Mafia 79:Bio Badlands Game Thread.

[Lady G]

My list would be
Sploke
Bally
JL
Pir

Top being most likely scum

Don't be so quick to lower John so much...he is a "fighter" for his team when he is on one, I would put nothing past him. I could easily see him being on a team with Razz, even though they voted each other. The fact Razz was the tying vote on him says nothing to me, John would definatly put himself up to make a team mate look good. Had the coin landed on him and he died...think would you of lowered Razz as a suspect if John was evil, most likley:grinyes:
This is why the vial is so important to me, if it wasn't really used then what other reason would John have to pretend to have been effected by it

Sploke REALLY has me feeling scum too.

 

[Chill]

So what are the possabilities here we have four possible evils:
Sploke
Bally
JL
Pir

and three possible tools
Test
Invest
Vial

If JL is faking a babble he is likely evil.
Sploke has just been setting off bad vibes for me.
Bally has been very low key could be the third evil.
Pir was put in when evil were at a bit of a disadvantage which to my mind means FF would likely make him evil.

 

[Chill]

My inclination is test Sploke
Use the vial on JL - he can't fake a second babble
Invest Bally
save Pir for tomorrow.
I haven't thought this fully through though yet so if you see holes point them out.

 

[Lady G]

My inclination is test Sploke
Use the vial on JL - he can't fake a second babble
Invest Bally
save Pir for tomorrow.
I haven't thought this fully through though yet so if you see holes point them out.

Or we could test Sploke/John, vial the other and invest them. The invest would tell what they were before they were vialed?

I think FF needs to clear up something though, it does say if a vial is used it would be revealed and which one, if it wasn't used then why is there only three left. That needs to be answered.

 

[Chill]

Either way if we convert JL or Sploke to evil and Pir and Bally are all ready evil then we have a 3-3 situation.

 

[Chill]

Or we could test Sploke/John, vial the other and invest them. The invest would tell what they were before they were vialed?

I think FF needs to clear up something though, it does say if a vial is used it would be revealed and which one, if it wasn't used then why is there only three left. That needs to be answered.

I agree what about it FF was the vial used?

 

[Lady G]

Either way if we convert JL or Sploke to evil and Pir and Bally are all ready evil then we have a 3-3 situation.

True, there is also the death vial and may still be the babble we have no idea.

Hopefully FF will clear this up soon and we can proceed from there. We have till tomorrow to figure out how we want to go about this.

 

[Lady G]

Well for the time being, Sploke still is my highest suspect until FF answers...if it comes out the vial was not used and there still are 4 left well then obviously that is going to change.

 

[TwoHobbies]

Don't be so quick to lower John so much...he is a "fighter" for his team when he is on one, I would put nothing past him. I could easily see him being on a team with Razz, even though they voted each other. The fact Razz was the tying vote on him says nothing to me, John would definatly put himself up to make a team mate look good. Had the coin landed on him and he died...think would you of lowered Razz as a suspect if John was evil, most likley:grinyes:
This is why the vial is so important to me, if it wasn't really used then what other reason would John have to pretend to have been effected by it

Sploke REALLY has me feeling scum too.

Lady G it's not that I don't see your point....because I do. I just see it differently.
Maybe it would be easier for me to except if I understood what John had to gain by faking a babble.
And I'm willing to move John down my list based on the fact he has the only vote on a known scum.
Sploke and Bally have only cast votes on innocents.

 

[Lady G]

Lady G it's not that I don't see your point....because I do. I just see it differently.
Maybe it would be easier for me to except if I understood what John had to gain by faking a babble.
And I'm willing to move John down my list based on the fact he has the only vote on a known scum.
Sploke and Bally have only cast votes on innocents.

The fact he has a vote on known scum doesn't really clear him in my mind, I know he will vote team mates and have team mates vote him. I know it seems as though he would have nothing to gain, the only real "gain" would be the fact we would think UN used it on him and the babble is no longer in play. Until FF clears things up though, really it doesn't matter much because we have no idea.