Mafia #77 Game thread- Back to the basics

[Chill]

If we are both lying then who ever this 3rd detective is might as well get lynched because you all will not believe him anyway. I don't think this town can agree on how to spell cat anymore.

Of course this or part of this will now get quoted 16 times as more great evidence of a grand mafia scheme.

If there is a third detective please do not come out, this could all be a scheme to get you to expose yourself.

 

[the wizard]

I need to get off to work, I will mull over this more but I think I know where my vote will most likely go.

I will be back in plenty of time to make my vote.

 

[Lady G]

If there is a third detective please do not come out, this could all be a scheme to get you to expose yourself.

AGREED!!!!!!

 

[rich311k]

Now you do the same thing Haydn just did. If you are the detective you know you were not investigated. I was leaning believing you more than Pir but ever since you asked that question about why would two mafia come out I been a whole lot less certain.

That was a tongue in cheek comment.

I am done. You all will do what you want anyway. I will invest and report in the morning if I am still here.

Zaf is scum. You will find that out for your selves sooner or later.

Pir is lying.

 

[Chill]

Thanks rich, at least someone has some brains around here if everyone votes to lynch pirana and finds he is scum then you will all know I'm telling the truth... I know I haven't been investigated, especially by pirana so therefore he is lying to get another innocent lynched... I hope everyone understands this.

Sorry Pir showing scum doesn't clear you, he could easily have implicated a team mate so when you show scum we would trust him.

 

[rich311k]

AGREED!!!!!!

You all are the densest bunch of people.

I think Pir is the detective vote for me.

 

[Haydn24]

Whatever, you will soon see you are making a foolish mistake and I WILL see pirana in death chat pirana, your awfully quiet.. Wanna reply?

 

[Haydn24]

Sorry Pir showing scum doesn't clear you, he could easily have implicated a team mate so when you show scum we would trust him.

But I won't show scum.

 

[Kashta]

Haydn, have you not thought this through or are you twisting it around on purpose?

Thanks rich, at least someone has some brains around here if everyone votes to lynch pirana and finds he is scum then you will all know I'm telling the truth... I know I haven't been investigated, especially by pirana so therefore he is lying to get another innocent lynched... I hope everyone understands this.

If Hay is mafia, he is a threat period. I have know idea why Pir does what he does, but just because he didn't investigate who you would of, doesn't make his reason any less valid.


IF he is lynched and found mafia, it will not clear you in anyway.

If pir is lying, how does that make me scum LG?

Clearing you as a townie and proving you are scum are not the same thing. You and Pir could BOTH be mafia -- therefore, a fake role claim proved false (Pir lynched and flipping mafia) does not prove you are innocent. Thus, you are still not cleared.

Pir could be your teammate, false role claimed, but told us the truth about your role.

 

[Haydn24]

You have a detective telling you pir is lying and you still believe pir...wow.