Mafia 78- The Gunslinger Returns...The Play

rich311k said:
I also was quite serious about my thoughts on giving FF the gun. There is almost no way I would ever shoot him and subject the rest of you to him with power.
Click to expand...

Yet you would still consider shooting someone who has just started playing? Would you rather have someone with at least some experience or a complete newb to have the gun?
 
jbradt said:
Was it an electric prod? Did it hurt? =)
Click to expand...

This is the old west. We use hot branding Irons to "prod"

(sorry I couldn't resist. it is difficult to be serious all the time)
 
the wizard said:
I find it interesting that you post this as well as(and I couldn't find the post quickly so will just state its content) your "idea" about a list after I have been just short of screaming these things all day.

For a noob you do seem very well coached. You claim to have read 1 previous game.

Others that have followed and read multiple games don't post as calmly as you do when they finally sign up to play.

I have less than 24 hours to shoot. I must say you aren't looking too healthy right now.

Please, no responses about how you are innocent. If you did read any game at all you would know that those pleas don't sway anyone's opinion.
Click to expand...
Wiz, I wouldn't shoot him if I were you. Give him a bit of slack, it's his first game, and if he does turn out scum, do you want a first timer as the GS? I'm good with whatever you decide on, but wait for more evidence on him I think...
 
jbradt said:
Sure you can... no need to ask.

Dang, I'm going to be in everyone's sig pretty soon. :grinyes:
Click to expand...

That's because you are such a wonderful person (with a secret internet crush on zombie Kashta) :raspberry:
 
Friend just left and Panther game is on but wanted to touch base.


the wizard said:
OK, I am seeing some posting coming along and that is good.

However I am beginning to think that the few questions I asked were not the right questions. ( I would still like to see the answers though)

Let me ask the town this, and that includes you scum too.

If YOU were the gunslinger, and had to take your shot right now at this very moment, WHO would you shoot and WHY?
Click to expand...

I'll get back to you. I haven't had time to go through the thread again and read reactions to certain posts and how they fit in with other posts.

I don't know if this will help until I get back but I'm thinking right now that those after me would more likely be innocent. The mafia doesn't want me to get the gun and when I did they would think I'd concentrate on those that went after me.

Don't know what I'll find once I get to reread but I'm going with that in mind and hoping to get connections from posts and lists.



Kashta said:
1. Ice could be sincerely trying to approach this in a similar way as he did the last gunslinger game because that worked out well for him and the town in the end. In that case, Ice would be innocent. The problem with this explanation, though, is this is a different game. Ice is not the gunslinger now.... so he should not be the one calling the shots (so to speak) or trying to sucker people in.

2. Ice and I tend to go round and round like this, just about every game we're both in. I often misread his seeming "scummy" posts and conclude he must therefore be evil. Too often, I've been wrong before when I'm too quick to decide about him one way or another and that ended up hurting the town in past games (when it turned out we were both innocent). Since I already recognize this as a drawback, I make it a point to be (at least try to be) extra objective and less apt to make a snap judgment about Ice until there's more time to observe his game.
Click to expand...

No I'm not the Slinger right now but why can't I ask questions that might help me when I am?

How am I calling the shots?

How do these questions not benefit any possible slinger?

Again I don't care if I look scummy. Actually by looking scummy I think I'll learn more about the players.
 
the wizard said:
That's because you are such a wonderful person (with a secret internet crush on zombie Kashta) :raspberry:
Click to expand...
:laugh:

You're half right.
 
Piranha86 said:
Wiz, I wouldn't shoot him if I were you. Give him a bit of slack, it's his first game, and if he does turn out scum, do you want a first timer as the GS? I'm good with whatever you decide on, but wait for more evidence on him I think...
Click to expand...
Sorry, doesn't*
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom