Mafia #74...ACville Penitentiary!

[Zaffy]

What I saw in UN as we were nearing nightfall was how jumpy he seemed about keeping his vote on Pir. I switched my vote late because I finally saw that with my own eyes. When I went back and read his posts, I was reading his words without much of the ongoing daily context with them.

As it turns out pir was innocent, so this raises the question of whether or not UN was getting freaked out about being "caught on an innocent." Which is understandable if you're a new player. His worry about JM "almost" being lynched last game I think is ridiculous because JM wasn't lynched last game, and the person who was lynched in his place on day 1 was a town PR.

This is why I'm going to go ahead and:

I vote to shiv UN


Ice, I didn't edit that post at all. I intentionally left the "vote" unbolded because it was a joke, and I made the text white so that I could indicate that in case someone picked up on the post and wanted to use it against me.

Mystery Solved.

 

[TwoHobbies]

This post bugs me. You easily let Jm and User off the hook but then assume that Pir is suddenly trying to throw the entire town a new one? Doesn't sit right with me.

I'm really not sure what you think I should have done Pap? The town at the time of this post had already decided it was going to be a two person run off, my options were UN, Pir, or a third person wasted vote. Pir at the time seemed to me to be the better choice.

 

[TwoHobbies]

2H:
I haven't pulled all 11 posts, because they were Largely :bs:. Here's the stuff I found that was actually game related.
Apparently, me, Zaffy and Vixen are suspects here. But I'm having trouble figuring out whether any of this is actual suspicion or joking. What say you, 2H? This is also the infamous slip re: Zaffy. It did take you a while to answer that question, 2H even though a couple people asked you about it. That worries me. If you are evil, maybe you took what Pir said about ignoring a question once to heart? He played a good game last time as scum... I can see another noob picking up on his hints.



Finally you answer the question. Did you feel responding to Tay would be easier than Labby? Also, who did you kick at... and when? I looked though all your posts and I must have missed that part... :huh:.

Pot, meet kettle. You can call UN out for not being "into the game", but at least he's posting and giving people a chance to read him. Let me reiterate that you've posted 11 times since the start of the game, and most of it has been pointless. (That being said, UN is on deck for scrutiny).

2H's response to Labby pointing out that he didn't answer her question about his comment re: Zaffy when he was asked before. Not sure if I buy it.

So you voted an innocent. That happens and I can't fault you for it. But where was any suspicion on Pir before this post? Did you really vote him because he played a good game last time? You call out UN for not reading the rules... I don't understand why you would play the game and not bother to post anything related. This all seems really off to me 2H. And "missing" this post or failing to respond will likely draw my d2 vote.

You of all people JB, should know I don't shy away from questions.

I can't say as any of you three at the time were suspects, just three that I kicked at to help get the game going, but NOW that you mention it!!

I think I answered that question yesterday. If lab asked me, I MISSED IT.

Answered that one for Pap already.

As far as not helping the town much. I'm sorry I really don't feel I'm a good enough player to play offense, and defense at the same time. Not exactly the Sisters of St Marys that have been after me.

 

[rich311k]

Right now I am thinking UN or JM. Is UN just scatter brained and throwing out posts or did he get himself in a bind?

JM made some questionable posts and made what seemed to be a mistake as he misread posts. I do not know if that still applies as the result of the lynch does not bear that out.

 

[jm1212]

What I saw in UN as we were nearing nightfall was how jumpy he seemed about keeping his vote on Pir. I switched my vote late because I finally saw that with my own eyes. When I went back and read his posts, I was reading his words without much of the ongoing daily context with them.

As it turns out pir was innocent, so this raises the question of whether or not UN was getting freaked out about being "caught on an innocent." Which is understandable if you're a new player. His worry about JM "almost" being lynched last game I think is ridiculous because JM wasn't lynched last game, and the person who was lynched in his place on day 1 was a town PR.

This is why I'm going to go ahead and:

I vote to shiv UN


Ice, I didn't edit that post at all. I intentionally left the "vote" unbolded because it was a joke, and I made the text white so that I could indicate that in case someone picked up on the post and wanted to use it against me.

Mystery Solved.

speaking of that, i believe he voted for me.

right now, i think i could vote UN but it is way to early in Day 2 for me to vote since there are still about 36 hours left and we only have one switch.

 

[jbradt]

You of all people JB, should know I don't shy away from questions.

I can't say as any of you three at the time were suspects, just three that I kicked at to help get the game going, but NOW that you mention it!!

I think I answered that question yesterday. If lab asked me, I MISSED IT.

Answered that one for Pap already.

As far as not helping the town much. I'm sorry I really don't feel I'm a good enough player to play offense, and defense at the same time. Not exactly the Sisters of St Marys that have been after me.

Why do you say me "of all people"?

 

[jm1212]

doubleplus hypocrite

I have to say Bally, for someone that has self-proclaimed that you picked up the words on your own and the run of the game, you have done almost nothing to help the town. most of your posts have been like this one, pretty much useless.

 

[jm1212]

User, make up your mind.

see, here we have another wonderful post. i said this before, but you have been really finger pointy, and telling someone to make up their mind in this game is just scummy. in this game, the odds of actually finding a snitch tonight or last night are so low that just 'making up your mind' that quickly can be hard. why not try to contribute some of your own opinions instead of badgering the other players?

 

[jbradt]

see, here we have another wonderful post. i said this before, but you have been really finger pointy, and telling someone to make up their mind in this game is just scummy. in this game, the odds of actually finding a snitch tonight or last night are so low that just 'making up your mind' that quickly can be hard. why not try to contribute some of your own opinions instead of badgering the other players?

I hate to be picky, JM... but why do you say that the odds of finding scum tonight are as bad as they were last night? Almost sounds like you're putting an excuse out there "in case" you end up voting an innocent...

 

[jm1212]

I hate to be picky, JM... but why do you say that the odds of finding scum tonight are as bad as they were last night? Almost sounds like you're putting an excuse out there "in case" you end up voting an innocent...

well they arent 'as bad' but they are still low.