![[AC] Tree_Hugger](/forums/data/avatars/s/83/83028.jpg?1431345517){kind=avatar}
Mafia 88: Insane Asylum (Game Thread)
- Thread starter Madcrawdad
- Start date
![[AC] RICKETS](/forums/data/avatars/s/83/83432.jpg?1431345517){kind=avatar}
since it was basically a two man race day 1, when people were voting based on silly things, I think it's the most valuable vote to study. We knew HH was Mafia but we didn't know if Nem was also mafia or innocent. I will admit the info was more valuable if Nem was scum also, but I think the votes as they are make Narwhal and the singleton votes look scummy. (Yes I realize I was one of them) I plan to go back into that in more depth later today.[AC] Tree_Hugger;2592450 said:
And you are correct, my tracking result are of no help to the town at this time.
That right there is a frustrated scum tell if there ever was one. I understand it is late, then just go to bed. But the "woah is the town that lynches me" line is tried and true scum fodder.[AC] scoop411;2592461 said:
![[AC] narwhal](/forums/data/avatars/s/83/83431.jpg?1431345517){kind=avatar}
[AC] RICKETS;2592380 said:
[AC] RICKETS;2592586 said:
I really hate coming back to this, but you keep bringing it up.
Before my vote, it was 4-3 with Nem in the lead. My vote caused a tie 4-4 (which is apparently what you think is scummy, me causing a tie. Is that correct?). Then HI IQ puts Nem back in the lead, 5-4. Almost immediately Goldleader ties it up at 5-5 (again, scummy move). Nem moves his vote making it 6-5 for HH. Mael and Tree both pile on at the end. Mael was trying to vote HH before Tree did, but was having technical difficulties (as pointed out by others). I would place Maels vote at 7th and trees at 8th because of that, even though mael didn't get through until after tree.
To me, it's those two pile on votes that look scummy, particularly Tree. If tree had seen that mael was trying to vote to make it 7-5, then tree would have known that it's a lost cause and jumping on HH to lynch scum could have been a smoke screen.
On the other hand, mael could have attempted to try and save HH by voting Nem and trying it again at 6-6, but that is a gutsy move because nightfall was approaching at that point.
I'm totally with you on the singleton votes though.
![[AC] UhOhChongo](/forums/data/avatars/s/83/83903.jpg?1431345518){kind=avatar}
I just skimmed through what happened after I left last night and don't have much time. I need to do some digging to reconcile Rick's RC in my own mind. There are the points I have made pre-nightfall, but I have seen a few things to make me think otherwise. I don't expect to be able to get on long enough to do the digging today it will have to wait until I get home.
One of the biggest problems I have was your "attempt to draw the hit" with the way you posted. (and your choice of timing to do it) That early in the game with the number of players we had it wasn't likely that scum would have found a PR yet.
If you could explain to me your thought process through this it would be appreciated and aid in my own checking.
One of the biggest problems I have was your "attempt to draw the hit" with the way you posted. (and your choice of timing to do it) That early in the game with the number of players we had it wasn't likely that scum would have found a PR yet.
If you could explain to me your thought process through this it would be appreciated and aid in my own checking.
Narwhal: Sorry it's just my opinion that the timing of your tie vote is pecular. even on Day 1 a scum voting for their team mate to distance themselves is a common practice in my experience.
UhOh: Random votes still kill PRs. Bad innocents are great for scum as they can draw a lynch away from them. So they won't hit innocents that the town already suspects. I was trying to be a suspect without being a top suspect, which worked until last night.
UhOh: Random votes still kill PRs. Bad innocents are great for scum as they can draw a lynch away from them. So they won't hit innocents that the town already suspects. I was trying to be a suspect without being a top suspect, which worked until last night.
Only 6 posts since I left this morning? The Town cannot win with low participation like this. My gut tells me to vote for Scoop or Driver based on how they saw the RC. But we need more input from the Town to make our best decision.
I'm not following your second paragraph there if you could clarify that. I know the question isn't for me but would still like to understand your logic.[AC] UhOhChongo;2592651 said:
![[AC] Old3Toes](/forums/data/avatars/s/83/83908.jpg?1431345518){kind=avatar}
[AC] Tiburon321;2592372 said:
I am just getting caught up on the game. Good job on getting BH and I think that it can be deemed that Rickets is the tracker. I think the above statement about me can be a little misleading. I was not voting with BH. My vote on Driver8 has nothing to do with BH. Driver8 is still my top suspect and would like to see him lynched. I need to arrange my suspect list. I also am suspect of those that do not believe Rickets is the tracker without an alternative. I am also suprised that I was the first one Rickets tracked.
