Mafia 80: Ghost Hunters

[the wizard]

Not like Kashta to RC though, she doesn't care for it and has said many times in the past how it can often screw up a game.

Although I can see your point about the write up of the protection, I don't see Kashta making a false RC either. I will trust her today but not Monday.

 

[noodles62]

Razz, would you car to expand on this list a little bit? I don't seem to understand that the only one you are getting a scum read on is Rich. That is amazing since many of the vets cannot ever get a read on him.

I also notice you have not contributed a whole lot after reading your posts.

As much as your name has come up I would think you would at least try to put on a show of trying to help the town.

Excellent points Wiz! :clap:

That does not help the town. Might as well dig in and see what you can unearth.

You are innocent so rather than try to help the town you are going to be quiet and let the town lynch you?

Seems a defeatist attitude if you ask me. Everyone that voted FF were wrong, with the exception of any scum that voted there.

Where would we be if every one that voted FF just gave up?

Thoughts on Bally's stance - which I completely agree with. If you are indeed innocent why would you just give up and let the scum win? I have made amny mistakes in these games (trust me!) but giving up is not a good sign....I feel pretty good with my vote where it is for now....



Kashta, wow! just wow! I just skimmed your post so I did not lose my train of thought on the above posts. I will come back with my thoughts on that in a bit......

 

[Kashta]

So Kash apparently protected herself last night...it's hard to match that up with what LG said at nightfall...unless Kash herself is the orb and the arms are from Bala?

Not exactly a solid reason to doubt Kash, but I do have to doubt her claim nonetheless. Hard to definitively believe she is telling the truth. But also hard to come up with why she would lie at this point in the game since she is practically telling us that she will be evil later...

Pappy, what makes you think a game moderator would write up a description - specifically - that reveals to everyone in the game that someone actually protected themself that night?

That would be totally unfair to the player in that power role to deliberately do that to them in the game thread.

It would also reveal to the scum the identity of that PR who could otherwise remain anonymous if they so choose.

And that defeats the purpose of allowing a PR to self-protect at all if they're just going to set themselves up by having that announced by the mod in clear terms.

 

[jpappy789]

Razz-4
Chill-5
Rich-5
Bally-3
UN-8
Wizard-6
Kash-8
Hay-3
Pap-10
Noods-5
Ninja-5


My list...I guess I'm opposite of everyone else since 1= scum, 10 = innocent...I don't have any read at all on any of the unknown vets, which kinda worries me to be honest.

 

[jpappy789]

Pappy, what makes you think a game moderator would write up a description - specifically - that reveals to everyone in the game that someone actually protected themself that night?

That would be totally unfair to the player in that power role to deliberately do that to them in the game thread.

It would also reveal to the scum the identity of that PR who could otherwise remain anonymous if they so choose.

And that defeats the purpose of allowing a PR to self-protect at all if they're just going to set themselves up by having that announced by the mod in clear terms.

Good point.

But do you not see why that would cause some concern?

 

[noodles62]

Excellent points Wiz! :clap:





Thoughts on Bally's stance - which I completely agree with. If you are indeed innocent why would you just give up and let the scum win? I have made amny mistakes in these games (trust me!) but giving up is not a good sign....I feel pretty good with my vote where it is for now....



Kashta, wow! just wow! I just skimmed your post so I did not lose my train of thought on the above posts. I will come back with my thoughts on that in a bit......

oops! amny = many!

 

[Kashta]

Good point.

But do you not see why that would cause some concern?

Yes, of course. That was a good question to ask, albeit...... a surprising one, as you often you've modded mafia games yourself.

That isn't something I expected you (in particular) would even wonder about -- much less ask -- with your experience as game moderator.

 

[Kashta]

Yes, of course. That was a good question to ask, albeit...... a surprising one, as you often you've modded mafia games yourself.

That isn't something I expected you (in particular) would even wonder about -- much less ask -- with your experience as game moderator.

Sorry for the typo. Let's make this read:

...as many times as you've modded mafia games yourself.

 

[Kashta]

Not like Kashta to RC though, she doesn't care for it and has said many times in the past how it can often screw up a game.

Although I can see your point about the write up of the protection, I don't see Kashta making a false RC either. I will trust her today but not Monday.

Very true. I'd sooner eat gum off the sidewalk than role claim to save myself or any of the usual lame-arse reasons (IMO) why players often do it.

Please refer back to the reasoning I stated in the post I made for the reasons I chose to do it this time.

 

[noodles62]

Making their way way back to their rooms, as one turns down the hall they feel a push from behind, as they fall over the banister looking up they recognize the face that has pushed them over. Screaming as they fall they see the person’s form turn into an orb flying off, then they feel arms wrap around them. Looking up as a smile spreads across the face of the one holding them....you are safe for tonight I have protected you

Pappy, what makes you think a game moderator would write up a description - specifically - that reveals to everyone in the game that someone actually protected themself that night?

That would be totally unfair to the player in that power role to deliberately do that to them in the game thread.

It would also reveal to the scum the identity of that PR who could otherwise remain anonymous if they so choose.

And that defeats the purpose of allowing a PR to self-protect at all if they're just going to set themselves up by having that announced by the mod in clear terms.

I am not seeing how the LG's write up hints or "specifically" reveals that you protected yourself, but that is probably why I do not excel at these games! LOL But, I am willing to take a chance & believe you at this point. How can we use this info to help us root out the scum?