Mafia #77 Game thread- Back to the basics

I agree with JB. There are just as many reasons why Pappy may have chosen him as a PR as there are reasons for scum. On the same hand there are others who have similar reasons of why they could be scum vs pr and the more we give out names the easier it gets for the mafia to cross off innocents and hit the PRs.
 
JB hasn't said anything.....

This is the second time you've mixed up names. The first time it was about Un and Pir and i let it slide because of the quote mess up, but now it's just getting odd.
 
Ballyhoo said:
JB hasn't said anything.....

This is the second time you've mixed up names. The first time it was about Un and Pir and i let it slide because of the quote mess up, but now it's just getting odd.
Click to expand...
Crap I even thought JM. Sorry I didn't mean to type JB.........:huh:
 
Lab_Rat said:
Maybe Razz is pulling a card out of JM's playbook. :duh:
Click to expand...
He has a playbook?!?!?!

JM, can I borrow that sometime?!?! :grinno:
 
well Lab running with your avatar idea he could be mafia and talking to Jb somewhere else.
But the avatar theory isn't conclusive so who really knows.
 
Ballyhoo said:
well Lab running with your avatar idea he could be mafia and talking to Jb somewhere else.
But the avatar theory isn't conclusive so who really knows.
Click to expand...

Yeah, I know it's a shot in the dark, but day 1 is usually a shot in the dark. I know from my experience that it would not be unreasonable to think Dawg was picked as Don by jpap based on his title line. I also find it interesting that Ice jumps in quickly to try and discredit that thought, then is gone when I mention that maybe he is the snitch.

My other option for the vote so far is S4S, but I'd hate to vote a noob day 1 (though what he's posted is very hard to overlook). Piranha and UN had some interesting interactions as well.
 
Lab_Rat said:
So jpap could have picked Dawg for another reason that I'm missing...if he's scum then who cares? Of course we've yet to hear from Dawg, but it's early day 1, I have no problem with my vote on him.
Click to expand...

im just saying that is a really odd reason and you really shouldnt base a whole case on that either. that would be like saying you are scum because you have rat in your name.
 
jm1212 said:
im just saying that is a really odd reason and you really shouldnt base a whole case on that either. that would be like saying you are scum because you have rat in your name.
Click to expand...

It's not like it's an uber strong case where I'm like OMG, he must be Don! More like, well, it's day 1, there's not much to go on, but based on history it's not an unreasonable day 1 vote.

You have a point, that could have been used by jpap as well, though I happen to know that it was not.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom