Pir was saying that we should guess the scum team by seeing who would be handpicked, which would lead to voting those players off. I was explaining how wrong that idea was, and why Pir would suggest that.
Mafia #77 Game thread- Back to the basics
- Thread starter jpappy789
- Start date
So you say you think she is playing differently than when she was scum? and that bothers you WHY?
I never said that it bothered me, i wanted to prove a point. Bally had accused me of playing more confident than my previously sloppy and unorganized self. So I asked her why she changed her playstyle to prove a point.
There is a big difference here User, she was pointing out your change yes, but it was a change from when you were innocent. You on the other hand are pointing out the fact she isn't playing as she did when evil.
I never really thought about it that way.
My post looks quite stupid and scummy to me now in hindsight.
:hitting:
Dear god people, proof your posts to make sure the quotes aren't all jacked up. I couldn't even get through all that because I couldn't figure out who said what and who was being quoted.
I don't know, what did they tell you? Did they not say anything? Sure sounds like you've admitted to being on a team, and seeing as it's day 1, the only team possible to be on is the scum team.
Are you threatening to make me the hit? Me thinks that overconfidence may have come from the scum den telling you not to worry about a lone vote thrown on you on day 1.
Yes LG, those were my thoughts as well.
That is a stretch Ice. Plus, that would imply that then entire scum team (or most of it) would jump on a noob day 1 for a scummy looking post. That would make no sense. Actually, I'm quite surprised you haven't questioned him about what he said/meant with those two posts. Were you hoping they'd slide under the radar? Are you now going to sacrifice a teammate for the good of the scum team since his posts have seemed scummy to many?
I don't know, what did they tell you? Did they not say anything? Sure sounds like you've admitted to being on a team, and seeing as it's day 1, the only team possible to be on is the scum team.
Are you threatening to make me the hit? Me thinks that overconfidence may have come from the scum den telling you not to worry about a lone vote thrown on you on day 1.
Yes LG, those were my thoughts as well.
That is a stretch Ice. Plus, that would imply that then entire scum team (or most of it) would jump on a noob day 1 for a scummy looking post. That would make no sense. Actually, I'm quite surprised you haven't questioned him about what he said/meant with those two posts. Were you hoping they'd slide under the radar? Are you now going to sacrifice a teammate for the good of the scum team since his posts have seemed scummy to many?
Ya, tell me about it! It makes catching up a little harder than normal!
Honestly, I don't know what's happening.:nilly:
I have seen Pir and S4S talked about a lot but the only one I can see going anywhere with is Pir. I do find his post about Bally's style scummy, but enough for a vote? Not yet. As for S4S it is really odd that a noob already seems to know what to say and not to say on D1 and also seems to know D1 banter isn't something to get too caught up on........ If I remember correctly, didn't you say in the sign-up that you had followed several previous games? I have to go check on that one.
Ice, if only it were that easy to pick out the scum team based on two letter nicknames!
Pretty sure it was Hayden who said they'd read several games. S4S did not say anything like that iirc. How can you deny that what S4S said is scummy?
Razz, you seem much more active than normal yourself. Last game I remember you being super active day 1 then backing way off, and you were scum. Wonder if the same thing is going to happen again this game...
