Mafia 81: The Bloody Coup

[Kashta]

I tend to not read THAT far into things...my only concern Kash is that you shrug off the fact that Noods wouldn't do that when innocent. Can an innocent not poke fun at another player during the beginning of D1? I don't see how she is trying to throw you off without jumping to the conclusion itself. I just see a quick one liner when there was some conversation earlier about RL excuses...then pizza...then football.

To me it doesn't look like the remark was in anyway directed at you personally. The joke involved you, yes, but that is different.

Again, Pappy... that's the whole point. As an innocent, Noods would've just been making a joke like anyone else might do. But in that case, she would've just said so... then possibily wondered why I made a big deal over nothing because she's just an innocent who was goofing around.

I waited to see how Noods would respond. Had she said that (which I expected she would), then I would have been satisfied that she was telling the truth and let it go.

Look back at her answer to me, though. It's actually more interesting than the original question... so I now think there is something more to this in her case, hence now deciding to vote her instead of dropping it.

 

[Lady G]

I didn't see it as sarcasm at all...I saw it as a hypothetical conversation between you and a scum teammate.


It was the only thing I saw at the time I voted that even remotely made sense for a vote. With that said FF doesn't need any help "going all ranty and crazy." He's pretty good at it all on his own. It was an attempt to get this game moving to actual game play rather than pizza topping discussions. So I threw a vote out to get people talking about it. We do have to lynch someone tomorrow so we need to get some more substance. Not to mention FF still needs to be reminded when he screws up. He still quite often forgets to think before he types. If he is an innocent typing without thinking doesn't help the Town. If he is scum he should continue to type without thinking.



I do agree with Kash's comments about a scum possibly missing on the numbers of scum in the game to try and throw people off their trail. It is a good observation IMO.

Opps left my comments off in the last post.

So why did you feel the "need" to vote at the time though? Yes, he does need to be reminded, but the vote just seems a little overboard at this point in time...more like someone trying to get something started IMO

As far as Kash's comment being a "good observation" well, really that could go either way..are ya trying to get on her good side?

 

[Kashta]

Ok, I can see your point...but would note it more as something to watch not really as "scummy" at this point, simply because she usually does state "silly" stuff and I've seen her do it (carry over from other games) as many players do.

That's what I was going to do, Lady G... I considered it was something to watch that didn't necessarily mean anything. But this depended on how Noods responded, which she since has.

Yeah, that was a nice try, but it was also a crap answer. I don't think it's the real truth here.... so Noods drew my vote after all.

 

[Lady G]

Here we go again, is FF scum or his he doing a patented FF?

Does the speculating on numbers prove anything? It is a usual day one topic?

With Ice as mod I am surprised at the modest amount of posting about Ice having fun assigning roles. He could make some interesting teams with this crowd.

I will just say right now, I will not be playing any part in trying to figure out who Ice would put in what role...BIG waste of time and energy IMO. Why would you even want to start that?

That is in reference to the last bloody coup game when I was actually scum (CIA). 2H said that I said there weren't four of us (CIA) in that game when all I said was I remember there being at least 3.

Ok, thank you for the answer

 

[jpappy789]

Look back at her answer to me, though. It's actually more interesting than the original question... so I now think there is something more to this in her case, hence now deciding to vote her instead of dropping it.

I do see your point. Although I am not sold on the idea, especially since making a deal out of it in the first place makes me uneasy about you.

 

[noodles62]

wow! Kashta my initial comment about not posting about RL was an attempt at sarcastic humor - note the little smiley face? If you truly feel that you can disect it to find more then that, then go for it. Yes, it was referring to the last game, and to be honest when you made that comment to me last game I took it seriously and made a promise to myself to not post my comings and going in the game any longer. If that is scummy...well, let's just say it leaves me scratching my head.

 

[noodles62]

g//o
ok - I know I told myself to cease and desist the RL posts in the game, but I just found out some bad news and I need to vent - like it or not, I consider you all friends so you get to hear it anyway!

......a good friend back in Idaho was just diagnosed with Melanoma. She goes in for her first surgery on Thursday.........


g//o

 

[IceH2O]

Ice, can you clarify that "half" the players are rebels?

Not exactly half since there are 17 players but pretty darn close.

 

[IceH2O]

Votes so far


FF- Dawg(128)

2H- Pir(173)

Noods- Kash(175}

 

[Lady G]

g//o
ok - I know I told myself to cease and desist the RL posts in the game, but I just found out some bad news and I need to vent - like it or not, I consider you all friends so you get to hear it anyway!

......a good friend back in Idaho was just diagnosed with Melanoma. She goes in for her first surgery on Thursday.........


g//o

Sorry to hear that Noods, you know my PM box is always open if ya need to just talk or anything...you also know me on facebook, send me msg's anytime you need *hugs*

Not exactly half since there are 17 players but pretty darn close.

What you couldn't make one person half bad, half good?