Mafia #77 Game thread- Back to the basics

Kashta said:
FFS Labby. A wildass theory at the last minute is one thing, but waiting like that when you intend to role claim?? That gave the town absolutely no time to evaluate which part(s) of your post to believe (or discount)... and still have time act upon it.

That role claim alone would have saved you. And without taking out another innocent in your place if you were wrong. Your theory was nothing more than just another theory. But we could have and should have been discussed in the thread if you'd only told everyone that part of it. The scum didn't know your role. And had your theory been correct (which would have implicated you as the doctor as well), then that knowledge would have been WAY more important to the entire town than the life of one townie PR.
Click to expand...

I have to say that I agree here. You handled that wrong LR and cost us a good player and the Dr with one last minute post.

Sorry you were hit and sad to see you go Ice.
 
Zaffy said:
There were 9 minutes between her RC and night. Not to mention just about everyone was hovering over the thread at that point.

It could have been anyone. I agree that we should be looking for scum, but focusing on who had it out for Labby, (or who didn't) won't give us real useful info.
Click to expand...

Lady G said:
Not sure I'm quite ready to go on another "what if", "who would", "who wouldn't" theory right now!
Personally I think ANYONE playing that is mafia would of hit her, she flat out said she was the DR, they would of been stupid not to put the hit on her
Click to expand...

Exactly. Who wouldn't have changed their hit to Lab Rat at that point?
 
I vote to lynch Piranha.

Reasons are the same as before. I think his whole Blackmail scheme is ridiculous. In light of Labby turning up innocent, (Pir wouldn't have known she's the doc yet). I feel like he used that as an attempt to protect her and buddy up to someone who he knew would flip town that night.
 
I guess it is time to wade back through the D1 mess and try to figure something out.

My head hurts just thinking about that.
 
the wizard said:
I have to say that I agree here. You handled that wrong LR and cost us a good player and the Dr with one last minute post.

Sorry you were hit and sad to see you go Ice.
Click to expand...

That's very easy to say now but the votes were very close right up till night. It could have gone any way and why would Lab out her role unless it was certain she would be gone. Votes were all over the place on Ice, Lab and Salt and we would have lost the doc and another innocent anyway. The only thing that may have been different is we would still have Ice. Which is definitely a good thing...don't get me wrong.
 
RazzleFish said:
Who was complaining? We aren't allowed to have reactions?
Click to expand...
Dawg and Rich. I'm just saying we shouldn't sit around.
Zaffy said:
There were 9 minutes between her RC and night. Not to mention just about everyone was hovering over the thread at that point.

It could have been anyone. I agree that we should be looking for scum, but focusing on who had it out for Labby, (or who didn't) won't give us real useful info.
Click to expand...
Oh, I didn't realize it was that long.
Zaffy said:
I vote to lynch Piranha.

Reasons are the same as before. I think his whole Blackmail scheme is ridiculous. In light of Labby turning up innocent, (Pir wouldn't have known she's the doc yet). I feel like he used that as an attempt to protect her and buddy up to someone who he knew would flip town that night.
Click to expand...
Can you explain that a bit better...?


I still think Haydn is scummy and I don't even know if I'm going to be on tomorrow, so I vote to lynch Haydn.
 
dirtydawg10 said:
That's very easy to say now but the votes were very close right up till night. It could have gone any way and why would Lab out her role unless it was certain she would be gone. Votes were all over the place on Ice, Lab and Salt and we would have lost the doc and another innocent anyway. The only thing that may have been different is we would still have Ice. Which is definitely a good thing...don't get me wrong.
Click to expand...
How do you know Salt is innocent?
 
dirtydawg10 said:
That's very easy to say now but the votes were very close right up till night. It could have gone any way and why would Lab out her role unless it was certain she would be gone. Votes were all over the place on Ice, Lab and Salt and we would have lost the doc and another innocent anyway. The only thing that may have been different is we would still have Ice. Which is definitely a good thing...don't get me wrong.
Click to expand...

Dawg, I think the point to be learned here is it would have been okay for Labby to post about either her theory or to role claim her role... just not both at the same time with little time left for us to process/discuss both pieces of info together.

Lab is the one who took herself out of the game based on the posts she made. I'd say the same is also true for Ice. He's the one who put himself up for lynching when he decided to post about someone by name that he thought was a townie PR. Us vets keep telling the noobs not to do this... ever. Had Ice followed that same advice, he'd still be alive now. When the rest of us were compelled to switch off Lab Rat after she RCd, Ice wouldn't have been in the running based on lingering doubts about his allegiance that he drew upon himself.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom