Mafia #76 Game Thread: Revenge of the Nerds

saying you had experience since day one of Mafia on AC implies that you have been around from the very beginning in the first game.


I will be back later....need to nurse the hernia operation and do some water changes..feel free to wait until you can confer with your scum team mates in your den...or post nonsense until they show up..it is Saturday after all.
 
Well I said "I CAN"T MAKE UP MY MIND" about dawg had I said nope I think he's 100% innocent without good reason to back it up then I would have been given crap for that.


No one has taken JM as truth for the entire game. He jumps in makes this one post and then everyone agrees with him.

Like I said I am fine being lynched tonight, yeah another geek down, but you know what at least we will have a direction in which to go after scum.

It was a pretty convincing post, especially since there really was no pressure on the scum team to do something as drastic as role claiming from what I can tell.
 
It was a pretty convincing post, especially since there really was no pressure on the scum team to do something as drastic as role claiming from what I can tell.

then why was a scum the first to do so?
 
I wasn't sure of Dawg on day one, I have never played with him and how he went from questioning PP to kinda protecting him it caught my attention.

Lab I investigated you because you were going to be my day 2 vote because of the banter about the dare, but I found you to be innocent.

The scum doesn't have any pressure on them right now, they are just trying to get as many innocents in a night as possible. They have gotten an innocent on every vote and on every lynch and then the bonus of the UD's. The scum are trying to get you to vote to lynch me, and then they can get a second innocent on the hit, and then just win this game even faster.
 
I wasn't sure of Dawg on day one, I have never played with him and how he went from questioning PP to kinda protecting him it caught my attention.

Lab I investigated you because you were going to be my day 2 vote because of the banter about the dare, but I found you to be innocent.

The scum doesn't have any pressure on them right now, they are just trying to get as many innocents in a night as possible. They have gotten an innocent on every vote and on every lynch and then the bonus of the UD's. The scum are trying to get you to vote to lynch me, and then they can get a second innocent on the hit, and then just win this game even faster.

Well, you wouldn't have gotten the investigation results until after night 2, so why wasn't I your day 2 vote?

How do you feel about voting to lynch Ice, DD, or RB?
 
I know I wouldn't have gotten the results till after day 2, I investigated you then so on the next day I could build a case. I wanted to vote for you but didn't have a solid argument based off of the dare votes, so I sent in the pm and asked about you intending to build a case as the results of that vote. We has already lost so many geeks I wans't going to vote or start to build a case until I was sure.

Ice - a strong player that distributes his questioning among players and doesn't seem to focus on any particular individual.
Rb - has been absent for the majority of the game and at first I found that suspicious but I didn't know he was off for surgery.
DD - I have confused her with LG quite a bit in the game. She seems very sarcastic and dismissive ( laughing off/joking about other peoples questions ). I don't know if this is her normal mafia persona or if she feels "safe" in with the scum that if anyone gets too close they can send out the hit
 
Ice - a strong player that distributes his questioning among players and doesn't seem to focus on any particular individual.
Rb - has been absent for the majority of the game and at first I found that suspicious but I didn't know he was off for surgery.
DD - I have confused her with LG quite a bit in the game. She seems very sarcastic and dismissive ( laughing off/joking about other peoples questions ). I don't know if this is her normal mafia persona or if she feels "safe" in with the scum that if anyone gets too close they can send out the hit

You didn't answer my question...how do you feel about voting for any of them? Also, who is on your scum list?
 
I would vote for DD out of those 3. Ice brings up valuable points on many players but if he proves to be scum then his points are twisted. and Rb hasn't said much I'd like to see more on him.

Jm is on my scum list at the very tip top, after him i'm still deciding.
 
AquariaCentral.com