Mafia 9: The Bloody Coup

[Hooked Newbie]

I am going to make a list of who is voting who so far and the suspects listed by them. If I make ANY mistakes please say so, so they can be corrected.

Ogre-Votes DD, names HN LG & CL
HN- Votes DC, names nobody else
Z-Votes Sploke, names Sov, Ogre, Jpap, DC, Bkw,CL & JL
CL-Votes Ogre
DD-Votes Ogre
Bkw- Votes Ogre, names JL, CL,
DC Votes Ogre
JL-Votes Ogre
KOTD- Votes DC
RB- Votes Ogre
Jpap-Votes DC, names Sploke, CL, Ogre & Z
Sploke Votes Ogre
LG-Votes Ogre, names Jpap, HN, CL,KOTD, DD
Now unless someone posted while I was typing this it should be up to date.

Interesting that you only include this bullet (bolded above) next to my name... what of the others that named no one? There are several (including deputy) that have never really offered any lists. I have named others consistently (post 781 for instance) and last night (forget post number). You seem to be casting a wide net and voting for someone you know is not at risk tonight.

Z-Votes Sploke, names Sov, Ogre, Jpap, DC, Bkw,CL & JL

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Interesting that you only include this bullet (bolded above) next to my name... what of the others that named no one? There are several (including deputy) that have never really offered any lists. I have named others consistently (post 781 for instance) and last night (forget post number). You seem to be casting a wide net and voting for someone you know is not at risk tonight.

Z-Votes Sploke, names Sov, Ogre, Jpap, DC, Bkw,CL & JL

Oops... thought Z wrote that. Same observations apply, but please insert "Z" where ever I stated "you".

 

[Lady G]

like i said..i dont like posts where people know why someone cant be posting all the time..and they call that person out for "not posting enough", if this was happening with anyone else i'd say the same thing..its not just because it's ogre..it gets me mad when people think you need to be posting here every second, especially when you have a fairly good reason/s not to

and no i did not "pop" up saying he wasn't a rebel "before" i mentioned something yesterday about it, that was the first time..AND..i never said he wasn't a rebel..i dont know what he is..but the only reason people seem to be voting for him is lack of posting if there is a better reason i would love to read it...if he is lynched and found to be a rebel..GREAT!, but i need something better to go on other than lack of posts before i vote for him.

the whole point is, i do not think we should be so quick to lynch someone because s/he has not been posting much, we've been doing that a lot lately especially in these last two games, i was lynched last game because i was not posting much due to my grandparents needing me, and charlie this game..he wasnt posting like crazy and he was taken out and found to be a CC.

if we are going to lynch someone we need a good reason, we need to be confident that that person may be a rebel..especially now that there are only 6 of us left..

and yes i know my name will now be tied to him if he turns out to be a rebel, but like i said..you all will know what i am sooner or later.

here's my list as of right now

deputy - stated my reasons in an above post
CL - slips under the radar, seems to only post after a lynching..
rb - unsure if him yet, but something about him isn't sitting right with me
ogre - ogre is named here because of whats going on right now, he is somewhat suspicious, but so is everyone else..there is a 50/50 chance he is a rebel, and if someone can convince me that he is, he'll move up.

Ok, you say you would do the same for anyone else...you never mentioned Sploke has a new baby and may have a hard time posting when it was mentioned he isn't posting much?
Then you say you only made one comment about Orge (no you didn't say he was/wasn't rebel) but I found at least 3 post where you came in posting about Orge after someone said they think he is suspicious.

yeah..because starting a school year and being at home with an infant really gives you free time to waste posting here..

and no im not defending him..i just hate when these types of posts pop up when it is already clear why the person can not post ALL the time, like i've said earlier..lack of posting does not always mean you are a bad guy..we should all know that by now..i DO NOT think lynching ogre simply because he has been busy is a smart move at all, i have yet to see one good case against him..someone convince me that he is a rebel and i will vote for him..but if there is nothing but the fact that he has not been posting like a madman..i'll pass

with that

i vote to lynch deputy he seems to slip under the radar quite a bit, his posts have also been pretty much non-existant..and there are a few good cases against him..

unless something else pops up with ogre, or anyone else..this vote stays

Hmmm interesting here you want to Lynch deputy b/c his post have been pretty much non-existent? How contridictory or is that just me?

i dont really see why people are voting ogre..is it because he's posting a bit differently? or is there something i've missed?

after reading through the posts..i want to stay with the second person on my list..which is mee-mee..i get a bad vibe from here..she's really defensive this round, something i have not seen much in previous games...

i vote to lynch mee-mee

has everyone forgotten that he has a baby to look after? and wasn't there a threat of a big storm where he is?

So KOTD, you have said something on more than 1 occasion here AND you are voting someone for thier "non existent post" something you say we SHOULD NOT do??..just wanted to point that out

 

[Lady G]

Interesting that you only include this bullet (bolded above) next to my name... what of the others that named no one? There are several (including deputy) that have never really offered any lists. I have named others consistently (post 781 for instance) and last night (forget post number). You seem to be casting a wide net and voting for someone you know is not at risk tonight.

Z-Votes Sploke, names Sov, Ogre, Jpap, DC, Bkw,CL & JL

OMG, I'm sorry...plz no one take that into consideration...that was a TOTAL typo, I had included the "names nobody else" after everyone who did that then decided NOT to include that part I thought I deleted it off of everyone...let me see if I can still edit it if I can I will. I do APOLIGIZE, really that wasn't meant to me like that.

 

[Lady G]

Ok I was able to edit...I am sorry it was not meant to be there and NO ONE use that for a reason for/against your vote to HN.

 

[johnlarson66]

I hope you're right. Any rebel gone tonight is a good thing, but I think an FBI rebel would be even better than a CIA rebel at this point because of the numbers. I agree that there are multiple rebels voting for Ogre right now, that's obvious. There could just as easily be individual rebels voting for no one that has a chance though. From the last vote count, that would leave you and Ogre.

Sploke - 1 - Zsand 734

DD - 1 - Ogre 732

I'm not accusing, I'm questioning. Right now, no one is a glaring innocent to me. I know what I am, but have no solid ideas on others. It's easier for me to be suspicious and find rebels than identify innocents.

I agree that any rebel gone tonight is a good thing.

I totally disagree that it is better to lynch a FBI instead of a CIA. If we can lynch all three of the CIA, then they have no night time hit. If the FBI can hit one for us, that is even better. If the CIA can hit one of the FBI for us, still even better.

I do not think we should really care what group the rebel is with. If I had to choose, I would say that Ogre is CIA, but it does not matter if he is FBI, either way I think he is a rebel.

As far as the other suspects are, I will see what happens. There seem to be a few that have attempted to come to Ogre's defense, if Ogre is rebel, most likely they are also.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

I agree that any rebel gone tonight is a good thing.

I totally disagree that it is better to lynch a FBI instead of a CIA. If we can lynch all three of the CIA, then they have no night time hit. If the FBI can hit one for us, that is even better. If the CIA can hit one of the FBI for us, still even better.

I do not think we should really care what group the rebel is with. If I had to choose, I would say that Ogre is CIA, but it does not matter if he is FBI, either way I think he is a rebel.

As far as the other suspects are, I will see what happens. There seem to be a few that have attempted to come to Ogre's defense, if Ogre is rebel, most likely they are also.

I'm confused (figure of speech, not an "I don't get it post)... how can we possibly lynch or get 3 in one night? If a CC is hit tonight, the FBI has an equal number to us and can render our votes moot. Eliminating one group entirely would be good, but remember that each group submits a hit and an investigation (if they choose to). So with one group gone the other could probably just submit hits against CCs since there will be no unknown rebel variable at that point. If they have a numbers advantage at that point, we're done.

 

[Lady G]

I don't know if anyone else has noticed this or if it matters to others...but Orge was the only one Voting for Charlie (yes CS was on others watch lists) He did not switch to MM until AFTER Charlie died...just seems a little odd to me, any other opinions on this?

 

[Lady G]

I'm confused (figure of speech, not an "I don't get it post)... how can we possibly lynch or get 3 in one night? If a CC is hit tonight, the FBI has an equal number to us and can render our votes moot. Eliminating one group entirely would be good, but remember that each group submits a hit and an investigation (if they choose to). So with one group gone the other could probably just submit hits against CCs since there will be no unknown rebel variable at that point. If they have a numbers advantage at that point, we're done.

IMO it would be better to lynch a FBI simply because they have more either would be great..but if we get FBI their number will drop at least with both neither is garenteed a "hit" if we take out ALL the CIA (which in the end we need to) then the FBI get a free shot EVERY night to take out a CC at least with a couple of the CIA in there they wont be sure if they are hitting CC or CIA until the hit goes through and hopefully they would hit a CIA.
I do not think MM and Ogre were same team...if Ogre is rebel. My suspecions are KOTD and Orge are playing together and I THINK they are most likely FBI since MM ended up being CIA. This is just what I am leaning toward.

 

[ZSandmann]

I hope you're right. Any rebel gone tonight is a good thing, but I think an FBI rebel would be even better than a CIA rebel at this point because of the numbers. I agree that there are multiple rebels voting for Ogre right now, that's obvious. There could just as easily be individual rebels voting for no one that has a chance though. From the last vote count, that would leave you and Ogre.

Sploke - 1 - Zsand 734

DD - 1 - Ogre 732

I'm not accusing, I'm questioning. Right now, no one is a glaring innocent to me. I know what I am, but have no solid ideas on others. It's easier for me to be suspicious and find rebels than identify innocents.

But couldn't the same be said for the three votes on DC? And to be fair I voted for Sploke before the Ogre train started up. But I understand your concern, at this point however, changing my vote would only make people accuse me of being a jumper. I voted early and I'll stick with it for today.