Interesting theories... I think Jm is acting suspicious. I am going to have limited posting, so for now, *I vote to lynch jm* (sorry, can't do bold from the iPod.)
Mafia 73: Werewolf Game!
- Thread starter Fishfriend1
- Start date
Jm, I know that is false because I read through a few games you have played and joke votes have been posted on D1. I've even seen you do it at least once.
Zaffy and Pappy pull the same quote and both respond to it in a similar tone.
Okay, so they were on the thread at the same time and saw/responded to the same post. By itself, that isn't anything, I know.
Then here, Zaffy goes on to jump on Pappy in response to JB... but for what? Because Pappy agrees with what Zaffy's been saying too?
You know, guys. You're both sounding like dual cross-examiners here. Don't get me wrong, you're both making good points about different people that I agree we should examine. But the two of you sound almost interchangeable and this tag team thing with alternating posts directed at whoever posted last is making my head spin.
After that, this post was directed to Chill from Zaffy.
And that was followed by this post to Rocker from Pappy.
However...... at this same time, both of you totally overlooked a direct question I posted earlier to all the experienced players. I posted that because I really want to know what others think.... including you.
@Pappy - How many werewolves do you think we should estimate there are in this game?
@Zaffy - How many werewolves do you think we should estimate there are in this game?
And, again... I'm not directing that question only to Pappy and Zaffy. I'd also like some input about this from Chill, Dag, Lab Rat, Lady G, Rich, and Wizard. (And yes, I'll repeat that again to each of you, if you don't respond to this.)
I think in this game it's important for us to discuss numbers. We usually do that anyway very early in the game whenever it's a non-standard game format.
In this round we have 15 players. The town side has 3 non-communicating PRs and 3 townies who communicate but have no power. That's almost half the field. Then on the scum side, they get an opportunity to possibly turn people.
How does everyone figure we should factor that in to make a best guess at the number of werewolves we're dealing with?
Okay, so they were on the thread at the same time and saw/responded to the same post. By itself, that isn't anything, I know.
Then here, Zaffy goes on to jump on Pappy in response to JB... but for what? Because Pappy agrees with what Zaffy's been saying too?
You know, guys. You're both sounding like dual cross-examiners here. Don't get me wrong, you're both making good points about different people that I agree we should examine. But the two of you sound almost interchangeable and this tag team thing with alternating posts directed at whoever posted last is making my head spin.
After that, this post was directed to Chill from Zaffy.
And that was followed by this post to Rocker from Pappy.
However...... at this same time, both of you totally overlooked a direct question I posted earlier to all the experienced players. I posted that because I really want to know what others think.... including you.
@Pappy - How many werewolves do you think we should estimate there are in this game?
@Zaffy - How many werewolves do you think we should estimate there are in this game?
And, again... I'm not directing that question only to Pappy and Zaffy. I'd also like some input about this from Chill, Dag, Lab Rat, Lady G, Rich, and Wizard. (And yes, I'll repeat that again to each of you, if you don't respond to this.)
I think in this game it's important for us to discuss numbers. We usually do that anyway very early in the game whenever it's a non-standard game format.
In this round we have 15 players. The town side has 3 non-communicating PRs and 3 townies who communicate but have no power. That's almost half the field. Then on the scum side, they get an opportunity to possibly turn people.
How does everyone figure we should factor that in to make a best guess at the number of werewolves we're dealing with?
Kashta, I do agree with you, but why would one need to know how many werewolves there are? I'm not saying it's unimportant, I'm just not sure why you would need to know that.
Kash, I didn't overlook it entirely...I just don't remember any more than what you said and forgot to comment on it. That game was a long time ago and like you I'm not sifting through every post in that thread to count all the wolves that were killed.
With FF it's hard to even guesstimate how many evils we started with...with 15 players in a normal round I probably would have done 3-4 personally but there certainly are a lot of townie PRs and since FF has repeated time and time again that the games should not be easy we could easily be dealing with more wolves if he wanted to even up numbers for them.
With FF it's hard to even guesstimate how many evils we started with...with 15 players in a normal round I probably would have done 3-4 personally but there certainly are a lot of townie PRs and since FF has repeated time and time again that the games should not be easy we could easily be dealing with more wolves if he wanted to even up numbers for them.
I'm thinking that there's 4-6 werewolves. I think that would let ff even up the power since last game, I think there was only 3 and they lost. Just my opinion.
Another thing is that turns don't come into play unless we kill all but the alpha. I don't think it is something we should really consider at this point if discussing strategy.
