Mafia 87: The Play, Basic Game

[Ninja Pigs Rock]

Good job town, I'm thrilled to see that went our way.

mhm. so your saying FF was typing while you were typing so it took you 4 minutes to type the quote above. im not buying that.

 

[Ninja Pigs Rock]

willard
2H
ninja
pir
Bally
Zaff
LG

I think this is the remaining players

woops take LG out of that list

 

[TwoHobbies]

Bit defensive of Rich, maybe?

Sees that his team-mate is about to get lynched, decides to seal the deal so he looks un-scummy. I believe I recall someone riding my back about voting late... hmm...

DEFENSIVE of Rich !!!!! Did you read any of the posts from today. Actually I was feeling out Bally. I haven't exactly cleared her yet.

My TEAM-MATE. That's what you got from that. Can you play this game just a little please. I posted before 10 am (that's morning Pir) that I would be the kill vote when Rich got 4 votes.

 

[TwoHobbies]

mhm. so your saying FF was typing while you were typing so it took you 4 minutes to type the quote above. im not buying that.

Actually there were a lot of post since I got back from happy hour and I was quite fired up about PIR's post. I had typed up a response to him, but erased it and thought I should comment on Rich being scum first.

I'm not surprised your not buying it, I mean lets face it so far you've been dead on all game!

 

[Piranha86]

This is definitely something interesting to look at. Although, I would suspect that the scum team would have this conversation with the scum team in the scum den rather than out in the open. Unless FF doesn't have access to the den.

Will have to check back and see if there's anything else that links pir to rich.

I don't want people to UD. It's just a stupid way to go. Nuff said. And LMK if you find anything b/t me and Rcih.

I'm confused. i now believe that there are 2 people left in the scum den. those being bally and 2H

IMO there's no way that there was a 4 person scum team at the beginning. The standard is 25% of the total number of players (sometimes less than that). Any more, and it's a huge domination. I'm really not understanding the case on Bally... 2H, I obviously understand.

DEFENSIVE of Rich !!!!! Did you read any of the posts from today. Actually I was feeling out Bally. I haven't exactly cleared her yet.

My TEAM-MATE. That's what you got from that. Can you play this game just a little please. I posted before 10 am (that's morning Pir) that I would be the kill vote when Rich got 4 votes.

Well, you defended him right before you voted him. You're starting to be very contradictory, and that worries me. AND WHAT HAPPENED TO LAST-MINUTE VOTES BEING BAD?!?

 

[Piranha86]

Good job town, I'm thrilled to see that went our way.

Wait, was this an RC?

 

[TwoHobbies]

Well, you defended him right before you voted him. You're starting to be very contradictory, and that worries me. AND WHAT HAPPENED TO LAST-MINUTE VOTES BEING BAD?!?

Ok...at this point I don't know if I'm not being clear, or your just being difficult. Re-read what was said today, and question me again tomorrow.

 

[Piranha86]

Ok...at this point I don't know if I'm not being clear, or your just being difficult. Re-read what was said today, and question me again tomorrow.

I read through everything... Still don't see which part you're talking about.

So, it looks like I logged off a little early last night, and missed the hit.

Based on the rules and the order of nightfall, I thought the hit came after the lynch. Ah well.... it is a FF game. Expect the unusual.

So at 10:30 FF tells everyone the evils can hit whenever they want and it will go though as soon as he see's it. At 10:40 Rich votes Haydn, and twenty minutes later the scum hit Haydn.

That changes my top three.

Rich: Either someone wanted to set you up, or you wanted to say "why would I hit my vote" I'll place the lynch vote if you get one more.

Well, Bally was also posting around that time, not that we should be limiting the hit to those that were posting then.
Point is we need to lynch someone. I'm all for lynching those playing innocent, but having "off" games.
The obvious (to me) hit would have been G, Zaf, or Rich. I already was uneasy of Rich, and with him having three votes!!!
Regardless of who pulled the hit it was well played. We all get to tell them great play after the game's over.

I'll continue on with my (now) second choice.
For everything already posted and this.



2-7-11 8:22
FF tells everyone he will not count Tanks vote unless he bolds it.



2-7-11 8:23
User asks FF if he will count the vote anyway.
FF again says no.



2-7-11 8:48
Pir asks for a replacement player.
Timing on this request was strange because Tank still had 10 minutes to jump in and bold his vote. Sure seems to me like Pir knew that wasn't going to happen.
Did Tank mention in the den that he wouldn't be around for nightfall, because I don't remember him saying that in the thread?

G: You know the mod talks in the den, and even if he didn't tell them there he posted it in the thread right here.

No Bally, I guess that wasn't worded clearly. What I meant was the obvious scum hit I thought would have been one of those three.

Other than Zaf's late vote switch night one, I don't really have a problem with his game play thus far. In fairness though I've played many more games with Rich than Zaffy.

What's your take on the scum hit last night?

G/O Congrats on the "A" G/O

Very funny Rich, nice twist. So of the two of us who had there vote on a known innocent the last two days? :nono:
What I told G was that we have to vote someone, and if it's an innocent at least lets vote one who isn't helping the town.

And just for the record Scum don't get scum scales! :laugh:

Come on now Rich, you don't have everyones respect here as a great Mafia player by jumping on things like that. It's for things like the hit on Hayden!

FF:
Post 372, Ladg G retracted.

You don't think it could be a setup?

What !??!!..She retracted on Rich also. Come on, I even listed the post number.

Well Rich, if you were setup Zaffy's going to look guilty to me, but I don't think you were.

I VOTE TO LYNCH RICH

Well I'm going to go hit "happy hour"

Guess I'll just cross my fingers and hope that Zaffy isn't playing us, while we wait for FF to call night fall.

Good job town, I'm thrilled to see that went our way.

Ahhh crap, and just when I was feeling good about today.

We'll still bring this one home for you G.

Sorry zaffy...I was typing while FF was. I hope it was pretty clear I thought G was innocent.

DEFENSIVE of Rich !!!!! Did you read any of the posts from today. Actually I was feeling out Bally. I haven't exactly cleared her yet.

My TEAM-MATE. That's what you got from that. Can you play this game just a little please. I posted before 10 am (that's morning Pir) that I would be the kill vote when Rich got 4 votes.

Actually there were a lot of post since I got back from happy hour and I was quite fired up about PIR's post. I had typed up a response to him, but erased it and thought I should comment on Rich being scum first.

I'm not surprised your not buying it, I mean lets face it so far you've been dead on all game!

Still not seeing it...

 

[Willard2.0]

Good job town, I'm thrilled to see that went our way.

Are you turning into UN??? :grinyes:

So, clearly LG was being sincere. not trying to set anyone up. Rich can't be trusted. I want some of what NPR is having...

What do you mean by that? Are you meaning that NPR is playing good? Or are you meaning that no one is interrogating him?

@Pir: :lol:

 

[Zaffy]

Starting at your vote.

If you think you have evidence against someone why hide it? It is very counter productive, especially with a majority vote based nightfall. Is there a reason you want this day to last a long time?

I have a HUGE genetics test in the am that I need to finish studying for so I will vote now. Because of blatant refusal to help the town, by not going back to pull posts or provide anything more than his "feeling", I vote to lynch Rich.

I will be back if I can but I HAVE to have an A on this test.

UN please....just shut up.


Rich at said that he believed that Zaffy was not playing his usual game and you say that you would hit players having an off game and then list Zaffy among them. Do you agree with Rich about Zaffy?



I think I made a 92% on my test, not that great of an A but I'll take it!! :dance:

I agree!

This feels helpful, but it could also be planting a seed of doubt in someone who was going pretty hard against scum.

:woot:Congratulations!!:woot:

I was not expecting to come back to the thread and see the hit. I think that it should have happened at the nightfall, or have been more specific in the rules.

I find it convienent for those who are building a case on Rich that hit vote happened at 10:39pm and the hit was posted at 11:00pm on the person that he voted for and then the hit is being used as evidence of him being scum. It seems too coincidental that the hit went in on the person he voted for so quickly after his vote was posted.



I assume that is why her name is in red.

I think this is pretty much a defense of Rich. Saying that the hit was an attempt to set him up. I think it's an attempt to seed more doubt.

I do think it could be a set up, as to who is being set up I don't know.

I see what you're saying on the vote, my bad

Backpedaling, it's looking like the heat on Rich isn't fading.

Ok Bally, because it looked like you were trying to pull people away from voting Rich to me by bringing out how "convenient" the timing was....yet you were voting him.

I think Lady G said it best.

Also, you were #2 on him, which is the best place to hide according to Rich. By the time others piled on, you had no choice but to stay. Rich took one for the team.

What say ye?:hitting: