to find an innocent? That leaves one more person who could be innocent with the rest mafia for sure...just a thought...
Here are my thoughts....
We have a known pool of innocents with which to fill 6 townie slots
King
JL
Wata
JPap
Madcrawdad
Now I know that JPap and I aren't KNOWN innocents, but if we believe RB's clue and the fact that Old School/New School Mafia look to be split by number of games that a player has played, that means JPap or I cannot be New School Mafia....As we've pegged all of the original Old School mafia, we can't be that either...
That leaves the following folks to fill the ONE remaining townie spot.
Deputy
Joander
Plantling
Charlie
King, as every investigation may be your last (in the event the doctor is hit), instead of looking for the mafia folks in the 4 remaining, we should actually try to find the innocent in the list....everyone else then has to be mafia. Even in the event your investigation fails (god forbid you hit mafia
) We're still okay as we know that we won't be lynching an innocent.If you hit innocent on your investigation, and we run the table on the remaining 3, if it's still 'game on' we KNOW that MP has to be mafia....
Thoughts anyone?
Wow, guys, crazy day!
I had to go to dinner at my grandmother's house so i was gone most of yesterday afternoon and night. we had three kinds of sausage prepared various ways. And she served pulled pork barbeque, but for some reason wanted to put it over pasta salad. : (
This mee-mee stuff has been totally crazy. I vote for Mee-mee
I had to go to dinner at my grandmother's house so i was gone most of yesterday afternoon and night. we had three kinds of sausage prepared various ways. And she served pulled pork barbeque, but for some reason wanted to put it over pasta salad. : (
This mee-mee stuff has been totally crazy. I vote for Mee-mee
Here are my thoughts....
We have a known pool of innocents with which to fill 6 townie slots
King
JL
Wata
JPap
Madcrawdad
Now I know that JPap and I aren't KNOWN innocents, but if we believe RB's clue and the fact that Old School/New School Mafia look to be split by number of games that a player has played, that means JPap or I cannot be New School Mafia....As we've pegged all of the original Old School mafia, we can't be that either...
That leaves the following folks to fill the ONE remaining townie spot.
Deputy
Joander
Plantling
Charlie
King, as every investigation may be your last (in the event the doctor is hit), instead of looking for the mafia folks in the 4 remaining, we should actually try to find the innocent in the list....everyone else then has to be mafia. Even in the event your investigation fails (god forbid you hit mafia
If you hit innocent on your investigation, and we run the table on the remaining 3, if it's still 'game on' we KNOW that MP has to be mafia....
Thoughts anyone?
Mad, I am innocent and the thief...I posted that last night
But no worries
Mad, I am innocent and the thief...I posted that last night
I realize that, but unless KOTD were to investigate you couldn't be known 100% (but I do believe you)....notice my joke (albeit a bad one) about you stealing my idea.
