Mafia 72-Vampires game thread

jbradt said:
Another thought... what if FF is the slayer? Same question goes for anyone we pick. Obviously, that person then has no choice but to either use the stake on a hunch; or wait to use it. Both of which I think are bad ideas.

I hate to sounds like a negative nelly, but from work I've been trained to look at worst-case scenarios vs. maximum utility.
Click to expand...

I see waht you are saying and understand your caution. Short of the slayer coming out (which I am not suggesting they do!) we would just have to go on faith and our best instincts; some better then others!
 
noodles62 said:
I think it is pretty obvious that Dag has been truthful in his RC so I would seriously hope that the slayer would not risk that. By leaving the slayer to stake Wiz, there is the chance that the vamps could bite the slayer and kill him/her before he has a chance to get him. If we use the town stake to take out Wiz it is a sure thing that he will be killed and leave the slayers stake to take out the next top suspect. I could definitely see LG as the top suspect.
JB, what is your read on FF at this time?
Click to expand...
If I had to guess right now, I would say innocent.
 
jbradt said:
Another thought... what if FF is the slayer? Same question goes for anyone we pick. Obviously, that person then has no choice but to either use the stake on a hunch; or wait to use it. Both of which I think are bad ideas.

I hate to sounds like a negative nelly, but from work I've been trained to look at worst-case scenarios vs. maximum utility.
Click to expand...

Yes but if we stake the slayer as the town vote, then they would lose the stake all together and we would lose an innocent townie. If we stake a known vampire and decide that the slayer should stake themselves that gives them the opportunity to not get killed themselves. I think if that were to be the case the slayer would just hold on to the stake and hope that my investigation would produce a vampire.
 
I find it quite surprising how many are hesitating placing their vote on Wiz. Am I the only one that really believes Dag?
 
Dagamoth said:
Yes but if we stake the slayer as the town vote, then they would lose the stake all together and we would lose an innocent townie. If we stake a known vampire and decide that the slayer should stake themselves that gives them the opportunity to not get killed themselves. I think if that were to be the case the slayer would just hold on to the stake and hope that my investigation would produce a vampire.
Click to expand...
Like I said, if that's how you guys want to go; I'm in. Just give the word.
 
noodles62 said:
I find it quite surprising how many are hesitating placing their vote on Wiz. Am I the only one that really believes Dag?
Click to expand...
I'm just waiting to see if that's the way we want to go.
 
jbradt said:
Like I said, if that's how you guys want to go; I'm in. Just give the word.
Click to expand...

It is really the way I am most comfortable. We need to take out at least 1 vampire tonight. If the town stakes the slayer on accident we definitely won't kill a vampire. With the low probability chance that the vampires try to turn the slayer and win the coin toss before slayer gets to stake we would still have taken out a vampire and prevented them from gaining a new one. Along with me being able to check someone out.
 
Dagamoth said:
It is really the way I am most comfortable. We need to take out at least 1 vampire tonight. If the town stakes the slayer on accident we definitely won't kill a vampire. With the low probability chance that the vampires try to turn the slayer and win the coin toss before slayer gets to stake we would still have taken out a vampire and prevented them from gaining a new one. Along with me being able to check someone out.
Click to expand...
'Nuff said...

I vote to stake Wiz.
 
Fishfriend1 said:
IDk why this came last. Hmm, molotov cocktail=Dag, Wiz, or Chill as turn.

I vote for option A.


I vote to stab a stake into Chill (again) for the same reasons. Placing vote early in case I can't make it tomorrow.
Click to expand...


This post really bothers me. Frist he questions why the UD came last. :duh:
Second he names Dag, Wiz or Chill as the possible turn?? This makes no sense. Dag has been cleared as inno, Wiz has been proven a vamp. Was there a reason he named Chill as well? Distancing or finger pointing.....

Makes me really distrust FF.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom