Mafia #7 -- The Play

Jpap, you may certainly be the thief, but i am still unsure of whether or not the thief is definitely an innocent. i checked the wiki mafia game explanation and it said it could go either way.

Innocents have the Detective and the Doctor
Mafia has limited investigations and Snitch
Innocents have the Kidnapper (a useless confused one who doesn't know what to do still), so. . . maybe to even it out the mafia has the Thief.

I don't know this for sure, and i'm not going one way or another because i don't have proof or clarification, but it makes me a little wary of following your lead just in case my theory is correct.
 
Jpap, you may certainly be the thief, but i am still unsure of whether or not the thief is definitely an innocent. i checked the wiki mafia game explanation and it said it could go either way.

Innocents have the Detective and the Doctor
Mafia has limited investigations and Snitch
Innocents have the Kidnapper (a useless confused one who doesn't know what to do still), so. . . maybe to even it out the mafia has the Thief.

I don't know this for sure, and i'm not going one way or another because i don't have proof or clarification, but it makes me a little wary of following your lead just in case my theory is correct.

Understood wata...but I did save the hit. I know if I was mafia I could say it was to try to prove I was innocent but that would not get me very far.

But at this point I am a wastde investigation...let's get through the remaining players and find out whether the game is over or not.

At this point the only thing one of the mafia members can do is claim to be the doc. That will be worthless though...so I don't expect any posting from them...
 
Jpap, you may certainly be the thief, but i am still unsure of whether or not the thief is definitely an innocent. i checked the wiki mafia game explanation and it said it could go either way.

Innocents have the Detective and the Doctor
Mafia has limited investigations and Snitch
Innocents have the Kidnapper (a useless confused one who doesn't know what to do still), so. . . maybe to even it out the mafia has the Thief.

I don't know this for sure, and i'm not going one way or another because i don't have proof or clarification, but it makes me a little wary of following your lead just in case my theory is correct.

Wata...I understand your concern, but based on the number of games played by all of the dead mafia, Old School/New School assignment appears to have been decided by number of games played. If JPap were mafia, it would have to be on the Old School side, and we've found all of the original members there....
 
Jpap, steve erwin?

Not much has gone on really. It is obvious that out of the list you posted, that all is mafia but one. There are five known innocents, and we have to find the last one. I understand that i am not a known innocent, But by all means, KOTD investigate me.

I personally would like to know what MP is. He is playing totally out there, and some of his posts are very hard to follow.
 
I vote to lynch mee-mee.

I didn't expect night to fall again so soon, so I've been running errands all day thinking I had tonight to read posts and vote. I still have to go pick up my kid from school in a bit and will be off on more errands after, so I don't have time to say much except I think the Mafia has set a well orchestrated plan in motion to make at least one of them blend in. Also the clue RB gave us is useful generally, but it's not a straight shot. Not all the oldest players are old Mafia and not all the newest are new.
 
AquariaCentral.com