Mafia #76 Game Thread: Revenge of the Nerds

Rbishop said:
ermmm...thats what the whole game is about....evil always accuses others of not helping, while all the do is get innocents convinced another is evil or imply it. Tell you what JM, vote me and everybody else "follow" tonight. PLEASE do so.....and when the geek goes....guess they will vote you the next night....DARE everyone to vote me....
Click to expand...

im not into dares.
 
IceH2O said:
Pretty much. I guess we could name some suspects in case we're the ones hit tonight.

If FF is evil: my top 4 no order

DD
RB
PP
Razz

If FF is innocent: My top 4 no order

JM
Dawg
PP
Razz

If I survive the night I'll give my reasons
Click to expand...

Now that I'm thinking Ice is scum, I'm loving this post. Note, he'll know FF will show innocent, so the if/then style is beautiful. On his "if evil" list, which he assumes we'll overlook since FF will show innocent, he lists 3 that I suspect are his teammates: DD, RB, and PP. But knowing FF is innocent, he knows we'll focus more on his "if innocent" list. Notice he's got PP listed third, perfect distancing spot, and drops his more hidden teammates off the list. This if/then style allows him the opportunity to mention his teammates without putting them in unnecessary danger.

Dangerdoll said:
man.... 3 more geeks... not good at all

again, I vote to lynch JM
Click to expand...

DD, this really bugs me when it's combined with the fact you didn't know jpap was gone. It's not like Zaffy didn't bold the names of who was gone, it was all bolded so even a skimmer can't miss it. I think you saw a message in the scum den of "woo hoo, got 3 more geeks" and then came to post without looking who it was.

IceH2O said:
Ok I was thinking last night when I went to bed and since I'm less sure of Dawg being jock because of reasoning I do want to add Bally back into the mix. Her 1st day of being on JB from the start for no reason other then she thinks he was hiding in plain sight and then yesterday while questioning FF all day she waited till there were more then enough votes on him before she jumped on.
Click to expand...

Already setting Bally up for the sacrifice.

Ballyhoo said:
Jm- he is erratic, inconsistent and generally vague and confusing
PP- seems as if he slipped up at some point in the beginning and was told to hush, or he was just going along with day 1 banter and joking around and enjoying role playing. I can't rule him one way or another.
RB and DD- very quite but from playing the last game with them they seem to be more active at night. I'd like to see more from them
Razz- I don't feel as uneasy with razz as I did before, I realized my mistake and then how little sense my post made. ( Razz I'm sorry for calling you a girl )

I'm having a hard time getting a read on
Tay
Chill
Ice
Noods and Mav
Click to expand...

Love that my scum team list includes those that seem on your list for distancing reasons. Are DD and RB more active at night in your scum den?

Ballyhoo said:
I can't make up my mind about Dawg
I don't consider Lab a threat to the town
And rich is on the fence I am back and forth reading the thread still.
Click to expand...

If you really investigated Dawg on night 1 you would have said that you're leaning him innocent or haven't seen anything scummy from him.

Ballyhoo said:
LG being innocent has cleared lab in my mind. Lab and LG have played together often and Lab says LG has a tendency to protect scum and she didn't try to protect lab and LG came up innocent, and the tone was too light between lab and LG.

Dawg is getting more suspicious to me in the fact that he jumped on PP for learning how to multiquote so quickly and then flipped and protected him at one point.

Rich isn't that suspicious to me, last game when I played scum with him he was much quieter and this game he has been much more vocal.
Click to expand...

Totally wouldn't have said that if you'd investigated him night 1. This is not a game with turns.

noodles62 said:
Checking in real quick - (I have to be quick or I get called "rude"!) :silly:

Labby, I voted for you because of the long exchange between you and G. It really pinged my meter and did not want to let it slip by. when I pulled the posts from you about LG, I expected to come up with something that confirmed my suspicion. After seeing it all together and then thinking about it some more, I did not find what I thought. I have not had the luxury of spending enough time (all at once) to look into other players yet. my vote will most likely move, but not sure where yet.....



more later, after mom leaves and i get a quick shower....
Click to expand...

Noods, where was the more to follow? Never saw your reasoning.

Chill said:
Okay DD knows we lost 3 geeks but now doesn't know one of them was Pap? I'm having trouble with that.
Click to expand...

Me too Chill, a whole lot of trouble with that.
 
Rbishop said:
but I could give a pass on Lab....maybe even switch the choice to mav...
Click to expand...

What's the deal with this? One minute you're calling your vote on Lab for the next night and then you suddenly change your mind? What makes Mav a better choice than Lab?

And if you don't believe JM, does that mean you believe Bally?
 
This may sound crazy, but I don't like how freaking quickly Ice and DD voted to lynch Bally. I'm pretty darn sure both of them are scum, and that Bally is, but part of me thinks we should lynch Ice or DD instead of Bally. Any one else think that is a good idea?
 
Taysius said:
What's the deal with this? One minute you're calling your vote on Lab for the next night and then you suddenly change your mind? What makes Mav a better choice than Lab?

And if you don't believe JM, does that mean you believe Bally?
Click to expand...

lol...finished reading the posts before posting....

I'd believe Bally way before believing JM...
 
Well I said "I CAN"T MAKE UP MY MIND" about dawg had I said nope I think he's 100% innocent without good reason to back it up then I would have been given crap for that.


No one has taken JM as truth for the entire game. He jumps in makes this one post and then everyone agrees with him.

Like I said I am fine being lynched tonight, yeah another geek down, but you know what at least we will have a direction in which to go after scum.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom